Doing Social Work in the Subway

Gary Mallon, DSW, is Assistant Professor at the Columbia University School of Social Work and continues to be affiliated with Green Chimneys Children’s Services.
I love the New York City subway. It’s a great place to learn about people and maybe even learn about yourself. The other day, while riding the Number 1 train, I had an experience which really made me stop and think. You know the story-a man in his mid-30s, very pale, wearing a plastic hospital bracelet, moving from one car to another with a paper cup:
“Hi, I’m sorry to bother you. My name is Mike.”
I thought to myself, Oh, no, another sad story. There are so many sad stories in New York that you get weary of them, even goodhearted people get weary. Then he continued:
“I was just released from St. Mary’s hospital today. I have AIDS. I have no place to live, I have nowhere to go, and I really need help…”
Lost Feelings
His voice choked with emotion, his eyes welled up with tears, and so did mine. I was moved. His story made me feel bad. I guess in some ways I related to his pain because I have lost so many friends to AIDS. I reached into my wallet and gave the man $5. I usually don’t do that, but this man got to me.
Even though I have worked in a foster care agency for 20 years, I hadn’t, for a long time, allowed my feelings to guide me in my work with people. Because I am an administrator, more often than not I found myself worrying about whether the paperwork was completed and whether or not we were following all of the rules, and that realization made me sad. I realized that in some ways I had lost sight of why I originally wanted to work with people.
Difficult Stories
Like so many of us who had grown up in the ’60s, I got into this work because I wanted to help people. I thought that helping people made the world a better place. I still believe that, but I realize now that I was unprepared for many of the things that I saw.
Working in foster care forces you to deal with many things that most people only read about in newspapers. Nothing prepared me for the boy whose hands were badly disfigured because his mother’s boyfriend got angry at him for being too noisy and burned them over an open flame on a stove; or the young woman whose uncle repeatedly sexually abused her; or the gay teen who had to hide who he was because he was afraid of getting beat up if anyone “found out”; or the little boy who lost the vision in one eye because his mother hit him in the head with a pipe. All of these stories and the thousands of others that I heard were shocking and disturbing.
In an effort to deal with this sadness, I realized that I had learned to turn off my emotions. Working in foster care is hard work and even if you try to turn off your emotions, it is an emotional business.
Whenever I tell people what I do they usually say, “Oh, that must be so rewarding.” I don’t always say it, but most times I think, Not always. I’m not saying that the work that we do is not worthwhile. It is, but on an everyday basis, it is not always rewarding. It can be a very draining and upsetting business.
It is certainly not rewarding to have people viciously curse you out, hit you, throw things at you, and, in some cases, attack you. I would definitely say that it is the least favorite part of my job. When I really feel drained and burned out, I have to stop myself and think about why I want to keep doing this. I guess the answer lies in the fact that, despite the drawbacks, I still love what I am doing. I still feel that I am making a difference. I still feel that even though it is hard, the work that I am doing is meaningful. I still feel that I am doing my part in helping to make someone’s life better.
The other evening, in another subway encounter, I had an opportunity to realize this again. As I entered the C train at 59th St., I sat down and immediately became absorbed in my book when I heard a voice say:
“Gary, is that you?”
I looked up and saw the face of a young man whom I did not immediately recognize, because he was much older than when I last saw him seven years ago, but the voice was familiar. I said:
“Jimmy, how are you doing?”
He told me he was living in his own apartment and that he had just celebrated his 22nd birthday. Jimmy was one of those kids who you don’t forget. He was a really difficult kid. In fact, he was one of the most difficult kids I have even worked with. As we talked, he said:
“You know, I made a lot of mistakes when I was at Green Chimneys. I was really pretty messed up back then. I made even more mistakes when I left Green Chimneys. I had a big drug problem, but I went to rehab for 18 months and I’m doing great now. I’ve been clean for over two years. I have two jobs, I’m supporting myself, and I have a really nice girlfriend.”
He wanted me to know that he had done well and I was really glad to hear that. To be honest, he was doing much better than I would have predicted. I actually talk about him a lot, because he was so difficult that he did a lot of memorable things. But what he said next, right before I had to get off the train, is what I will remember about him the next time I talk about him. He said:
“Gary, even though I was a real pain when I lived at Green Chimneys, I want you and any of the other staff who are still there to know that I really did learn from all of you. You taught me a lot and some days when I was really down, I remembered what you all told me and it helped, it really helped me. And I’m not just saying that, I really mean it.”
I guess that knowing I have made a difference is the reward that people are always talking about, and when all is said and done, that’s reward enough for me.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.