Immigrant Teens and Sex: Stick with Tradition or Go with the Flow?

When Jessie Xiang, 15, of Leadership and Public Service HS, got to camp last summer, two of her roommates put pictures of their boyfriends next to their beds and started talking about how cute they were, how much they loved them and, of course, they talked about sex. When they asked Jessie if she had a boyfriend, she said she didn’t.
“Oh, that’s OK,” they told her. But, according to Jessie, “They sounded kind of sad,” when they said it. “I felt kind of left out,” she explained.
Since coming to this country from China five years ago, Jessie has found that many young people here think having a boyfriend is “cool.” “They’re proud of it,” she said. “But I don’t think it’s cool. At this age you have to be thinking about education.”
Nevertheless, Jessie says having a boyfriend is “all [some people] talk about.” She knows it can make a person more popular and feels she and her friends would be “closer” and more accepting if she had one. But she also knows that’s not what she wants for herself right now.
‘Americans Look at me Weird’
“My Chinese friends, they don’t have boyfriends,” she said. For that reason, sometimes it’s easier hanging out with them than with her American friends. “[The Americans] make me feel weird,” she explained. “They look at me weird, they say I’m a lesbian.”
Jessie says she knows they’re only joking but it’s still hard. “They see a boy who’s cute and say, ‘Look how cute he is,’ and I [say] ‘I don’t think he’s cute, what’s the big deal?’ They think being with me is not fun…[I] get tired of arguing with them.”
Nancy Tibana, 17, of Bushwick HS, remembers how hard not having a boyfriend was on her friendships. “They say friends are forever,” she said, “but if you don’t have a boyfriend…[your friends] always try to hook you up with somebody.”
Nancy is Colombian and even though she came to America when she was 5, her culture still has a strong influence on her decisions about sex and dating. She said she knows people who stay out until 4 a.m. and don’t even bother to call their parents. “[For] a lot of people around here it’s weird when you respect your parents,” she said, but she would never do that or deliberately go against their wishes.
Valuing Virginity
Young people coming into a sexually open society like the United States from cultures that have very strict beliefs about these matters often feel left out and find it difficult to decide what to think or do.
Premarital sex is probably the biggest source of their confusion. “Americans think if you like a boy, you can have sex with him,” said Jessie. “They don’t value virginity.”
But Jessie comes from a culture that traditionally discourages women from losing their virginity before marriage. In communist China, she said, “You only have sex with your husband. If they find out you’re not a virgin, they might divorce you or put you through a hard life.” She added that in ancient times they used to “put you in a cage and throw you in the river.”
For Nancy, it is much the same. “In my country you have to get married when you’re [still] a virgin,” she said. “If you’re not…[people] wouldn’t respect you as much…If I told my grandmother I had sex, it would be such a disgrace.”
Wanting to Fit in
But as strongly as someone’s family might look down on her being sexually active, there are bound to be other forces pushing her in the opposite direction. “Overall, I feel like a goody-two-shoes,” said Nancy. “And at [this] age, you really don’t want that. You want to be like everyone else.”
Nancy hasn’t always been able to resist the pressure. “They say ‘no’ is easy, but it’s hard when you want it too,” she explained. “I kissed this guy…you melt, you don’t know what you’re doing…You’re young. You’re careful, but sometimes you slip.”
For the most part, Nancy still believes what her culture teaches. She doesn’t think that you necessarily have to remain a virgin until you get married like her grandmother does, but she thinks it’s better if you do. “It’s kind of hard,” she said. “But I would rather stick to the traditional.”
One of the strongest reasons Nancy has for continuing to feel that sex is a bad idea for someone in her situation comes not from her family, however, but from people her own age.
A Permissive Society?
“I had a friend,” said Nancy. “She was like, ‘I want a baby, I want a baby.’ ” Her friend got pregnant and then her boyfriend went to jail. Now she has a child and is living on welfare with her mother. Before, Nancy was always “the good girl,” she said, while her friend was out partying and having a good time. “But now she’s the one who can’t go outside.”
Nancy feels that one of the reasons so many girls like her friend are having sex and getting pregnant before they’re ready is that American society is too permissive.
“We even have a daycare center in our school because so many girls get pregnant,” she said. “I think a lot of people get envious [of the young mothers]. It’s very sad when you think about it. You can go to school when you’re pregnant.” Nancy says that unlike people like her friend who had the baby, if she got pregnant “my mom wouldn’t take care of me.”
Changing Views
Though teens like Nancy and Jessie share many of their parents’ views about sex, one area where they tend to break with tradition is abortion. Many people, young and old, are strongly against it when they come to this country. But once they confront the American reality, their minds begin to change. Nancy, for example was, like her parents, against abortion until one of her friends got pregnant and had one. If her friend had a baby, she said, “It would’ve been such a mess.” Jessie also thinks abortion is OK, “in some cases.”
But the biggest conflict all the people I interviewed had with the way their respective cultures dealt with sexuality was the double standards they hold for boys and girls.
Helen Stogova, 17, of International HS, said that in Russia, where she’s from, “When you go out with many guys, they think you’re a b-ch or something. But when a guy does that, it’s OK. When a husband cheats [on a wife], the relatives don’t pay as much attention, but if a wife has an affair…a lot of people, especially older women, say you’re a b-ch.”
Making Their Own Decisions
Nancy said that in Hispanic culture, whatever happens, they always blame the woman. Even if you are raped, she said, they’ll say it’s your fault. “You wore a short dress, that’s why you got raped,” people will say.
Few people agree with everything their religions, cultures, families or friends tell them when it comes to dating and sex. But there comes a point in life when you have to make tough decisions about dating and sex. Some have a harder time reaching theirs than others, but ultimately everyone makes choices. Jessie, for example, decided that she doesn’t want a boyfriend right now. “[At] this age, you go to school and learn,” she said.
Nancy and Helen, on the other hand, are dating, but they don’t let guys run their lives either. Nancy said she has no problem dumping guys who don’t treat her with respect. Helen doesn’t have a problem with premarital sex but still has had to come up with her own criteria for when it makes sense for her. “Sex is the next step in the relationship,” she explained,”but before that, you have to build a strong relationship.”
No matter what you choose, whether you’d rather adapt to the American culture like Helen or “stick to the traditional” like Nancy, it’s your decision. Helen put it best when she said, “The important thing is what I think about it.”

SIDEBAR: Do What’s Right for You Reported
Amanda Waltz is a clinical social worker who counsels teens and their families about sex, birth control and pregnancy at Planned Parenthood’s Brooklyn clinic. When pregnant teens come to see her, the very first thing Waltz wants to know is who they’ve already talked to about it, what “the outside influences” are. “They say, ‘Well, my mother says this, and my boyfriend says this, and my religion says this…'” explained Waltz. When it comes to sex, “culture influences a person in a tremendous way,” she continued. “Some cultures are more restrictive and [parents] pass it on to their children…so they think it’s wrong or a sin. Others glorify sex, and teenagers feel pressured to be sexual.”
Clueless Parents
Parents often tell their daughters that they’re not old enough to have sex, that boys will take advantage of them or get them pregnant. “In general,” though, “parents say very little, hoping they’re learning [about it] in school,” Waltz said. “It’s hard for them to think of their kids as sexual people.” Waltz said there are some parents who don’t care, while others are too involved. “They’re dragging [their kids] here every month,” she said, mentioning a 14-year-old whose mother found out she kissed her boyfriend and “dragged her in for a pregnancy test.” Parents react in a variety of ways when they find out that children aren’t following what their culture dictates. “I’ve seen disappointment and anger,” said Waltz, citing the example of the mother of a young Puerto Rican woman, who didn’t wait to have sex. “Her mother felt that she failed in some way…[that she] hadn’t taught her.”
Parents Who Support Their Kids
A 16-year-old African-American Waltz counseled was forced to leave home when she got pregnant. “Right now she’s living in the maternity shelter, then she’ll go to foster care,” she said. Waltz feels that it’s sad when parents turn away from their children at a time when they need them the most. Nevertheless, there are plenty of parents who support their children even when they disapprove. Waltz said that a young woman, 17, got pregnant last summer and told her mom about it. At first her mother cried, but then made the appointment for her at Planned Parenthood. “She tried to help her daughter,” said Waltz, “but that doesn’t happen all the time.” In some cultures or families it might be OK to have sex at a young age, Waltz added, but not to use birth control. Some religions hold that sex should be for reproduction. The church, on the other hand, takes “a very strong stand” that young people shouldn’t be having sex before marriage. There are also myths in some communities that the pill will make you sterile, that condoms are for people who don’t love each other, etc.
When Reality Strikes
People’s views sometimes change when reality strikes, however. “A lot of people are raised to think that abortion is wrong,” said Waltz. “But when they become pregnant they begin to change.” She said she has also seen many parents who start out against abortion but are “glad it exists when their child becomes pregnant.” Waltz says that teens are also receiving “mixed messages” from sources beyond their parents and friends. Music videos, movies, and TV are showing them “very sexual people who never take time to [use] birth control.” Many of the teens she counsels are “confused, scared, overwhelmed by the choices,” Waltz says. “Often [they’re] really looking for guidance.” She says the first thing to do is “to recognize that there isn’t one absolute right or wrong way in life.” What others tell you about sex is what’s right for them. Parts of it might be right for you also, but ultimately you have to decide that for yourself.
Figuring Out What’s Best For You
The best way to do that, according to Waltz, is to “soul-search.” Think about what’s most important to you at this point in your life and “see where sex might or might not fit in.” If you’re not sure what’s best for you, Waltz suggests you talk to someone-a counselor or a friend who understands you. “It’s great when you can talk to your parents,” she said. “But as sad as it may be, some parents don’t listen.” When other people disagree with your beliefs or try to pressure, judge or make fun of you based on their own values, Waltz suggests that it’s always better to be honest about it and tell them the reasons why you have made the decision you have. “It’s much harder to resist that,” she said. Finding the right thing to say to people who are critical of your decisions is hard. “I wish there was an easy answer,” said Waltz, “but that has to come from the inside.” When making choices about relationships, sex, birth control and pregnancy she says to keep your long-term goals in mind and focus on the future.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.