Government Crackdown

So what is this new Food and Drug Administration (FDA) rule and how is it going to stop kids from smoking?
First, it will force merchants to be more careful about who they sell cigarettes to. It’s already illegal for people under 18 to buy cigarettes but, of course, a lot of kids pass for over 18 when they’re not. The new rule requires merchants to ask for photo ID from anyone who looks to be under 27.
Carded at the Corner Deli
Is the guy at the corner deli where you buy your cigs going to card you the next time you go into the store? Probably not, but he’s supposed to. Whether this part of the rule has any impact depends on how well it’s enforced. If merchants who don’t card people are fined or banned from selling cigarettes, it could make a difference.
Next, the sale of single cigarettes and the distribution of free cigarette samples will be banned. I think this provision has absolutely no bearing on kids. I mean, what is it saying? That you’re going to have to buy the whole pack if you want to smoke? And how often do kids get their first smokes from a free sample anyway?
Cigarette Machines for Adults Only
The third big part of the rule calls for the removal of cigarette vending machines and self-service displays in places where children are allowed. In other words, you’re only going to find cigarette machines in “adults-only” places (bars, clubs, etc.). I think this is a good idea and will actually be quite effective in reducing children’s exposure to tobacco products.
The other provisions aren’t directed at consumers, but at the tobacco companies. They’re designed to restrict cigarette advertising that’s targeted to kids.
Cutting Down the Colorful Advertising
Basically, the companies will no longer be allowed to have billboards within 1,000 feet of schools or playgrounds, and all other advertising in public places that kids have access to (billboards in other locations, posters in stores, subways, and buses) will be limited to black and white text only. That means no more photographs of people smoking and having a great time and no more cartoon characters like Joe Camel. The “black and white, text only” rule will also apply to ads in magazines with a large youth readership.
Cigarette companies will also be prohibited from giving out self-promoting products like bags and clothes with their brand’s logo or name on them and from using cigarette brand names to sponsor sporting or entertainment events (that means that Marlboro won’t be able to sponsor the World Cup, but Philip Morris, its umbrella corporation, still can.)
The FDA will be giving businesses between six months and two years to adapt to meet these new requirements.
Kids Buy Joe Camel
Now, I’m sure some of you are thinking that the government has gone overboard with these rules and regulations, especially the ones about advertising. “How can Joe Camel actually have an effect on whether kids smoke?” you’re probably thinking. “He’s a camel with a leather jacket, for goodness sake!”
Well, I would have agreed with you until I heard about the results of two research studies about kids and smoking:one found that 30% of 3-year-olds and 91% of 6-year-olds can identify “Joe Camel” as a symbol of smoking and the other found that 86 % of underage smokers buy one of the three most heavily advertised brands. These studies convinced me that advertising does affect when and what kids smoke.
If You’re Over 18, It’s Up to You
For those of you who are old enough to smoke legally, rest assured, you will still be able to buy cigarettes and smokeless tobacco products. If you’re over 18 and want to smoke, the government won’t be stopping you. Sure, you may feel like you’re becoming a social pariah (if your friends and family are constantly telling you to quit or you find yourself being banned from restaurants and other public places), but as long as you’re an adult, it is still your prerogative to smoke.

SIDEBAR: Get Tougher
While I think the new FDA rule is a nice start, I would actually like to see the government make a greater effort to curb teenage smoking. To me, the president’s program is only the first step. There should be many more reforms to come. For example, I would like to see smoking banned in and around schools. I know that smoking is probably against the rules in most schools already, but we all know there are people who smoke in the bathrooms and stairwells.
Suspend Student Smokers
I would propose that cameras be installed in these areas and kids who are caught smoking be suspended and required to kick the habit before returning to school. I know this is an immense demand, but if it were strictly enforced, we would find fewer kids smoking. Sure, I understand that quitting isn’t that easy and that some kids would probably drop out of school before doing it, but every new idea has its snags. Maybe there’s a way to create alternative programs where teen smokers can go to class while also getting help kicking their habit. Another idea I have is to force merchants who sell cigarettes to minors to pay a tax on their earnings which would go directly to programs which get kids to quit, like the school idea I just proposed.
Fine the Tobacco Companies
I also think the cigarette manufacturers should be held just as accountable as the merchants for the illegal sale of their products. I refuse to believe that a company as large and powerful as Philip Morris cannot have any influence over the people who sell its products. If the tobacco companies discouraged vendors from selling their products to minors, it could make a real difference. If they continue looking the other way, they should be held just as liable for breaking the law as the merchants. While store owners who sell to minors should lose their cigarette licenses or be required to pay a heavy fine, cigarette manufacturers should also be subject to fines and be at-risk of losing all advertising privileges in the future. A Sick Source of Profits And, in case you’re wondering why I specifically mentioned Philip Morris and not another cigarette manufacturer, I have a good reason. Just recently, it got into the news that an internal company memo from the early 1980s stated that Philip Morris would be one of the companies most affected by a decrease in the number of younger smokers. Why, I wondered, should they be affected at all if young people aren’t supposed to be able buy their cigarettes in the first place? To me, that just proves that cigarette companies count on kids to buy their products and specifically target them in their advertising campaigns. This is the same Philip Morris which launched a huge ad campaign earlier this year to tell Americans that it had never tried to get young people to smoke. I honestly believed that. But not anymore. Now, I see that smoking will always be just a matter of dollars and cents to these people. Nothing more.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.