My Typical Chinese Father: He Provided Everything But Affection

As far back as I can remember, I’ve considered my father to be no more than a provider. Maybe that wasn’t the case early on. I’m told stories about how, back when I was less than 4 and we still lived in Hong Kong, my father would take me jogging and to play every Sunday afternoon. But since coming over to the U.S., I haven’t done much with him, have hardly even talked with him.
Technically, he’s a great father. My mother knows I’ve never loved him, but to get me to be fair, she defends his behavior. “He’s not really that bad,” she’ll say. “He doesn’t smoke, gamble, waste money, or beat you. And he loves you all.”
I appreciated all these qualities, but I wondered why we lacked a bond, the typical father-and-son love. I couldn’t even answer a question of his while watching television because talking to him was so out of the ordinary, such a struggle.
He’s No Fun
There were times when my mom told me she understood how my father is, and how closely he identifies with the typical Chinese father. In Chinese tradition, a good father is a good provider above all else. He is to be respected, not necessarily loved. Money and his ability to work are the qualities to look at, not how open he is, or how he handles children.
I ignored all that bring-home-the-bacon nonsense. What I wanted was a father who would drag me off my sofa, take me out on a weekend afternoon and teach me to play ball instead of constantly chanting, “Did you do your homework?” I could see no fun in my father, and being a child, that meant I saw nothing good in him.
Besides his personality, I suspect it was also his constant hours at work that made our relationship so distant. We were an immigrant family, and my father was not afraid to earn his share of wealth. (He started out working in a restaurant; now he owns five apartment buildings.) He would leave at around 7 in the morning, come back at 8 at night and go to bed at 10 p.m. sharp. He hardly spoke, and when he did, nothing he said concerned me. He didn’t exist in my world of hot dogs and television.
Siding With Grandma
Another reason for the distance is my grandmother. I am close to her and they despise each other. She hates my father for his arrogance, short temper, and restrictiveness. He hates my grandma because she smokes, drinks, gambles, and flies back to Hong Kong often (tickets aren’t cheap and my mother gives her the money for them).
They behave calmly and kindly when in each other’s presence but when my grandma and I talk, we wind up complaining about him. It seems inevitable that I would take her side against him. All conversations I had about family problems were with my mom and grandma; how could I sympathize with a man whom I didn’t speak with?
But something happened recently that got us talking to each other, an incident that made communicating with my father a lot easier.
A few months ago, I decided that I needed a new computer. My father agreed to buy it, being extremely concerned with my education. I couldn’t risk getting him upset until I got the computer on my desk, so I talked to him much more often than I normally did.
A Big Disappointment
On the day that he had said we would go pick up the computer, I came straight home and waited. I sat on the couch talking with my sister, feeling a mix of expectation, excitement, and after two hours, impatience. The store closes at 7 p.m., I thought; it was getting late. Finally, the door opened and my father came in. “Are we getting the computer today?” I asked. He looked at the clock and said, “No. It’s too late. They’re closed now.”
He went to the bathroom, and I paced to the kitchen, where my grandma was. “Three hours!” I said to her, with three fingers raised. “Three hours, all gone, and nothing to show for it.” I paced back, head down, as I passed the open bathroom door.
I went back downstairs soon after, and saw my father leaning against a table, arms and legs crossed, facing the door I had just come through. “What did you mean when you told your grandma ‘three hours’?” he asked. I paused to gather myself together (being a little surprised as well as loaded down with an armful of laundry) and told him I had waited for him for three hours.
He’s Human!
“You said three days ago that you’d be getting it with me today, so I came straight home and waited,” I explained.
“But why did you go off and tell her that? Why didn’t you just tell me?” he asked.
I had to pause again, but felt comfortable enough to smile a little. “She’s spent the whole day at home and saw me waiting the entire afternoon. Besides, I feel comfortable talking with her.” And I went into how I can say stupid things to her and get away with it, whereas with him, I had to be careful.
While I spoke, he looked around, hands in his pockets. His response was a monologue also, during which I couldn’t look him in the eye. I stood with my laundry in my arms, analyzing the cracks in the ceiling boards. He asked me whether the only way he could get me to talk with him was by buying a computer. I felt awful right then, though I was more surprised than hurt. I realized my father was human.
“Shut Up and Eat”
After he interrogated me on how I felt about my mom, my grandma, and himself. “You really don’t understand how I feel, do you?” he asked. He walked away, but I wasn’t going to let go of this moment we were having so soon, without a decent finish.
“Come on,” I said. “You can’t just leave like that. Let’s talk some more.” The phone rang right then. I don’t know if he would have turned around and continued our talk if it hadn’t. But it did and the talk ended. Still, it was enough to make me realize he wasn’t a robot who brought home the money and fed us. He was a man with emotions and a voice.
There’s a little bit more to that day. At dinnertime, even though it’s not considered polite for Chinese people to talk then, I turned to my father and said, “I know this isn’t the best time, but let’s continue the talk we had earlier, huh?” “Eat your food,” he said.
But I was hyped for the task of stitching the family together, and so I just smiled and prepared to ask the same of everyone. My mom also told me to keep eating, though in a tone of frustration, not anger. And my grandma agreed. After one last, loud protest by my father, I continued eating.
A Real Conversation
A month or so later, my father and I had another talk. I was in my room playing games on my computer, and he came up and knocked at my door.
“What are you doing?” he asked through the crack I allowed him.
“Nothing much. Just looking at some reports,” I said, motioning to a few journals laying on my bed.
“Using the computer?”
“No; it’s just doing something while I’m waiting.”
“Do you have school tomorrow?”
“Yeah. I have to hand in a report.”
“Why didn’t you do that today?”
“I still had to finish it up.”
“What time are you getting there?”
“By 12.”
“What time are you leaving?”
“At 10.”
He nodded and said, “I was just thinking maybe we could go to the restaurant tomorrow morning and have a little talk.” He paused. “Can I come in?”
The Story of His Life
I was concerned that he was suspecting me of some crime I’d forgotten I’d done, and had come up to accuse me of it. I was preparing for my own personal inquisition. But after he came in and sat down on my bed, he said, “I want you to know what your mother wants from me. She asked me to buy your grandma a house.”
He went on, carrying me through his life with my mom, from the wedding dinner to the present. He showed his frustration with having his own children dislike him, and started crying when he mentioned the time my brother was asked, “Who earns the money in your house?” and my brother replied, “Grandma.”
I sat without looking at him throughout the conversation. I responded to his questions, and glanced at him now and then, but it was his monologue, his summary of his life, and I was not going to interrupt. This was my father, unadulterated and honest.
He asked me, “Do you think I should buy her the house?” I said, “No.” How I really felt didn’t matter. I couldn’t even consider adding another disappointment to his list.
As he left, I smiled and got up, telling him, “If you ever need to talk, feel free to come up and talk with me. I absolutely don’t mind.” He nodded without turning his head to me and left my room.
We’ve Made Progress
Since then, my father and I have been talking much more than we ever have. He and I even joke with each other sometimes. We haven’t had another real conversation like we did that day, but the everyday exchanges that used to be so painful are now more natural.
There is still an uneasiness between us, though. Unlike with my mom and grandma, I can’t criticize him, or be blunt with him. He has a bad temper, and doesn’t like to be insulted, or even questioned. And whenever I say something that doesn’t go along with his ideas, he says, “You just don’t understand, do you?”
Recently, during a car ride home, we had a little talk. He told me my grandma had compared my mother to a “worker” for him since coming to America. He asked me if it was right of her to say that. I said I didn’t know. “I’m too young to understand these things,” I told him. He shook his head. “You just don’t understand,” he said.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.