Question: Can all group home residents be punished for what one resident does?
Answer: Definitely not, according to Fred Rosenberg at the CWA’s Office of Advocacy. CWA policy is that agencies should not punish all residents for what one resident did. But this does happen in some group homes and on some campuses.
New York State law says that these kinds of punishment are illegal:
-Not giving you meals, snacks, or visits with your family
-Room isolation
-Solitary confinement
-Corporal punishment
-Allowing other youth to punish you
Also, the agency cannot:
-Put you on “unlimited restriction”
-Withhold your allowance unless they tell you how you can “earn it back.” (If they hold your allowance and you don’t get a chance to earn it back, the agency has to give you your money when you are discharged.)
-Withhold your clothing allowance
-Withhold your independent living stipend if you are participating in the independent living program
If you feel you are punished unfairly:
-Ask to see the agency’s policy manual. Every agency has one. Look for the section on discipline or punishment. It should say something about the agency’s “standards” for punishment, and also who makes the decision about punishment.
-Ask for a meeting at the agency. Find out who makes the rules on punishment for your group home. Then ask your social worker or someone else you trust to help you to talk to that person.
-Prepare for the meeting by writing down: what you were punished for, when it happened, and who was involved. Think about what the agency is going to say and what you’ll say in response. Do you have other ideas about what the agency should do? For example, what kind of punishment would you use in the group home?
-At the meeting, explain why you think your punishment was unfair and how it could be done differently.
-If you feel the problem still isn’t settled, call the CWA’s Office of Advocacy (Children’s Rights Unit) at 212-266-2500. According to Mr. Rosenberg, they will start an investigation into whether the agency punished you unfairly.
For help in setting up a meeting at your agency or in taking other action to stop unfair punishment, call the Legal Rights Hotline at 212-675-6181.
Question: Can a resident press charges against a staff?
Answer: It depends on what happened. A resident may press charges against a staff person in a group home in some situations-just like you can sometimes go to the police to complain about anyone who hurts you or does something illegal to you.
If you call the police or go to the precinct because a staff or someone else hurt you, it is up to the police to investigate, take a complaint from you, and decide whether to arrest the person you’re complaining about.
In some situations the police may not take your complaint as seriously as you would like, or may not be able to do much. This doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t contact the police, but you should realize that they don’t arrest everyone who is the subject of a complaint.
You should also realize that the agency is going to have some reaction when you go to the police-you might want to talk to your social worker or someone you trust at the agency about what is happening and try to get someone on your side. Some people at the agency may be angry, defensive, or worried that you are unnecessarily involving police in the agency’s business. Of course, if a staff member is really hurting residents, then the agency should want to know so they can put a stop to it immediately.
Going to the police means you are starting an investigation that may lead to someone’s arrest and prosecution in court. It is very serious, and you will be expected to cooperate with the police and district attorney, even if you later change your mind.
When you have a conflict with a staff, you should think about what kind of result you want. For the staff to stop acting inappropriately? For the group home to take residents’ complaints more seriously? For the staff member to get fired? In a lot of situations, there may be more successful ways to get your result without going to the police and pressing charges.
If a staff member insults you or talks about you in a way you don’t like, or otherwise acts in a way that to you seems unfair or unprofessional, you should let him or her know. You should also tell this to your social worker, and to someone higher up, like the director of the house or of the group home program. Staff are not supposed to act in a way that is harmful to residents.
If you have something stolen by a staff member, you can file a police report by calling the police or going to the precinct. The police should give you a complaint number and investigate what happened.
If a staff member hits you or otherwise uses force (twists your arm, pushes you, etc.), you should report it to the people at the agency and also call the Child Abuse Hotline (1-800-342-3720).
It is against New York State law for staff or foster parents to use corporal (physical) punishment on foster care youth. The Child Abuse Hotline person will send your report to CWA, which is supposed to start an investigation right away. You can also call the CWA Office of Advocacy (Children’s Rights Unit) at 212-266-2500, but they may tell you to call the Child Abuse Hotline.
If a staff member hits you, you can also call the police. They should investigate and let you file a complaint against the staff. Under the New York State Penal Law, the staff person may be guilty of harassment or even assault. If you were physically injured, and the police believe there is “probable cause,” they should arrest the staff person.
If a staff person rapes, beats, or otherwise seriously hurts a resident, you should go to the police, as well as report it to the Child Abuse Hotline. This should result in an investigation and the arrest of the staff member, and probably a criminal case that will go to court.
Whenever you go to complain to anyone-the police, your agency, the Child Abuse Hotline-it is very important to have your story straight. Write down what happened, when, where, etc., and the name of anyone who saw it happen. It is also helpful to have people who will back you up, who are on your side. Talk to your social worker or someone else at the agency you trust, or to a family member, or to someone from school. Tell that person what the problem is and what you are doing about it.
If you have questions or want help dealing with a situation in your group home, call the Legal Rights Hotline at 212-675-6181.
Know Your Legal Rights
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.