I always thought that a lot of guys are afraid to tell someone they like how they really feel. I wanted to test my theory. So I asked some guys at my school, Landmark HS, what they do when they’re really interested in someone. Some of their answers surprised me.
Most of them revealed that they do show their feelings, just maybe not in the same ways a girl would. And there were a lot of reasons for the way they behave that I didn’t know about before.
Some of the guys I talked to have trouble telling a girl that they like her at first, but eventually they find some way to do it.
Jorge Abreu, 16, said, “I would show my true feelings to a girl if she showed her feelings to me. But, only if I really cared about her.”
Two other guys told me that they “flirt” with girls to show them they like them, instead of just coming out and saying it.
What Flirting Means to Them
Luis Santiago, 16, said, “It’s hard for me to just say it, the words won’t come out. I’m scared the person won’t like me, so I flirt.” To him, flirting means hitting girls in a playful way.
Rosario Lecler, 16, says he flirts too, but his idea of flirting is bugging a girl. For example, he’ll take her hat or follow her around. He says, “I comes on strong…so she knows how I feel about her.”
The other guys I talked to said they talk to girls who they like “straight up.” Chris Jivers, 16, said, “I tell her a joke and just start talking to her, then I ask for her number.”
The Biggie Smalls Approach
Jorge quoted Biggie Smalls to explain what lines he uses to talk to girls. “I usually go up to the honey and ask, ‘What your interests are? Who you be wit? Things to make her smile, what numbers to dial?’ “
Two friends of mine approach girls a little more politely. Kurt Williams (not his real name), 17, goes up to a girl like a gentleman. He said, “I approach her and say excuse me, and talk to her like a person.”
Andrew Cruz (not his real name), 15, feels it’s best not to show you like a girl in front of other people. When he asks a girl out, he does so in private. “If you can’t do that,” he said, “you call her and make a date to spend time with her.”
Flowers, Poetry, Hugs and Kisses
So what things have these guys done to show a girl they like her?
Andrew said, “I’ve brought [a girl] flowers, wrote her poetry, [been] willing to drop everything for her as long as it made her happy.”
Jorge said, “I told [a] girl I cared for her and gave her many hugs and kisses.”
I asked the guys how they feel about showing affection to a girl. In my experience guys think they are too tough to do that. They think that showing emotions makes them seem like less of a man. I was surprised that some of them like showing affection.
“I love telling a girl how I feel about her,” Andrew said, “because you get your feelings out and you get that off your chest.” And, he added, “when you say something like that it always surprises them, and you can find out how they feel.”
Jorge said, “I feel good about showing affection to a girl. I always spray my girls with hugs and kisses.”
It Didn’t Last
Most guys that I’ve seen cheat on their girls, which has made me think that no guy has ever really fallen in love. But I found out some have. Unfortunately, it didn’t last very long for most of the ones I spoke with.
“I lost my first love over jealousy,” Rosario said. “I was gone for a while and when I came back my girl was always playing me. I beat up the boys [who I thought she was cheating with], only to find out later that they were visiting cousins from P.R. (Puerto Rico).”
Chris said he fell in love once, “But I broke up with her…I didn’t like her no more so I [got] rid of her.”
Andrew said that when he fell in love, “I was ready to give her everything in my power and do anything for her,” he said. But the girl wasn’t in love with him.
But none of these guys thought that having his heart broken changed the way he shows his feelings to girls now.
They’ll Settle Down. . .Someday
Most of the guys I interviewed said they want to settle down eventually, but they haven’t found the right girl yet. As Rosario said, “I have been thinking about it but I don’t know [at] what age.”
Only two guys said something really different: Kurt and Andrew.
Kurt has already found someone who has the qualities he wants in a long-term partner. “I really care for her,” he said, talking about his current girlfriend, “and I want to be with her in the future.”
And, although Andrew doesn’t have a girlfriend, he really wants to find his soulmate, settle down and be true to her. He said, “All the time, I would like to find one girl that I love and have her love me, and that would be it.”
Not Just a Guy Thing
Some of the guys I tried to interview didn’t feel comfortable answering my questions. (They must have been some of those guys who don’t feel comfortable talking about their feelings to a girl unless she is someone they really like.)
I was glad to hear from most of them that they like showing a girl how they feel. It’s just that each wants to do it in his own special way. Guys should know that if they show how they feel, it’s the most likely way to get a positive response from someone they like.
And I also want to point out to the guys out there that some girls also don’t find it easy to pour out their feelings to that special person. It’s not just a problem for guys.
Surprise, Girls: Guys Have Feelings Too
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.