Louis Pinnock (John Travolta) lives on the wrong side of the tracks. On his way home from his factory job in his decrepid pickup truck, he cruises past White drug dealers who are on the prowl, White prostitutes who are on the job and intoxicated while vagabonds who waddle through the forsaken streets as deafeaning heavy metal music blasts in the background.
Although diligent, Louis is unappreciated at the factory where he works; he has just put in two hours “off the clock” without so much as a “thank you” from his Black supervisor. His motor rumbles as he pulls into the driveway of his eyesore of a home. He thinks things can’t get any worse…then they do. A White guy in this society can’t catch a break.
Are Whites Inferior?
In White Man’s Burden, writer/directer Desmond Nakano raises the question: what if the societal roles of Whites and Blacks were reversed?
This kind of reversal has been tried in movies before. For example, in Planet of the Apes (the 1968 movie adapted from a Pierre Boulle novel), an intelligent society of apes treats members of the less intelligent human species as slaves. But White Man’s Burden is different (and better) because it addresses the issue of race more directly.
What’s going on is clear from the first scene, set in a lavish dining room where everyone, except for the maid, is Black. This is the home of Thaddeus Thomas (Harry Belafonte), the owner of the factory where Louis works. The conversation at the dining table touches on how Whites either can’t be helped or don’t want to be helped. Thaddeus seems a fair, reasonable person and speaks (sympathetically) about how Whites are socially inferior. Clearly, he and his family are not an isolated Black success story. They are members of the “ruling” class.
This message is reinforced by the depiction of life in the Pinnick home. In spite of their financial hardships, Louis and his wife Marsha (Kelly Lynch) are dedicated parents. But the film makes it clear that poverty is not the only problem they’re struggling with when the camera zeroes in on their 5-year-old son flipping through the television channels. Everyone on TV is Black. People like the Pinnicks are invisible.
A Big Misunderstanding
At the factory, Louis is counting on being promoted to foreman. He is one of the best workers there; he’s earned it. The new job would help him reach his goal of bringing a better life to his family. But when he asks his supervisor about it, he is not only denied the promotion, he is fired.
The night before, on his way home from work, Louis had been asked to deliver something to Thaddeus’s house. The place is enormous and as he wandered around trying to find the front door, he looked through a window and caught a glimpse of Thaddeus’s half-dressed wife. The supervisor accuses Louis of being a “peeping Tom.”
Stumbling upon the wrong window was not Louis’s fault, this is made clear. Louis goes back back to convince Thaddeus that the whole thing was a misunderstanding but he can’t even get in to see him.
Louis Gets His Gun
Louis spends the next few weeks on a long and unsuccessful job hunt. He gets more and more desperate and sinks deeper and deeper into debt until, in a dramatic scene, the Pinnock family is evicted from their shanty. This a scene that stands out-the family is given no time to evacuate the premises and the authorities who’ve come to throw them out trample on both their belongings and their dignity.
Not knowing what else to do, Louis gets a gun and goes to Thaddeus’s house to demand money. The confused Thaddeus is unaware that he had fired Louis. (In fact, the firing had been the supervisor’s idea, not his.) Sticking a revolver to Thaddeus’ head, Louis feels empowered. He has gained control over a man who previously wouldn’t spare him two minutes to discuss the fate of his job.
Louis kidnaps Thaddeus. Alone together over the next two days, the two men discover that they are a lot alike. They even end up discussing their families and their values over greasy cheeseburgers in a cheap diner. But the circumstances that brought them together will not permit them to end up as friends.
This is a film which you must watch with an open mind. It just might teach you something new about the “other” race. It taught me that we still have a long way to go before we fully acknowledge how much our differences have to do with our “place” in society.
Films like Menace 2 Society, Juice, and Boyz N The Hood depict problems in the Black community like violence, drugs, and poverty. But these films don’t show the causes of these problems. For that reason, some viewers may assume that Blacks themselves are somehow to blame. White Man’s Burden suggests that it is the condition that you are born into and live with day-to-day, not your skin color, that determines how you behave and what becomes of you.
“White Man’s Burden”: Our World Turned Upside Down
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.