Speak Out: Should Youth in Foster Care Be Tested For HIV? (The Virus That Causes AIDS)
Interviews by Angela Rutman, Lenny Jones, and Michelle Brown
“No, because those types of tests are supposed to be private. The way some staff act now can change after they find out the person or persons has the virus.”
Beatrice Campbell, 19
Edwin Gould Services for Children
Manhattan
“Yes, because I think it is for their own good if they get tested. You will never know what’s in your body.”
Violetta Tovar, 17
Edwin Gould Services for Children
Manhattan
“No, I feel if they have AIDS, that’s their business.”
Nicole Thorpe, 14
Edwin Gould Services for Children
Manhattan
“No, because if I had the virus I would not want anyone to know.”
Darnell, 15
Leake & Watts
Manhattan
“Yes, because you never know what is in your body.”
Antwan, 16
Leake & Watts
Manhattan
“Yes and no. First yes, because we all need to check and see what is in our bodies. We could never know. But on the other hand I say no, because those who may find out that they have the virus and really don’t know how to handle the news, may try to destroy themselves.”
Will, 17
Leake & Watts
Manhattan
“In a way, yes, and in a way, no. Yes, if they got raped or molested. It’s a violation of privacy, yes, but it’s also good to know if you do have H.I.V.”
Jennifer Haas, 17
Mt. Vernon Residence
Jewish Board of Family and Children’s Services
“First of all, if someone said that I had to take an H.I.V. test I’d be offended, because it’s like accusing me. Second of all, if one of us was to have H.I.V., the staff might be prejudiced against us.”
Steven A., 16
Mt. Vernon Residence
Jewish Board of Family and Children’s Services
“I feel that they should test residents for H.I.V. because there’s a time when couples up here might get into a sexual situation on home visits or while being AWOL. They should know how their health is.”
Coleman Reader, 19
Mt. Vernon Residence
Jewish Board of Family and Children’s Services
“Yes, because if that person does have H.I.V. and you don’t know, you can catch it. But taking the test should be private and by choice.”
Joe Morris, 18
Mt. Vernon Residence
Jewish Board of Family and Children’s Services
“I believe that it’s good that they’re thinking about the children in that way, because they want to protect and help them. But you shouldn’t be forced to take one.”
Miriam LaRoche, 16
Mt. Vernon Residence
Jewish Board of Family and Children’s Services
“I would be happy to take the test. I feel that people with H.I.V. or AIDS shouldn’t be on a campus with young, sexually active people.”
Scott Marshall, 17
Mt. Vernon Residence
Jewish Board of Family and Children’s Services
“Yeah, because anybody can be infected. These kids could be in danger to themselves and other people around them. Regardless, people should take the test to know what’s going on in their body because AIDS is a deadly disease.”
Madira Lopez, 16
Mt. Vernon Residence
Jewish Board of Family and Children’s Services
“I think they should be tested, but only if they want to be tested.”
Keith Jones, 17
St. John’s Home for Boys
Queens
“Not unless other youth at risk and not in foster care are also tested. Otherwise, I think foster care youth will be unnecessarily discriminated against and stigmatized more than they are now.”
Name withheld
St. John’s Home for Boys
Queens
“I feel that foster care youth should only be tested if they agree to go along with it.”
Kaseen Harris
St. John’s Home for Boys
Queens
Should Youth in Foster Care Be Tested for HIV?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.