Who Would You Rather Be: Miss America or Madame President?

In 1920, two things happened that changed the lives of American women forever. Seventy-five years later, during the summer of 1995, one anniversary was celebrated with a live televised show for all of America to enjoy and appreciate. The other anniversary was largely ignored by the media and most of America.
What were these two events? The first one was the Miss America Pageant, which gave women an opportunity to show their “talents” (especially how good they look in scanty swimsuits with tons of makeup and plastered-on smiles) and delighted men all over America. The other event was the passage of the 19th Amendment, which gave women, to the dismay of many men, the right to vote.
The pageant celebrated its big anniversary with a “controversy” over the swimsuit competition. This year’s live show featured a telephone number people could call to vote on whether it should be dropped from the pageant.
Swimsuits or Business Suits?
It probably was not a surprise to anyone, especially women, that viewers overwhelmingly voted to keep the competition. After all, even 75 years after women got the right to participate in government, America is still a place where it’s more common to see women walk down runways in swimsuits than walk up the stairs of the White House in business suits.
How was the 75th anniversary of women’s suffrage celebrated? As far as I know, there were no big parades, no Macy’s fireworks, no major speeches by anyone important. It amazes me that something as monumental as the passage of a constitutional amendment giving half the American population the right to vote was totally disregarded by most Americans.
Sarah DiTroia, associate director of media at Planned Parenthood, New York, told me that there were a few events celebrating the anniversary. Planned Parenthood and other women’s groups fittingly sponsored a voter registration drive on August 26, the day the amendment was signed into law. But most of the other events were award ceremonies, closed off to the general public.
How Far Have We Really Come?
There should have been a nationally televised show about women’s suffrage, celebrating how far women have come in 75 years and examining how far we have yet to go. Instead all we got was a show that degrades women by judging them on how great their bodies are.
Yes, the contestants are asked to answer a few thought-provoking questions. (As though it’s really possible to give a serious answer to a question like “How would you end racism?” in 10 seconds!) It’s also true that the Miss America Organization gives out more than $24 million a year in scholarships. But why couldn’t the women be judged solely on their intelligence, their accomplishments and their true talents, instead of their bodies? Another big problem I have: Why isn’t there a Mr. America Pageant, with 50 guys parading around in swimsuits and tuxedos?
One of the reasons for the almost complete public indifference to the suffrage movement may be that we don’t know much about it. The struggle for women’s right to vote is largely forgotten by American society.
Demonstrations, Arrests, Hunger Strikes. . .
Most of us have probably learned the big names, such as Susan B. Anthony or Elizabeth Cady Stanton, and what they did for the movement. But our textbooks and teachers don’t always talk about the hundreds of other women who participated in countless demonstrations in front of the White House, who were arrested and humiliated, and who went on hunger strikes (and then were often brutally force-fed) in the course of the fight for the right to vote.
It’s important for today’s women to realize how long and hard the struggle to gain that right was. It took 72 years from the first step, the Seneca Falls Convention of 1848, to the final victory, the ratification of the 19th Amendment.
But many women today take their right to vote for granted. Eligible voters tend to vote only in national elections and ignore the smaller local elections, which tend to affect their lives more directly. For example, 59% of the voters who voted in 1992 (a presidential election year) but did not vote in 1994 (Congressional and local races) were women.
But Still No Female President
How far have American women really come over the past 75 years? Our government still doesn’t proportionately represent the country’s population. Although women are 51% of the American population, they only make up 11% of the members of the U.S. House of Representatives, 7% of U.S. Senators, and 8% of governors.
1995 was also the year of the U.N. women’s conference in Beijing. During a speech there, Hillary Clinton spoke out against the atrocities being committed against women in China (for example, women are sometimes sterilized against their will and female babies are sometimes killed because families are only allowed one child and males are considered more valuable).
But are things that much better for women in America? Nations all over the world, including England, India, Canada and Israel, have had female leaders. But America has yet to have a female president. Sexual harassment, domestic violence and rape are still prevalent in our society, with women being the vast majority of the victims.
And something as old-fashioned as the Miss America Pageant still exists. The contestants are role models to the females of the country. And in many ways, they are positive ones. This year’s pageant featured four future doctors, four future lawyers, and many aspiring teachers. But I wonder how many viewers knew that or if they really cared?
And what about the idea that Miss America is supposed to be the “perfect” American woman? In an age when disorders like anorexia and bulimia are very common among women, isn’t it foolish to project the idea that all women should strive to have bodies like Miss America? To me, the pageant (as flaky and entertaining as it may be) demonstrates that women are still valued more for our bodies than for our brains.
We Got the Vote-Let’s Use It
All of this is not to say that American women haven’t achieved anything since 1920. Since they won the right to vote, women, as a group, have used that right to make a difference on issues that affect women’s health (research on breast cancer) and family issues (childcare at work, paid leave to take care of sick children). But, as DiTroia of Planned Parenthood pointed out, the original suffragists would have been disappointed by the current low level of female participation in politics.
Women still have a long way to go before achieving complete equality with men. Women (and men) need to educate ourselves on issues that concern women, such as reproductive freedom and welfare reform. We need to actively participate in our government to ensure that it addresses those issues.
One of the reasons women are not represented in our government is because not that many women are running for office. More of us need to do that. And our participation doesn’t just have to be at the national level. Women can and should get involved at the local level: their school boards, city councils, etc.
Only 43% of eligible women voted in the last presidential election. That’s not a good sign. We need to realize how important it is to vote and to participate in government. The next presidential election comes in November, 1996. And having your say in that election is as easy as registering to vote and casting a ballot.
Many women fought long and hard for the right to vote. Now it’s up to the women of today to start using that right to make a difference.

SIDEBAR
Brief History of the Suffrage Movement

The fight for women’s suffrage in the U.S. can be traced back to a convention held in Seneca Falls, New York, in July of 1848. The meeting, arranged by women leaders of the time such as Lucretia Mott and Elizabeth Cady Stanton, was a forum to discuss women’s rights and their social, civil and religious condition. The 68 women and 32 men who attended the event debated and then adopted the Declaration of Sentiments, a document that proclaimed that both men and women are created equal. (The Declaration of Independence said “All men are created equal.”) During the Civil War, the suffrage movement was temporarily suspended and the women leaders worked with abolitionists to end slavery. The passage of the 15th Amendment, which gave Black men the right to vote, caused a rift among the suffragists, with one group supporting the amendment and the other opposing it because it did not mention women. In 1878, the “Anthony Amendment” for women’s suffrage (which later became the 19th Amendment) was introduced in Congress. It wasn’t until 40 years later, in 1918, that the U.S. House of Representatives passed it. The next year, the U.S. Senate approved the amendment. And finally, in 1920, the 19th Amendment, granting American women the right to vote, was ratified by the states and became law. It read: “The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States on account of sex.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.