“My name is Donna, I’m 18, and I just got moved to this group home in Queens. It’s pretty cool here but I’m upset. I need a jacket and a new pair of Nikes, and I haven’t gotten my clothing allowance for over six months.
“What am I going to do? I’m freezing my butt off going to school every day without a jacket. Plus I’ve got a job interview at a store near my group home coming up. I can’t go wearing my dirty old shoes and worn out coat.
“My worker said she’s doing all she can, but I haven’t heard anything from her in a long time. Can you help me???”
Who is the best person to help Donna?
a) her lawyer
b) her social worker
c) you (young people in foster care)
d) Donna
The correct answer? C and D. You and Donna-youth in foster care-know what it is like dealing with the system. Your social worker and lawyer are important in helping you get what you need, but, in the end, you have to tell them what you want and take action to get it for yourself.
This is what we call advocacy-a fancy-sounding word that means “taking action to protect a right or belief, or to change a policy or the way someone is acting.” When you advocate for yourself, you find out your rights and come up with a plan to get what you need and deserve from the system.
When you cook, you need a recipe. If you want to win a basketball game, you need a strategy. And when you advocate, you need a plan. Before you take action by talking to your worker, making a phone call to your lawyer, or writing a letter to your agency, there are 8 steps of advocacy to help you make a plan. If you follow these steps, you have a very good chance of solving your problem in a positive way.
Here are the eight advocacy steps to identify and follow before you take action:
1) What is the problem I’m facing?
2) What goal is my problem keeping me from reaching?
3) What is the solution?
4) What are my rights?
5) What facts support my position and rights?
6) Who’s in charge?
7) Who’s on my side?
8) How will I present my problem to people who can help me?
Step 1: What Is the Problem?
When you are upset about something, it’s sometimes hard to explain what the problem is. You may end up talking about other things that bother you, and the person trying to help you may get confused because you’re not clear about your problem.
If you’re having a problem in foster care, it helps to take a few minutes to write it down to help make it clearer. When you try to explain what your problem is, 1) be specific and clear, and 2) list all the facts that relate to the problem.
For example, what is Donna’s main problem?
a) her group home
b) her expensive taste in Nikes
c) she needs her clothing allowance
d) she wants to get a job and finish high school
Answer? C is the best answer because it is specific and says the facts clearly.
The group home may be part of the problem, but you have to be more specific. The fact that Donna wants Nikes is not the whole problem. The fact that she wants to get a job and finish high school is something positive Donna wants to do for herself, but it is not a problem. The truth is that Donna may have a lot of problems, but getting money for clothes is her most important one.
What other facts would help make Donna’s advocacy plan stronger?
a) the supervisor said Donna’s not getting a clothing allowance because she hasn’t been in the group home long enough
b) the last time Donna got a clothing allowance was in February
c) Donna put in about 15 job applications before she got her job interview
d) all of the above
The answer is: D. All these facts are good to know. When Donna is getting ready to deal with her agency, she will want to use these facts to help get her clothing allowance. For example, the fact that she’s looking hard for a job may make the agency more likely to help her get the allowance.
STEP 2: What Goal Is My Problem Keeping Me From Reaching?
Your problem is important because it is keeping you from reaching a goal. A goal is usually positive, while problems are usually negative; if you focus on your goals, you will usually get more help in solving your problem.
What should Donna choose as her goal?
a) to get her worker fired for not helping her get clothing money
b) to have clothes she can wear to school and work
c) to buy new Air Jordans
d) all of the above
Answer? B. Donna’s goal is to get clothes so she can go to school and get a part-time job. Not having money for clothes (the problem) is keeping Donna from her goals. While she does want new sneakers (answer C), it is better to talk about a goal that is bigger than that (getting an education and working). Donna may feel like she wants her worker fired (answer A), but that probably won’t help her solve her problem, and focuses her energy on something negative rather than on doing something positive for herself.
STEP 3: What Is the Solution?
Sometimes the person you complain to about a problem might not know how to help you. Therefore, you can and should have some ideas about what solution you want and how that person can help you get it. When you try to come up with a solution to your problem, ask yourself:
1) What exactly do you want to happen or change?
2) What is reasonable and not reasonable to expect as a solution?
3) What are the steps to reach the solution?
What is a good solution for Donna’s problems?
a) She gets her clothing allowance and then a job to earn extra cash
b) The agency changes its clothing allowance policy to give residents money every month
c) Donna takes money from the group home petty cash box because she has to have clothes
Answer? A is the best solution for the short term and long term: Donna should get the allowance so she can look presentable at school and work. Maybe the agency’s clothing allowance policy should be changed (answer B). Donna can try to do this, but should realize that changing the rules in a group home can be complicated and take a long time, a lot of work, and the cooperation of many other people. She’ll get faster results-and work experience-if she focuses on getting her clothing allowance and the job. Stealing money from the group home (answer C) will give her the fastest results (instant cash), but is illegal and could get her arrested.
Now that she knows the solution to her problem, what should Donna say to her worker that is a step in the right direction?
a) “Maybe we can go talk to your supervisor, Ms. Jones, together to explain my situation.”
b) “Why don’t you back to social work school and learn what your job is, stupid.”
c) “Come on, just give me the money and I’ll quit bothering you.”
Answer? A. The worker can’t just write a check herself and might not really know what to do to help Donna. Donna is showing that she understands that her worker probably needs approval from the agency to give out clothing money. Telling her worker to go back to school (B) is not a very direct step to help Donna get her money, and insulting the worker will hurt Donna more than it will help her (though it may make her feel better for a short time!). Answer C does not show the worker how she can help Donna get the money.
Donna can also explain that getting the clothing allowance is a step to going on an interview, which is a step to getting a part-time job, which will give her more money, independence, and work experience. By showing that her goals are positive, her worker may be more willing to help her get the clothing allowance.
STEP 4: What Are My Rights?
When you are in foster care, you have rights that come from State laws and regulations, as well as from policies of the agency. You have the right to a safe place to live, meals, clothing, independent living training, etc. You can use your rights in your advocacy plan to get what you need.
You can find out what your rights are in many ways. The Youth Advocacy Center (YAC) has a book called “Rights and Advocacy Guidelines” that explains a lot of foster care rights (call 212-675-6181 to get a copy). You can ask your social worker. If he or she doesn’t know (or you don’t believe him or her), ask to see your agency’s policy manual. You can also call your lawyer.
What right does Donna have that is important to her advocacy case?
a) the right to $200-a-month allowance
b) the right to proper clothing
c) the right to privacy in her group home
Answer: B. If Donna looked in the YAC “Rights and Advocacy Guidelines,” she would see that the State regulations say that she has the right to an “adequate basic wardrobe.” For an 18-year-old girl, that means two pair of shoes and one pair of sneakers (plus clothes, of course).
This right is important to Donna’s advocacy case because it means that the agency has already agreed that they have to give her proper clothing.
But Donna doesn’t have the right to a set amount of allowance from the agency (answer A). It is pretty much up to each agency to decide how much allowance they will give youth, and how often they will give it. She does have the right to get some allowance, but it is about $10 a week for an 18-year-old, in addition to an Independent Living stipend of $30 a month (if she participates in the agency’s Independent Living program).
Donna has some right to privacy (answer C). For example, the group home staff can’t open her mail or search her room without permission, but this isn’t related to her problem.
This is not the end of Donna’s advocacy case! She still needs your help! In the next issue of FCYU you can help Donna finish up her plan to get her clothing allowance. She will need to:
5) Get her facts together
6) Find out who’s in charge
7) Figure out who’s on her side
8) Plan her presentation to the agency
Have you ever tried to call your social worker or lawyer for help with a problem and not gotten anywhere? You know what it’s like: they tell you they have so many cases, it’s not up to them, or maybe they really don’t know how to help you.
I used to be a lawyer for foster care youth in Family Court. I thought I was pretty good, but there were still a lot of problems I couldn’t help kids with.
Now I’m director of the Youth Advocacy Center (YAC), which teaches foster care youth to advocate for themselves. Advocacy is a fancy sounding word, but it basically means taking action to protect your rights and get what services you’re entitled to. You-youth in foster care-can be your own best advocate.
In each issue, this column will help you solve a problem you’re having in foster care by using the steps of advocacy and your own ideas.
Step 5: What Facts Support Your Position and Rights?
Many youth go to complain about a problem without having enough facts to back them up. To make a winning argument, you need to connect the most powerful facts that directly relate to your goals and your rights.
You have to think beforehand about all the facts of your situation: ask yourself a) what happened, b) when, c) for how long, and d) who is involved. Even if some facts seem unimportant, they can turn out to be useful. For example:
Betsy: “Donna, tell me again, what happened?”
Donna: “I haven’t gotten my clothing allowance since last February. Not one cent.”
Betsy: “OK, who have you talked to about this?”
Donna: “My social worker, Joyce. Oh yeah, and her supervisor, that darn Ms. Jones.”
Betsy: “What did they say?”
Donna: “My social worker said she didn’t know why I haven’t gotten it. Ms. Jones said it’s because I haven’t been in the group home long enough.”
Betsy: “Let’s talk about what else is going on.”
Donna: “I finally get an interview at this store to work after school and I don’t even have a decent pair of shoes to wear!”
Betsy: “And how are you doing in school?”
Donna: “Thank God, that’s one place I’m not having problems right now. I have a B average and I’m going to graduate in June. That is, if I can keep going there. I’m freezing my butt off without a jacket.”
Donna has told me a lot of good facts. She said when she last got her allowance, how long this has been happening, and a possible reason why she’s not getting it now. The fact that she has been looking for a job and will graduate with a good average are important because they show that Donna is not a “problem child.” She is someone who is doing a lot for herself. It’s important when you advocate to remember to present the positive things about yourself: your achievements, goals and plans for the future. By being positive, you’re more likely to get help.
Step 6: Who’s In Charge?
Even the best argument won’t win if it’s made to the wrong person. If you go into the Wiz and try to return a broken Walkman to the security guard, you’re not going to get very far! You need to go to customer service. In foster care, you need to know who can help solve your problem and what the “chain of command” is.
Betsy: “In other words, who’s in charge at your agency?”
Donna: “They’ve got all kinds of people running around. There’s the group home director, Mr. King, but he’s not around a whole lot. My social worker, Joyce, and her supervisor, Ms. Jones-I told you she’s got a nasty attitude, right? That’s it, I guess.”
Betsy: “What about at the main office? Who’s over there?”
Donna: “In those fancy offices downtown? The head of the whole agency, Dr. Whatever, and a bunch of secretaries or something.”
Betsy: “Is there anyone else who might be responsible for making sure you get your clothing allowance?”
Donna: “There’s that Independent Living lady who gives us pizza and tokens when we go to her meetings.”
Donna identifies a lot of people in her agency. She also figured out that the social worker is supervised by Ms. Jones, who probably is supervised by the head of the group home, Mr. King. The person in charge of all of them is the agency director, Dr. Whatever (Donna has to find out his or her real name). Also, there is an Independent Living director who probably has to report to the agency director. It’s always good to ask if there is a staff person whose job is to deal with the specific problems you’re facing.
Step 7: Who’s On My Side?
You need to identify people who’ll support you: a sympathetic social worker or staff, your foster parent, lawyer, even a teacher. They will make your advocacy stronger and also can give you good ideas.
Betsy: “First, let’s go over the list you made in Step 6 to identify anyone who may be supportive of (for) or hostile to (against) your advocacy.”
Donna: “Well, we know who’s against me-Ms. Jones. My social worker Joyce is okay, but she’s new, she doesn’t know what she’s doing. Mr. King is cool-at least he acts like he cares about us. Too bad he’s always running around somewhere. The Independent Living lady, I don’t really know her.”
Betsy: “Who else do you know who would be on your side? They can be part of or outside the agency.”
Donna: “Well, my old foster mother, Maria Ramos. She said she’d lend me some shoes to go on this job interview. That’s it, I guess.”
Betsy: “What about at school?”
Donna: “My homeroom teacher knows I need a coat. The other day it started snowing and he was like, ‘You better get yourself something warmer than that windbreaker.'”
Once you figure out who’s on your side, see if any of these people can contact the decision-makers at your agency. Having them call or write a letter of support will help (get copies of their letters).
In some cases, having them come to a meeting with the decision-maker at your agency can be helpful. If this is a problem that other youth are having, talk to them and get their support, or see if they want to work with you on solving the problem.
Step 8: How Can I Present My Problem To People Who Can Help Me?
Once you get all your information together using the eight steps of advocacy, you’re ready to take action. There are several approaches you may end up taking to solve the problem, such as making a phone call, requesting a meeting, or writing a letter. Whatever you choose, it’s important to organize your argument ahead of time and a letter can be a good way of doing that.
Now Donna is ready to plan a meeting with the agency to try to get her clothing allowance. I helped her write a letter asking for a meeting, that was also an outline (or agenda) for what she wanted to say at her meeting.
Donna sent copies of the letter to Mr. King and to the head of her agency. Donna also asked her old foster mother, Ms. Ramos, to call her social worker, and asked her teacher to write a short letter to her social worker saying that Donna was doing well in school.
Then she called the social worker to set up a time to meet. When she sat down with the social worker and Mr. King, they agreed to give her enough money for the jacket and sneakers.
The Letter That Donna Wrote
Dear Joyce,
I know that this agency really tries to help teens prepare for independent living. You may know that I am a resident who is doing well. I have a B average and will graduate in June. I’ve also been looking for a part-time job, and after applying at about 15 places, I finally have an interview. It’s very important to me to do well in school and to be able to earn some money for myself-I hope to go to college in the future.
For me to do these things, I need decent clothes to wear. I don’t have a winter jacket or a pair of sneakers. I have been freezing on these cold days going to school because all I have is a windbreaker. I don’t have shoes to wear to the job interview that’s coming up.
I have not gotten a clothing allowance since last February. I looked up the regulations, and found out that I have the right to get an “adequate wardrobe,” even if I haven’t been in this group home for so long. For an 18-year-old, that means one pair of sneakers, and one winter jacket, plus other things. I need $150 to buy these things right away.
I’d like to meet with you and with Mr. King, the group home director, by Friday this week to make sure I get this clothing before my job interview and before it gets even colder. Thank you for all your help.
Sincerely,
Donna Jones
509 Garden St.
Brooklyn, N.Y.
Conclusion
Donna put a lot of time and work into solving her problem, and in the end she was successful. Sometimes a letter will work, but sometimes you need to go further than that and have meetings, make several phone calls, and do a lot of follow-up. Remember: you can use the steps you learned here to solve problems you’re facing.
Advocacy takes time, hard work, and patience, and often requires you to get help from others. If you want help solving a problem in the system, call the Youth Advocacy Center at 212-675-6181. We will train you in advocacy.
Advocate for Yourself
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.