From the time I first arrived in my foster home a year ago, I felt close to my foster sister Michelle (not her real name). Michelle and I are around the same age. I’m 17 and she is 18.
We had to share a room together like sisters, so I wanted to get to know her. Everybody in that house told me that Michelle never really talked to anyone. She kept to herself until I came along.
But when I first came to my foster home Michelle and I hit it off great. So she opened up much more than she had before. And that’s how we started to become friends. Soon enough I felt that l could tell her anything because I knew she would understand.
We would play games such as Monopoly, Life, and Trouble in our free time. We also played card games such as Crazy Eights, Spades, and I Declare War. Sometimes we’d play games all night long. We would also stay up late and talk about school or relationships (you know, girl stuff), the kinds of things that sisters do all the time.
Sometimes when I felt bad because a guy rejected me, Michelle would say things that would make me feel better like, “He just isn’t good for you,” or “You deserve better.” These words were telling me to move on and made me feel she really cared. If she didn’t care, why would she say these things?
During our late night talks while we were in bed, I opened up to Michelle about my problems and she would often say things to encourage me, such as “You are beautiful, you have a great voice, you are going to be somebody someday.” Likewise, I was there for her when she needed me the most.
Like a Real Sister
Michelle often reminds me of my real sister, Crystal, who is 16 and lives in Virginia. Nobody ever made me feel as good as Crystal did, until Michelle came into my life. Maybe I just wanted Michelle to be like my sister because I miss my real sister so much. Crystal and I have been living apart for about nine years, and for three of those years we didn’t even really speak.
Michelle reminds me of Crystal in lots of ways. I’ve always played the role of the big sister with Crystal. When I get the chance to talk to her over the phone, I still seem to play the big sister role. For example, Crystal sometimes asks me a question about boys and I give her advice. I seem to be doing the same thing with Michelle, even though she is a little older than me.
Shot Cold
Another reason Michelle reminds me of Crystal is that their birthdays are in the same month, and they are both the same Zodiac sign (Pisces), which means they are both indecisive but kind-hearted. Also, they are both very good dancers.
Since I never knew my parents during my childhood, Crystal was all the family I had. And after I was put in foster care at the age of nine, I had no family at all. So when I met Michelle and got to know her, and some of her characteristics reminded me of my sister, I guess Michelle became like a sister to me. I know I wanted Michelle to feel the same kind of bond I was feeling.
So one day last summer we were having a conversation and I was feeling very close to Michelle. I asked her “Do you think of me as a sister?” Her response was “NO.”
When she said that, my feelings were shot cold. I could feel the cracking in my throat as I said, “That’s cool.”
I really don’t know why Michelle said that, but I didn’t go any further with it because I really didn’t want to get hurt any worse.
Michelle and I have not changed our behavior toward each other, even though she doesn’t want to consider me as her sister. But after we said that, I really felt that I had misjudged our relationship.
I define family as a place where you can be yourself and not be judged when you are doing it. You may get corrected at times, but that’s life and that’s family. You should be one with the people who are close to you and it shouldn’t matter if you are a real family or not. That’s what makes a family-people who care about you, and know how to help you at times when you are down.
A Nationality Thing?
Maybe one reason why Michelle said she didn’t want to be considered my sister is because she is having a hard time with her own sister, so maybe she doesn’t want our relationship to go bad.
I really don’t know how Michelle defines family, but from what I see her own family is going to be better than the one she grew up with.
Michelle has never said anything to me, but I think another issue for her is a nationality thing. I am Black and she is Indian, so she may feel that since we don’t look alike and we are not blood related, she can only call me her foster sister, not her “real” sister.
She’s My Sister
But lately Michelle hasn’t been in my life as much. We both go to school all day, so we don’t have as much time with each other as we did last year (when she was unable to go to school). She has a boyfriend now, so on weekends I am home alone with nobody to talk to. I feel Michelle has a life and I don’t. That’s not her fault, it’s just the way it is.
I miss the talks we used to have about the things we have in common. Michelle and I both came from abusive homes where alcohol played a role. Our relatives don’t seem to care about us. We both feel so alone, and that nobody will be there for us when we need them the most.
But I’ve tried to let her know that she has someone-me-and I will be with her until the day I die, because she is all I’ve got right now. If I lose her, then I would be alone.
Even though Michelle doesn’t feel the same way I feel, I will always think of her as a sister no matter what she may say. Foster siblings are family to me.
Are Foster Sisters Really Family?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.