No matter how much we all like to think we’re different, sometimes we just want to be part of a group. Say you’re hanging out with your friends and someone says that “only an idiot” could like the boring book you’re reading in English class. Even though you like the book, you just look down at the floor because you’re afraid to look stupid in front of your friends.
Or you overhear a group of kids make fun of someone you know for not wearing name-brand clothes. You think it’s wrong to judge him by that but pretend not to notice, thinking, “Why should I get involved?”
It’s hard to speak up against something everyone else seems to agree with. And it’s a thousand times harder when your life is at stake.
That’s what happens in the new movie, The Crucible. It takes place in the 1600s, in a small, peaceful village called Salem that’s surrounded by woods and populated by Puritans. One night a group of teenaged girls are caught dancing around a fire in the woods-something that’s forbidden among these very religious people, most of whom are farmers. One of the girls is Abigail Williams (Winona Ryder), a forceful, confident girl who is used to getting what she wants.
A Chain of Accusations
Afraid that she might be punished, Abigail accuses a woman who was with them in the woods of making her dance against her will by casting spells on her. The woman is beaten until she finally confesses to being a witch (she isn’t) and even though they know it isn’t true, the other girls decide to go along with Abigail’s story rather than risk being accused themselves. That decision almost leads to the destruction of the entire village.
Shortly after that, Abigail goes on to accuse the wife of a man named John Proctor (Daniel Day-Lewis) who she is secretly in love with. Soon, the other girls start making up stories about people putting curses on them, making them sick and forcing them to do things against their will.
No One is Safe
Before long, no one in the village is safe. Neighbors, friends, people who have known each other for years start suspecting each other of being possessed by the Devil. Those who do not admit to being witches are hanged, and those who plead guilty are put in prison. John Proctor, a man respected for his honesty and integrity, is the only one besides Abigail and the other girls who knows the truth. But he keeps his mouth shut as people he knows are innocent are condemned to death.
Watching the movie, you get a feeling that the whole world has gone mad. Everyone is running and screaming, afraid of every little sound. They can’t think of anything but the Devil.
The trials are held in the town church before a panel of three judges, with the whole village present. When one of the women is suspected of being a witch because she predicted that her neighbor’s pigs would die, one of the judges asks her how she knew that was going to happen. “I raised pigs all my life,” she tells him. “If they are not fed properly, they die.”
Hanged for Stating the Obvious
“But you predicted that,” he says, implying that this proves her supernatural powers. The people start cheering and the woman is eventually hanged.
What’s really scary is the fact that no one says a word in the woman’s defense. Educated people sit there listening to these absurd accusations and the most anyone ever does is get up and leave in the middle of one of the trials. One of the people who does that is herself accused and executed.
During one of the executions, some people in the crowd are crying and, looking in their eyes, you can tell that they don’t believe the accused deserve to be hanged. But they just stand there like little scared children, wiping their tears.
I can’t really blame them. I don’t know what I would do if I were in their place. It’s easy to say from the comfort of your own home that you’ll stand up for what you believe in, no matter what might be done to you or your family, but it’s a lot harder when it actually happens.
Dying for the Truth
There are a few people in the movie who refuse to “confess” even when they’re beaten and tortured. Ironically, one of them is John Proctor, who, after his own wife is accused, finally goes to the judge with one of the original group of girls and tells him that Abigail and the others have been lying all along. When the judge doesn’t believe them, the girl turns around and accuses Proctor of witchcraft as well.
Out of a whole village, only a few have the courage to die rather than say they’re witches. In all honesty, I don’t think I could do that. Why should I die because of something I didn’t do?
The Crucible is great at showing how human beings can be blinded by the mass insanity of a witch-hunt, and how some of us will even take advantage of events like these to get back at people we don’t like.
A Part That Doesn’t Fit
The one thing I didn’t like about the movie is Abigail’s relationship with John. She slept with him once and is obsessed with getting him away from his wife. He, on the other hand, realizes that what he did was wrong. He still loves his wife. The sex part only seems to be there to get more people to see the movie. It doesn’t belong and the movie would have been a lot better without it.
Apart from that, The Crucible is great, and the fact that these events actually happened back in 1692, made it scarier. Even though it’s something that happened almost 400 years ago, when you think about it, human nature hasn’t really changed. People still become jealous, scared, obsessed, etc. During the Cold War in the 1950s, a lot of people were accused of being Communists and started turning against one another. They even called them “witch-hunts.”
It Makes You Think
When I left the theater, I started thinking that something like this could still happen today and wondering how I would handle it.
If you’re in the mood for a comedy or an action movie, The Crucible is not the movie to see. But if you want to see a story about a community being torn apart by mass hysteria, a story that will make you think, this is the movie for you.
“The Crucible”: A Real Witch Hunt
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.