A Lighter Shade of Black

I was sitting with some friends watching MTV Jams, when a Babyface video came on.
“He looks good,” said Shamika. “Why he have to be married?”
“I know, right,” said Crystal. “And to that light-skinned b-ch.”
“I’m sayin’,” said Shamika, while they both laughed.
Shamika looked at me, but I wasn’t laughing. I’m a light-skinned girl, the only one in the room that day, and I didn’t see the humor in their joke.
“Of course you know we like you,” said Shamika. It’s just “some light-skinned girls think that they’re the bomb.”
These girls were my friends. Usually I felt comfortable with them, but it was obvious they had a problem with light-skinned girls. Suddenly, I felt like maybe I didn’t belong here, maybe I wasn’t really welcome.
I’ve had to deal with feeling like I didn’t belong since I was a child. Comments such as “White girl,” “yellow,” and “whitey” make me feel like I’m unwelcome among Black people. Even in my own family, my brothers and sisters are always saying that I’m the “whitest.”
On one hand, I know they mean I’m the lightest-skinned person in the family, but sometimes it feels like what they’re really saying is I’m too “White,” and too different from the rest of the family.
How Black is Black Enough?
I never really thought about my skin color until I was 10 years old. I was visiting my grandmother in the Bronx. While resting on the porch with my cousin and some other little girls from the neighborhood, a Latino girl with light-brown skin looked at her arm and said, “I need a tan.”
“I don’t need to get a tan,” said a darker-skinned Black girl. “I’m naturally tanned.” Then she looked at me.
“She’s the one who needs a tan,” she said grabbing my arm. “Look, you can see the veins through her skin.”
It hit me then that I was the lightest one there. I felt out of place, like I was not as Black as I should be.
For the rest of the summer I tried to get darker. I sat on our fire escape every Sunday, and went to the beach as often as I could. I did get darker, but when I returned to my grandmother’s those girls never even noticed.
That September, I went to P.S. 192 in Brooklyn. Most of the students were Latino. I wanted to fit in, so I told everyone there that I was Puerto Rican. If they found out I was Black, I was afraid they wouldn’t be my friend.
I Thought I Was Puerto Rican
That year, a part of me really started to believe I was Puerto Rican. But the following summer, my mom sent me and my brothers and sister to day camp near where she worked. Almost all the other kids were White. The first day they stared at us like we didn’t belong there, and by the end of summer I knew that even though I was light-skinned, I was still Black.
I was 11 years old but I still didn’t really feel accepted by other Blacks. As I got older, comments like the ones my friends made about Babyface’s wife were more and more common. It always makes me angry, because I feel singled out.
But there’s more to being light-skinned than just nasty comments. I’ve learned that even though I don’t want it, sometimes I’m treated better than darker-skinned Blacks. My freshman year in high school, I worked at the school library. The head librarian was a short-tempered White woman with blue-rimmed glasses. If she caught you talking, she would yell and embarrass you in front of everyone.
I worked with a darker-skinned girl, who was just as good as me, but the librarian made her work a lot harder. She would tell the darker-skinned girl to re-shelve books, which is very tiring, while I got to stand behind the desk and check books out.
Special Treatment
I disliked the librarian, because of her impatience and her favoritism. I also felt guilty, because the other girl worked twice as hard. I was too embarrassed to talk to her about it though.
By favoring me, the librarian was giving me the chance to belong with people like her. I wanted to turn my back on her offer, because I felt it was unfair that I was having an easier time at my friend’s expense. In the end, I quit my job, so I wouldn’t have to deal with the librarian.
Even within my own family I’ve noticed that differences in skin color sometimes come between us. My sister, Maryam, has darker skin than me and dark brown hair. Now that she is 13, she complains about her looks, especially her hair, at least once a day.
It started when she and I got our hair relaxed, cut, and styled at the JC Penney styling salon in Queens.
Bonita, the hairdresser, did Maryam’s hair first. She told my sister that her hair was coarse and broken and cut about one and a half inches off. But when Bonita got to me she said, “Your hair is not as bad as your sister’s. Hers was really damaged.”
Good Hair/Bad Hair?
My sister heard what Bonita said and watched as she styled my long hair. I think Maryam felt angry while she watched Bonita work.
“You still have long hair,” Maryam said when we were finished. “But mine is short and ugly.”
I felt bad about myself when I heard my sister say that. She doesn’t see her own beauty, because she sees what they call beautiful on TV, which is mostly White women, sometimes light-skinned women, and hardly any dark-skinned women at all.
My sister’s experience showed me that darker-skinned girls might not feel as though they belong either, because they do not live up to an American standard of beauty which mostly calls for blond hair and blue eyes.
But, unlike my sister, I’ve had to ask myself again and again where do I belong, and who do I really want to be with. I wonder how my life would be if I felt accepted by other Black people. I don’t know when I will ever get that feeling of belonging, but I hope someday I will find myself with people who can accept me for who I am.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.