Teens React to Pataki’s Plan: Nowhere To Go But the Streets

If you still think that Governor Pataki’s proposal has nothing to do with you, wake up and smell the coffee. Listen to what some teenagers in the system had to say about it.
Everyone I spoke to said they aren’t ready to leave the system at 18. They said they won’t be able to find jobs and would have a hard time surviving.
“If they’re kicking everybody out at 18, and they don’t have any program for the people that are 18 and over, where are they going to be at? They ain’t going to be nowhere but the streets,” said Jose Maldonado, 18, a resident of the Green Chimneys group home in Manhattan. He added, “They really can’t survive out there. They gonna end up doing bad stuff.”
Jose said he might end up doing negative things to survive.
Struggle to Survive
“It would make me stop going to school,” said Jose. “I’m going to a vocational school, trying to get a trade and get my GED. I could do something for myself, but if I get kicked out of the group home, I don’t know if it will be the same…My biggest fear is me ending up back in jail or having a messed up life like selling drugs because, like I said, I got to support myself, [by] robbing, or doing something negative to survive…Whatever comes first I would do to survive.
“How am I going to pay for college if I don’t have a job?” Jose continued.
Some youth in foster care would go back home if the proposal takes effect, but others don’t have family and foster care is the only thing they can depend on.
“I don’t have any family or parents to support me,” said Charles Murray, 16. “My father left before I was born, my mother went to jail when I was little and now she is in a mental institution…so I have to rely on the system to support me.”
Charles, also a Green Chimneys resident, has been in foster care since he was five years old. He said that if the proposal passes, he’d try to find friends or relatives to live with.
“It will be hard,” he said. “I haven’t graduated and I don’t have a job.”
Last January I went to Albany with a group of young people who wanted the politicians to know that if the bill passes, it will hurt them. They testified at a State Senate hearing and what they had to say to the politicians was strong and to the point.
“Youth in foster care don’t need to be kicked out at the age of 18. What they do need is a system that will not only care for them, but will also teach them the skills that they need to live independently,” said Jose Reyes, 17, who has been in foster care for four years. “Ending foster care for youth at the age of 18 will not save money and will end up hurting the people.
“The Governor says that it will save $3.3 million,” Jose Reyes continued, “but he will see much greater costs in terms of welfare, shelters, and in the criminal justice system as youth are forced from their homes into the streets.”
Zcherex Solis, 19, who is a teen mother in foster care, also testified. She said that if the bill passes, it may mean that “my son and I will be discharged from foster care and become homeless…There is a good chance that once we are homeless the city will decide that my son is ‘at risk’. The city will take him from me and put him in a foster home.”
Zcherex would prefer to stay in care and continue her education by attending college.
“If I can stay in care until I am 21,” she said, “the foster care system will help pay room and board at college and I will be able to get an education so that I can support myself and my son.” If foster care ends at 18, Zcherex said “it would be impossible for me to support myself and Justin on the kind of minimum wage jobs you can get with a high school diploma.”
So as you can see, the proposal will affect everyone! Charles may become homeless, Jose may live a life of crime, and Zcherex may lose her son. What will happen to you?

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.