The Trouble With Being a Virgin: I Had To Lie (Part I)

Names have been changed.
Ever since we were kids, my friends Susan, Amaryllis and I used to hang out three or four times a week and call each other every night to catch up on what we did that day. We were mad close-like sisters.
In junior high, there were times when Susan and Amaryllis would cut out of school. I hardly ever joined them, but the few times I did we went to the movies or to Manhattan to just walk around, bug out and act silly. I was always the “innocent” one, though. When my friends were experimenting with pot I backed off. Whenever they offered me a forty, I would say “No thanks.”
That was my choice. But I didn’t think less of my friends if they chose to do something different and they always respected the fact that I wasn’t down with that.
The summer before we entered high school, I went to Puerto Rico on vacation. When I came back, I started hearing a lot of rumors about Amaryllis and Susan sleeping around. I didn’t believe them. People were always saying stuff about them and none of it was ever true. So why should I start paying attention to rumors now? I didn’t even feel it was worth mentioning.
Keeping Secrets
But once we started high school, things started to change between us. We would only chill once a week. We rarely called each other anymore either, and when we did the conversations always felt incomplete. It was like there was a big area in their lives that I wasn’t being filled in on. It seemed they were acting differently whenever I was around.
One day Amaryllis and Susan cut school and wouldn’t tell me where they went. It was like this big secret. Another time I was walking with Amaryllis around my block when we ran into Joey, the local flirt. My friends and I always kept away from him, but this time Joey stopped Amaryllis and told her to give him a hug or else he would shout her out. Amaryllis looked real scared and said OK, but warned him not to touch her ass. (Of course he touched her anyway.)
I was confused. “Did I just miss something here?” I asked as soon as Joey finally left her alone. “Since when do you give a hug to Joey?” Amaryllis got really pale and didn’t even want to look at me. I dropped it, but I didn’t forget.
She Blew Their Spot
Then two weeks after that, Amaryllis and Susan were at my house and we were talking about the guys on the block and how stupid they were. “Yeah, remember that day with Joey and Charlie,” said Susan. Amaryllis opened her eyes real wide to let Susan know that she just blew their spot.
“What happened that day?” I asked.
They looked at each other as if trying to decide whether or not to tell me.
“Forget it,” I said, annoyed. “I don’t want to know.” And I left the room. I was getting sick and tired of all the secrecy.
They followed me, sat me down and explained to me that it was very difficult for them to tell me because they felt embarrassed. They told me about how, over the summer, they had lost their virginity. I wasn’t too surprised; I already knew something was up.
Susan and Amaryllis also told me that, on the day they cut school and didn’t want to tell me where they were, they had gone to Joey’s house and had sex with him and his friend Charlie. Amaryllis was looking at the floor when she told me. She seemed embarrassed, but Susan was just chilling like it was nothing.
My Friends Deserved Better
I didn’t think differently of them because they were my friends, but I told them that they made a big mistake. Now Joey had something to bother them with if they ever ignored him, which was really bad news. He could blackmail and harass them and they would have to do whatever he said unless they wanted to be shouted out and have their names dragged on the floor. That’s why Amaryllis had hugged Joey that day. If she had a choice she wouldn’t have but she was at his mercy.
Even though I didn’t say it, I was really disappointed in them. When we were kids, all three of us were raised with that law of morality that said you save your virginity until you are married. I always figured we all would abide by it, but apparently I was wrong.
I also knew they didn’t even like Charlie and Joey. “I just wanted to see how it would be like,” Susan told me. It was a one time thing and that is really low. I felt my best friends deserved better.
I didn’t tell them that, though, because I know not everyone thinks like I do. To Amaryllis and Susan, relationships and even just having male friends, meant having sex. The way they go about things is different.
We Kept Drifting Apart
Now that my best friends had told me they weren’t virgins like me anymore, all the pieces of the puzzle began to fit together. But, somehow, we were still drifting apart. It was awkward because they were the only ones that I felt comfortable talking to about personal stuff. My other friends in school were cool, but we didn’t go back far enough for them to gain my trust. Suddenly, I felt really alone.
One day after school, Susan, Amaryllis and I were walking to the park. “Remember when we were in junior high and we used to go to the park all the time to chill with everyone,” said Susan.
“Yeah,” I snapped. “That was when we were close. We used to do everything together, but now we’re drifting apart.”
“It’s different now, that’s all,” said Amaryllis. “We’re changing. We’re not in junior high anymore.”
“Whatever,” I responded.
“It is different,” said Susan. “You are a great friend. But for some reason it’s like we feel inferior to you. You are always getting high grades, while we barely pass. Even when we chill, you don’t like doing anything we like to do.”
‘We can’t talk about sex to you’
“We can’t talk about sex to you,” Amaryllis added. “It’s uncomfortable. We don’t want to feel like we’re talking to a priest.”
I just kept saying, “Whatever” until we got to the park. Then I told them, “We’ve been through so much. Everyone in the whole world can call you ‘sluts’ but I would never think that way.”
After that, we never spoke about our friendship coming apart again, but for weeks I was thinking about what they had said. Then I started noticing that something was wrong with Amaryllis. In class, she was quiet and would put her head down on the desk which was weird because she was usually laughing and talking to everyone.
I asked her what was the matter, but she said it was nothing. I didn’t believe her, but I understood that she felt uncomfortable telling me. I figured it had something to do with her boyfriend.
If I wanted to know what was wrong with her, I had to do something. And I sensed that what stood in the way was me being a virgin. Now I wasn’t about to go out and lose my virginity to anybody just like that because my friends were drifting away from me. I had to figure out a way to be a virgin and not be a virgin at the same time.
My Big Lie
A few weeks later, I made the decision that I was going to have a long talk with each of my friends and tell them I had sex with Danny, my boyfriend in Puerto Rico over the summer. I wondered if it would make a difference, if that was the real reason we were drifting apart. I was also curious to see if I could go through with the lie.
I told Amaryllis first. We were in our English class and had to work in pairs. Amaryllis and I finished our work and started talking. “You know,” I said. “There’s something I haven’t mentioned to you about Danny. Remember him?”
“Yeah, of course,” she said. “You wouldn’t stop talking about him for weeks when you came back from Puerto Rico. Did he come to New York?”
“No. It’s something that happened when I was in Puerto Rico with him,” I began telling her. “The day before I came back home, Danny took me to the beach. We had mad fun that day. Before he took me to my aunt’s house, he took me to his apartment. We were making out on the couch, then things went a little further.”
“What do you mean, ‘Things went a little further’?” Amaryllis asked with a weird look on her face.
“I lost my virginity to Danny,” I blurted out. I almost ruined my whole lie because I could feel myself beginning to laugh, but I managed to hold it in.
‘YOU AND DANNY? NAH’
“I don’t believe you,” Amaryllis said. “You and Danny?…Nah.”
“I didn’t want to tell anyone because I wanted to keep it to myself,” I responded.
As quickly as I convinced her that I wasn’t a virgin, Amaryllis told me what was wrong with her. She said that her period hadn’t come in over two months and she was feeling real sick. She was scared.
As soon as I convinced her that I wasn’t a virgin, Amaryllis told me what was wrong with her. She said that her period hadn’t come in over two months and she was feeling real sick. She was scared.
My first thought was that she was pregnant. Most of my friends in school were already sexually active and used to talk about the places they went to get checked out. I immediately called a women’s clinic I had heard about, made an appointment for Amaryllis and went with her.
She Wasn’t Pregnant, It was an Std
It turned out she wasn’t pregnant at all; she had chlamydia. I didn’t know what the hell that was, but the doctor explained to Amaryllis that chlamydia is a common sexually transmitted disease (STD) that, if left untreated, can lead to ovary damage. We were both really surprised. When she told me her symptoms I never thought it could be an STD.
The doctor gave Amaryllis some pills to treat the infection. You would think that having an STD would have made her think twice before having unprotected sex the next time. But Amaryllis was so ignorant that she continued down the same path she was on before she found out she had chlamydia. This really bothered me because it never seemed to have occurred to her that as easily as she had caught chlamydia, she could have caught AIDS.
I Meant to Tell Them, But. . .
I had told two other friends the same story as Amaryllis. Originally, my plan had been to tell them I wasn’t a virgin and if our friendship went back to being like it was before high school, then I would tell them the truth and they’d realize that they’d never had any reason to feel uncomfortable talking to me in the first place.
I told myself that I would wait about two weeks to tell them the truth. But when two weeks had passed, I told myself that I would tell them in a month. When a month passed, I told myself I would tell them on April Fool’s Day. That way it would be a sort of joke I had played on them. But April Fool’s Day came and went, and I still hadn’t told them that I was really still a virgin.
Since they started believing that I was sexually active, they told me everything that was going on in their lives. And since I was “one of them,” I had the right to help them the way I had Amaryllis because I “understood” what was going on. Back when I was a “virgin,” I hadn’t earned the right to advise or help them because, as far as they were concerned, I didn’t have a clue as to what goes along with being sexually active. To them, I was an outsider.
A Good Influence
There were many reasons why I kept the lie up. Most important was that I felt I was able to slow their pace, to help them realize that they shouldn’t have sex with every guy they met, especially not on the first date. Once Amaryllis went out with a guy named Alex and on their first date, he took her to his apartment and they had sex. She called me after the date crying because she hadn’t really wanted to do that, but he was very persistent.
Without me saying a word, she told me she was never going to put herself in that predicament again. “The next time I go out with a guy, we go to the movies or something,” she told me sobbing, “and then he takes me straight home.”
Amaryllis didn’t change her ways immediately. It took several similar situations before she began to accept what I had been telling her all along.
It’s been three years now since I first lied about being sexually active, and our friendship has grown stronger. We are like sisters who talk about everything and anything. We hang out every day and are always there for each other. If I hadn’t made up that story, I don’t feel they ever would have confided in me.
Birds of a Feather. . .
I’ve always wished I could tell them the truth, but I never do. It’s not that I’m ashamed of being a virgin, it’s just that my best friends feel comfortable with me now and I’m helping them in the process. Most of us confide in people who are like we are because we feel that, that way, we don’t have to worry about being judged or criticized. When an alcoholic begins to realize she has a problem, for example, and is ready to get help, she goes to an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting where she can be amongst people who have experienced the same things.
My best friends have been through wild stuff-one of them had an abortion and another has had sex with two guys at once. If I hadn’t lied, I wouldn’t have known about these things. I have to admit sometimes I feel really uncomfortable hearing about their sex lives, but I’m supposed to be one of them.
One time Susan, glowing with pride, told me about having sex with her boyfriend in the shower. “Really?” I asked, giggling to make it believable. “Are you sure that’s really what happened?” But on the inside I was thinking, “Is she for real? She’s real dumb. She thinks having sex in the shower is a great accomplishment? That makes no sense.” After a while, I got used to this kind of thing and now it doesn’t faze me as much as it used to.
The Snowball Effect
But sometimes I’ve had to make up stories of my own which is really weird for me. I feel so guilty afterwards and I always have this fear that they’ll ask my boyfriend about it (he doesn’t know about the lie) and he’ll freak out. But it’s all part of the lie. Once you tell one lie, there’s a snowball effect, one lie comes after another.
I get my tales from friends at school. I just switch the names around. For
example, one time my friend was telling me about how she had sex with a guy in the movies. I made my friend out to be me and the guy to be my boyfriend, Eddie, and I had my story for the day.
I really didn’t like the lying trend, so last year I started backing off talking about any topic related to sex. I talk about my relationship with Eddie and all the things we do together. Like we hold hands when we walk together, he takes me to restaurants, we go to the movies, he helps my father fix the car while I watch, and he chills with my family. It made my friends realize that sex isn’t the only thing in a relationship.
Pretending to be Someone I’m Not
Since Amaryllis is the follower of the group, she caught on fast and started trying out the simple things that make relationships work. Then if she decides the guy’s alright, she moves on to the sex part.
As close as we are, however, I still can’t say things are the same between my friends Susan and Amaryllis and me. I guess the way I feel now is similar to the way they used to feel towards me. Initially, they felt they had to pretend that they were still virgins like me. Once I lied, the pretending was over and they felt comfortable with me again. Now I’m the one who feels uncomfortable.
A Friend Who Knows the Real Me
Maybe that’s part of the reason I have a new best friend, Lisa. Lisa is the only close friend I have who knows I’m a virgin. She’s also a virgin which makes it really easy for me to talk to her about relationships and stuff.
For Amaryllis and Susan all relationships have to involve sex, but when I hang out with Lisa I don’t have to pretend to be something I’m not. Lisa is a real best friend because she knows the real me. There’s no pretending in our friendship. I confide in her more than I can confide in Amaryllis or Susan.
I want to be able to tell them that everything I’ve said for the last three years is bullsh-t, but I never do. It’s not that I’m afraid they won’t be my friends anymore. It’s more a matter of my not being ready to take back the title of the “innocent.”
With that label, I was different. They wouldn’t let me talk to them or help them. If the label had stuck to me throughout high school, my friends could have had really messed up lives. They would probably have had kids and dropped out of school by now.
Sacrificing My Image
I may have helped them, but now I’m the one pretending. They don’t know what I truly believe or want in life. Outside their circle, I’m me. Inside, I’m someone else. I don’t like being perceived as being sexually active, but sometimes you have to sacrifice your image for things that are more important.
On the other hand, if they really are my best friends, they should be able to accept me for who I am and I shouldn’t have to pretend to be something I’m not. I know I’ll tell them the truth eventually, but not now.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.