They are nerds with glasses and pocket protectors (to guard against ink stains) who walk around muttering “E=MC2.”
They are gangsters with rings on their fingers and slicked-back hair parted in the middle.
They are wannabes, who wear clothes from J. Crew or the Gap, have two hairs coming down their faces and try desperately to act “cool” as they smoke, Rollerblade or play ultimate Frisbee.
Who are they? The characters in the latest spin-off from the TV show Beverly Hills 90210? Not quite. They’re just your average stereotypical Asian American guys.
As Jie Yi Zeng, 16, of Stuyvesant HS, put it, “They are totally ugly, totally possessive [in a relationship], spoiled, traditional, geniuses in math and science, passive, detached [and] aloof.” Not to mention nerdy, skinny, gangster-like and asexual.
Nothing To Do With Me
Nearly all of the Asian guys I interviewed for this story were aware of these stereotypes, but they also believe the images didn’t really affect their lives. (Or so they said.)
Not sensual? Try telling that to Paul Wong, an 18-year-old Chinese-American. He says, “I am not asexual. Just ask my mom who has to help me dodge those silly girls with their jealous streaks.”
Passive? Well, you better not mess with Raymond Chan, 18, a CUNY student. “I’m not a wimp and I’ll beat [up] anyone who says that I am,” he says.
These guys do what they want, when they want, and they don’t let the stereotypes stop them from, well, sometimes doing stereotypical things. Eldee Khowong, 15, of Hunter HS, likes having the slicked-back “gangster” hairstyle, but says that doesn’t mean he’s a gang member. And Kent Ho, 16, of Murry Bergtraum HS, says there’s two parts to him: the one who’s “smart in school” and the one who’s “streetwise.”
The guys did admit they have to deal with people (mostly non-Asians) who believe the stereotypes are true. Their response? Kent says, “Most of the time I’ll say ‘F-k you’.” Or, he adds, “I’ll ignore them and brush it off cause you can’t help other people’s ignorance.”
Many Asian girls I interviewed, however, say that there’s more truth to the stereotypes than the guys want to admit. They say, for example, that Asian guys are often spoiled (by parents) and bossy (with women). Most of the girls acknowledge that it’s because Asian cultures have traditionally favored men.
What the Girls Say
In Chinese culture, for example, says Jie Yi, the Stuyvesant student, boys “have always been cherished by parents” because they carry the family name. In her family, the parents spoil her older brother, who’s also the only son. It doesn’t help matters that Jie Yi’s brother has some traditional expections of his own, like a future wife who will cook, clean, and take care of him.
This kind of attitude definitely bothers Jennifer (not her real name), 16, also of Stuyvesant. She believes that all Asian guys at her high school “will grow up to be their fathers-strict and traditional.” They might be Americanized on the outside, she adds, but they “will boss the wife around.” She wants guys to let the woman be her own person.
Believe It. . .Or Not
Jennifer was the one girl I interviewed who “totally believed all the stereotypes” about Asian guys. She says her attitude towards them probably has a lot do with her ambivalence about being Asian. “I went to an elementary school [which was] all White,” says Jennifer, who’s Korean-American. “I was the only Asian kid. I was always ashamed about Asian stuff.”
Other girls said they were more open to dating Asian guys. “I don’t have an anti-Asian guy attitude,” says Millicent Cho, 17, of Stuyvesant HS. “Not all of them are dorks.”
But none of the guys said that they wanted to date traditional girls. In fact, Paul says, “I’ll date any girl with a good heart and a big brain!”
Russell Wong and Brandon Lee
Still there seems to be a grain of truth to these stereotypes. I have to say that a lot of Asian guys I have known have some of these characteristics. But there’s also a lot more to them than that. Asian guys are not all ridiculous cartoon characters, as the stereotypes make them out to be.
Asian guys ugly? Anyone who has seen Russell Wong in the Vanishing Son TV series or Brandon Lee in the film The Crow can attest to the fact that Asian guys can be really cute. (True, both actors are mixed-Asian and White-but they definitely look Asian.)
Asian guys are math and science nerds? I don’t know how well Gus Lee did in his math classes, but I know he can write pretty well. Just look at his novel China Boy about a boy growing up in San Francisco, who goes to the local Y to learn boxing and ends up learning about life.
Asian guys are gangsters? Lance Ito, the judge presiding over the O.J. Simpson trial, is probably more used to throwing gangsters in jail.
Even Jennifer admits that she has a cousin in California who’s not the stereotypical Asian guy. “He doesn’t go with the flow,” she says. “He has his own style.”
So the next time you meet an Asian guy who happens to wear glasses and has a pocket protector, talk to him before writing him off as the typical nerd. You may find out that he listens to the Stone Temple Pilots, and that he’s an incredibly good basketball player!
Just Your Stereotypical Asian Guy? Not!
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.