A Black/White Relationship: Were We Too Different? (Part I)

When I was younger I had this sort of sick vision that all my boyfriends would be White with blond hair and blue eyes. It wasn’t because I was prejudiced, but because that’s what my Ken dolls and the heroes on Saturday morning cartoons looked like.
As I grew up, I never fantasized about a Black, Hispanic, or Asian man. It never occurred to me that I could be with someone different. All my friends were White, and of course, the main male figure in my life-my dad-was White too. By sixth grade I realized I didn’t really like the “California” look, but preferred dark hair and eyes. But still white skin. I wasn’t exposed to anything else.
All this began to change when I turned 15 and made a new best friend, Kelly, who is Dominican. Kelly was a hip-hop maniac, raised on rap. At first I couldn’t understand how she could listen to anything but rock music. But she finally got me into it and soon enough Black Sheep and EPMD dominated my tape racks.
Smooth, Sweet-Talking, and Gorgeous
With this introduction to hip-hop and reggae came another introduction: Black men. Kelly had been going to rap and reggae dance clubs for a while, and she knew many Black guys. I started to hang out with them more and more. They were smooth, sweet-talking, cultured, and physically gorgeous. I wondered why I had never paid attention to them before.
Last summer, Kelly and a few other friends suggested we go to a reggae club in Harlem. I was kind of nervous since this would be my first mainly Black party, but my friends reassured me, and my twin sister agreed to come along.
I was glad I didn’t back out. I felt totally comfortable, and danced all night. When my friends went to the bathroom I decided to sit at the bar and smoke a cigarette. It was then that I noticed this really cute guy staring at me. We made eye contact a few times, and I smiled to be nice even though I had a boyfriend and wasn’t really interested.
Then Kelly came back from the bathroom and I saw her talking to him. It turned out that she knew this guy, whose name was Billy (not his real name). She brought him over to meet me. He asked if I would like to get to know him better, and started giving me these really bad lines. I tried to ignore him but I finally gave in, and we exchanged numbers.
When Billy did call I avoided him (telling my mom and sister to say I wasn’t home) because I had a boyfriend already. Then, one day I bumped into him on the street and we started talking. He was really sweet and told me a lot about himself.
Billy liked to play basketball, dance reggae, and had managed to graduate from high school instead of dropping out like his two older brothers and most of his friends. He told me he was thinking about going to college and wanted to travel when he saved more money from his job at a record store. He’d already been to Africa, Barbados, and Jamaica. By the time we reached my train station I was completely charmed. I had broken up with my boyfriend by this time, so Billy and I became an item.
A Different Kind of Relationship
Before I knew it, five months had gone by and Billy and I were still together. Being with him was so different from my past relationships. My prior boyfriends were cute, but it was their personalities that made them shine. They always urged me to talk about myself because they knew I was shy, and needed a kick start to let it all out. I’ve always needed that to keep me talking. Billy never did that. He was drop-dead gorgeous but very quiet.
With Billy it was no talk and all action. (Sex, that is.) I didn’t feel I was in love with Billy as I had been with previous boyfriends; it was more that we were having fun. We were learning things about each other, and our different cultures. I would tell him about my punk rock stage, and he would describe his experience at the Sun Splash reggae festival in Jamaica. We went to parties and reggae concerts.
But all along I knew something was missing. We never really talked about our relationship. Everything was kept locked inside. It was like we both knew there was something not right, but we were scared to confront it.
Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner?
Billy had asked me a few times if my parents knew I was seeing a Black man and if they would approve. I was deeply ashamed to have to tell him no. My parents are old-fashioned and think people should stay with their own kind.
Billy was hurt, but he said he expected it. In his mind, most White families preferred their kids to date White men. Billy was taught that by the adults in his family, who had experienced racism. Billy told me his mother and aunts and uncles taught him not to be angry at Whites, but to stick with his own race so he’d avoid getting hurt. In spite of that, he had told his family about me from the start.
Since I felt I couldn’t have him meet my family (except for my sister-they did meet and she totally fell in love with him), I didn’t expect to meet his. But he said he wanted me to meet his mother and brothers, who he was really close to.
The night that we planned to go to his house for dinner I was petrified. I thought about how his mother and brothers never dated interracially and how his mother had bad experiences with Whites. Would his mother be disappointed that Billy was dating a White girl like my parents would about my dating a Black man? I didn’t know what to expect.
When I first arrived at Billy’s, I was overwhelmed by the number of friends and relatives in the house. People were everywhere: watching the Knicks, drinking a beer, talking, laughing. Everyone was so relaxed.
The atmosphere was so different from my household-not as conservative and proper. Billy’s brothers greeted me with friendly bear hugs. When I mentioned to Billy that I was going outside for a minute to satisfy a nicotine fit, he said it was fine to smoke in the house. I felt bad lighting up, but no one seemed to care. Right then I was totally chillin’.
While we waited for his mother to finish cooking, I talked to Billy’s friends and cousins. I didn’t feel like I was there to meet the family, but like I was hangin’ out with my friends. Then I realized this was meeting the family. We talked about everything, like music, work, school, movies, relationships. The fact that I was White slipped my mind, because no one seemed to care.
Things got a little more serious when I talked with his mom over dinner. She wanted to know if I was in school and what I wanted to do when I got out. She urged me to graduate, and told me how she fought hard to get Billy to finish school. She was really proud that he had made it. I had really good vibes about her: she looked like a strong, loving mother.
I felt satisfied with how the evening went, but I couldn’t help wondering if his family was as comfortable with Billy dating me as they appeared to be. I asked Billy the next day if his family liked me. He said they thought I was sweet and pretty. When I asked him if they cared about him being with a White girl, he said no and that was the last time it ever came up.
Weird Looks and Nasty Comments
Not everyone was cool with it though. I noticed that since Billy and I starting going out, we received a lot of attention. Homeboys that walked past us on the street would give Billy weird looks, and some of them would shout out encouragement like, “Give her the flava, son!”
I didn’t mind that, but when people got nasty, it really bothered me. I stopped counting the times that people (both Black and White), on the train or on the street, made comments indicating we were betraying our race by not keeping within the lines. Once when Billy and I were waiting for the light to change, an elderly White woman whispered to me, “What do your parents think?” She said it as though I were committing a crime of indecency or something.
Billy and I tried to ignore the degrading comments as best we could, even though inside we both wanted to fight back. We would look at each other and wonder whether to stand up for ourselves, but we never did. We would just mumble under our breath. We never talked about these incidents-we had too much pride to admit they were hurting us. It makes me angry now to think about how we never responded to the looks and comments. Why? Did pretending all the bad things weren’t really there help our relationship?
Together, Alone
We got into the habit of spending most of our time together, alone-going to movies or chilling in his house-instead of our usual partying. We wanted to avoid any possible trouble. We never really got to know each other’s friends. It was almost like we didn’t want to bother with any problems that might arise. If I called him and he happened to be hangin’ with the boys, I would make plans to hang out with him the next day, or another time when he’d be alone. I didn’t want to create any problems and he never objected; in fact he never invited me to come hang with him and his friends.
After about six months I felt it was time to see if Billy’s friends accepted me. There was a rap and reggae jam going on at Lucy’s, a well known club, and since Billy and his best friends were going, I decided to go too. I arranged to bring along my sister, my best friend Kelly and another good friend who is White.
I asked Billy if it was OK. The way he said yes made me wonder if he really was comfortable mixing his pretty hard-core pals with some White girls from the Upper West Side. But it was important to me-introducing my friends to his was my first step toward challenging our safety net.
The Beginning of the End
The plan was to meet in front of Billy’s house in Harlem. His friends seemed uncomfortable right from the start. We ended up going to the club in two separate groups-Billy with his friends and me with mine. Inside the club I made an effort to strike up a conversation with one of his friends, but after a minute he made an excuse and sped off.
Billy tried to make up for his friend’s rudeness by paying attention to me and my friends, but the more he tried to be with me the worse I felt. Was I ruining Billy’s image in the eyes of his friends, and his social scene?
After the incident at the club I started to feel less secure in the relationship. I don’t know if Billy noticed because he never said anything to me, and the last thing I wanted to do was talk about it. What could I say? “Billy, I’m ashamed of being White. I think it’s ruining your life?” I’d feel like an idiot. And what would he say? I just wanted it all to go away. I felt hopeless.
Then, a few weeks ago, I went to visit Billy at his house and found him messing around with another girl. (She was Black.) I really felt like an idiot. I was putting myself through all this agony and frustration because I cared about him and wanted to salvage the relationship, while he was being unfaithful. I didn’t give him a chance to explain; I was out of his apartment and into a cab as quickly as I could go.
Race Wasn’t the Only Problem
After a good, long cry in the taxi, I felt better and I realized that what happened shouldn’t have surprised me. Our relationship had been going downhill for a while. Our being Black and White was only part of the problem. The rest was our personalities-we just weren’t compatible.
I needed someone to pay attention to me when I looked upset, happy, or angry-someone who would sense how I was feeling and get me to talk about it. I needed to know that person was looking out for me. I wanted to know I could say anything to him, and he would try to understand. I needed someone with warmth. Billy just wasn’t that way.
I finally admitted to myself that we had just been fooling ourselves by staying together. There were people out there who would be better for each of us.
Billy called me that night and we finally talked about how we felt. It was the first time we were really open with each other. I let him know that I felt betrayed and we both let out all the insecurities we had about our relationship. He admitted that the pressure from his friends and neighbors was really wearing him down, but he didn’t want to tell me because he didn’t want to make me feel like his insecurities were my fault.
We Should Have Talked More
I was glad it was all out in the open at last. We talked about still seeing each other, though not steadily. But I decided I needed a break. I wanted to spend more time with my friends and not have to worry about a boyfriend. It felt good to know that I could be myself again.
I realize now that I should have talked to Billy about how I felt sooner, even though I don’t think it would have made a difference. We might even have broken up sooner because we would have realized we just didn’t mesh. Maybe I knew that all along, but Billy’s good looks and the excitement of our relationship kept me trying.
If I ever get into an interracial relationship again (or any other relationship, for that matter), I’ll make sure I like the guy for his personality. I won’t pay attention to color, because it doesn’t mean a thing. The important thing is being able to say what you feel without being afraid. I never want to be in another relationship where I’m uncomfortable about saying what’s on my mind. I don’t want to feel restricted that way ever again.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.