When a Group Home Closes: Like Losing Our Families Again

In June I was told that my group home in the Bronx would be closing down by the end of the summer due to budget cuts. A staff person from the agency called a meeting to tell us the news, though some of us had already heard rumors. He told us not to worry, that we would still be taken care of and moved to another group home. But at that point, it was still too early for him or anyone else to say where we would go.
When an agency makes the decision to close a group home, they are taking away people’s homes and jobs, but I feel they may not realize the affect it has on us. Many residents have had to alter our lives many times because we’ve lost our families and homes-and when a group home closes, we’re losing them all over again.
When I heard my group home was closing I was confused. It appeared to me that the other residents were, too. Some of the girls, including me, started to cry. We couldn’t understand why this was happening to us.
When you hear something as upsetting as this, your heart races as if it’s the end of the world. You want to be told exactly what is going to happen to you, like where and when you are going to be moved, and whatever else pops into your mind.
A Close Attachment
I turned 21 years old in September and would have had to leave the group home anyway, but I was still hurt. This has been my home for two years. I have grown and matured here. Some of the staff members went beyond the call of duty to make that group home a home-like setting for us.
I had developed a close attachment to the residents and staff, which is very hard to do in the foster care system. It felt like my entire family was being split apart. I felt helpless; there wasn’t anything we could do about it-our group home was closing regardless.
I interviewed residents and staff to find out how they felt when they were told the group home was closing.
At first it appeared to me as if the residents were suffering but the staff were dealing with it all right. But after I interviewed some staff members, I learned that they were hurting almost as much as the residents.
The three staff members I interviewed are: Ms. Barbara Montana, 41, a child-care worker who has worked with the agency for nine years; Ms. Sherry Best, 23, a social worker who has been with the agency for 10 months; and Mr. Eugene Hunter, 58, a supervisor who has worked with Sheltering Arms for 17 years.
Tamecka: What was your first reaction to the closing of the group home?
Ms. Best: After I heard the house was closing in that manner I was really shocked.
Mr. Hunter: After my director told me…I was in a state of shock…You would never think that something like this could happen. This is a good program and the girls really benefited from this house.
Tamecka: How will this affect you?
Mr. Hunter: I am going to get laid off. It’s really going to affect me because I looked forward to coming here every morning.
Tamecka: What impact has the closing had on the residents?
Ms. Montana: We were a family and all of a sudden we were being torn apart. It felt as if nobody wanted [the residents] anymore, like they gave up on them.
Ms. Best: Many of the residents are frightened because they don’t have any family to go home to. For some residents, this had been their home for many years. They are wondering where they are going to go. At this point the residents are reaching out to undesirables for protection, because they feel they won’t have a place to live.
Mr. Hunter: The residents don’t know what they are going to do. They’re AWOL, getting angry with the staff; they are also working things out on their own.
Tamecka: How have you helped the residents deal with the closing of the group home?
Ms. Montana: It wasn’t too much I could say, we were all walking around like zombies. We were all just shocked.
Ms. Best: Myself, the childcare workers, the manager, the supervisor and clinician (psychologist) are meeting with the residents and talking about their feelings surrounding the closing of the group home. In those meetings we discuss future plans, placements and places they would like to be, and we also talk about alternatives. We ask the residents to think about what life would be like when the group home closes. There are tears, they fear they will endure more hardship. One person is not enough to help the residents, it’s a team project.
Tamecka: What do you have to say to the residents who are still in fear?
Ms. Best: I’ll just let them know that it’s not the end of the world, to move on and make the best out of what they have to work with. One thing they are not going to be is on the streets.
Tamecka: Any last comments?
Mr. Hunter: I am going to miss having our annual anniversary that’s held in October and also our annual Bar-B-Que that we have every summer. These events are like homecoming for many of the staff and residents. All of this has come to an end and it’s too bad.
* * *
I also interviewed several residents of my former group home: Vanessa Agee, 16, who has been in foster care for 11 months; Betzaida Santana, 18, who has been in foster care for six years and in five group homes; Denise Archbold, 20, has been in seven group homes since she was 12 years old; Carlean Francois, 18, has been in foster care for three years and in three different group homes; and Monique Allen, 25, a former resident.
Tamecka: How do you feel about moving again?
Vanessa: I don’t like moving because this is my first group home and it’s really nice.
Betzaida: I feel more hurt than anything because it’s now that I’m getting myself together. I’m a senior in high school…I’m currently working …and I’m also considered one of the elite girls of the agency and everything is going good for me.
Tamecka: What was your first reaction when you discovered your group home was closing?
Vanessa: Oh my God! I felt very bad, because I was thinking, where would we go? Would we have a place to live? And also how would we survive?
Denise: I was upset, I was crying, and also I was moody because I don’t have a place to go.
Carlean: I was mad, I cried a little, and was thinking, “Where am I going to live?” I feel left in the cold and abandoned because I really can’t handle being out on my own right now…because I don’t know what to do.
Tamecka: What do you or did you think would happen to you when the group home closes?
Denise: I thought and still feel a little that I’ll be on the streets.
Monique: I’m losing a father [speaking about the supervisor] and he’s losing his job and I’m sorry about that.
Tamecka: Has anyone helped you cope with the closing of the group home?
Betzaida: [My] social worker. She sits down and talks to me and encourages me, but she really doesn’t have much information.
Carlean: Yes, but they speak in general, not [about] what is going to happen to me.
Tamecka: Do you feel prepared to deal with the group home closing?
Vanessa: Yes, because I already got it in my mind that the house is closing and I know I have to find some place that’s going to work out for me.
Denise: No, because I’m not financially prepared and I don’t have a job.
Carlean: Yes and then no…I’ve been out on my own before, but I always had the group home to fall back on.
Tamecka: Any last comments?
Betzaida: I just hope all the girls end up somewhere that doesn’t get them down because living in the system you can get brought down a lot.
Carlean: I am mostly concerned about the staff and what’s going to happen to them. I may not show it but it’s the staff that I really care for…They’re like my parents.
* * *
So, as you see, everyone is emotionally affected by this. Some people take it personally, others are tired of being shuffled around the system. After building up that togetherness, you don’t want to pick up and move again where you may not get that same type of closeness.
On the day we first heard the news, while we were getting ready for bed, most of the girls were discussing their feelings of abandonment. Most were totally scared. Some thought they would be thrown out on the street, others that they would have to find an apartment or place to live. All of these fears are understandable when you’ve discovered your home is being taken away.
But if you or someone you know is in a group home that’s closing, there are some things you should know that might help you avoid the fear we felt: No matter when or how a group home closes, you will be taken care of until your 21st birthday. And, although you may want to know everything at once about where you’ll be going, your agency may not tell you anything while they’re working on new placements. All of this takes time, so while you may have been told that your group home is closing, things are still being worked out.
When an agency decides it must close a group home, it investigates various options for each resident. Those include: placement in another of the agency’s group homes; placement with another agency that has a similar program to fit the individual’s needs; returning to the family or another relative if possible.
As of now, all the girls from my group home were placed either in another group home within my agency, with family members, or in different agencies. Some of the staff moved to the agency’s other group home and the rest were laid off.

SIDEBAR: What You Should Know About College Financial Aid
If you’re going away to college, it’s important to find out exactly what financial support you’ll be receiving so you can budget properly and avoid running out of money. It can be confusing for kids in foster care to figure out what they’re entitled to when they go away to school. As Tamecka pointed out in her article, some agencies give different types of college financial aid than others. The one thing that is the same for everyone is that your agency will pay for your college room and board (food) if you live in a dorm. You are eligible for this money until you turn 21 (up to $526 a month, paid directly to the school). Other financial support you may be entitled to (and should ask about) includes: independent living checks ($30-40 per month); clothing allowance (varies); grants for books and supplies (varies). Any additional spending money for college is up to individual agencies. (Remember, college financial aid packages may also cover additional school-related costs.) The best bet to avoid confusion about financial aid is to talk to your school or agency’s college advisor, and call the free college counseling centers.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.