The names in this story have been changed.
Until last year, the only teen relationships I knew about were fictional: In books and on TV, cute guys asked pretty girls out for a date at the local hangout. But I didn’t date and neither did my close friends. Then my friend Veronica got a boyfriend. I was a bit jealous, but I was excited too. Finally, I was going to get a closeup look at a real teen couple!
Actually, I didn’t find Michael, Veronica’s boyfriend, to be really cute or interesting. But I thought it must be nice for Veronica just to say, “I have a boyfriend.”
Veronica met Michael at school in the beginning of our sophomore year when he started a new club on religion and meditation. Over the next eight months, they became good friends. They were both Indian and they found they had a lot in common. In the spring, they became a “couple,” and everything got complicated.
In my daydreams about having a boyfriend, we spend lots of time together and he is also my best friend. So that’s how I pictured Veronica and Michael’s relationship. I thought they would sit around and talk for hours about everything from religion to their favorite flavor of ice cream. They would go to the movies, to McDonald’s, to play miniature golf…
Doing Things His Way
But the reality wasn’t like that. Veronica soon realized that if she wanted to be with Michael, she had to work around his schedule because he refused to compromise. She cut classes (something I frowned upon) to spend time with him. And since he wouldn’t wait for her when she went to after-school clubs, she cut all her after-school activities, too.
But when she did these things she would usually end up sitting around and talking to him and his friends. Veronica never spent much time alone with Michael except when they made out in the West 4th Street subway station. They never actually went out on a date.
Veronica started to get very depressed. When she confronted Michael about his lack of attention, he would say he was sorry and that he didn’t mean to ignore her. She would accept his apology and things would go on as usual.
All of this bothered me. In my family whatever the male (my dad) says, goes. I don’t always obey, of course: When my dad yells at me to clean up my room, I yell back or leave the room. But my mom just takes it. I hate that. When I ask her about it, she smiles and says that in every relationship one person has to give in.
But my mom’s always the one giving in. I decided I was going to be different: I would never allow a guy to run my life or tell me what to do. So I wanted Veronica to stand up for herself. I felt that Michael was saying, “Hey, I’m the GUY, so I’m going to be the one making decisions.”
I also began to resent the fact that Veronica and I didn’t get to spend as much time together as we used to. Before, we would walk to the train station or stop for a bite to eat after school, and have plenty of chances to talk. Now Michael took up all her time, and she wasn’t even happy. I never thought that being “in love” meant being unhappy all the time.
Hiding From Their Parents
The only thing I found normal and healthy about their relationship: They hid it from their parents. Both Veronica and Michael’s parents come from an older generation and a culture that forbids dating.
In India, girls and guys don’t see each other socially (so dating is out), and marriages are generally arranged. Everyone is expected to remain a virgin till marriage. I guess the parents are trying to protect their children, both from practical problems (pregnancy, STD’s) and from emotional hurt.
My parents, who are Indian too, are just as old-fashioned, and I’ve often wondered how I would deal with it. Sometimes I want to go on a date, just to defy them. As I found out from Veronica, who was able to hide her relationship from her parents, it’s not that hard. Still I don’t want to hide things from them.
Breaking Up Is Hard To Do
Although Veronica’s parents didn’t find out about it, her relationship with Michael was still falling apart. By June, Veronica wanted to dump him, but she wouldn’t do it. I told her to go for it. But she didn’t want to be the one to end the relationship. She didn’t want the responsibility.
After school ended, they didn’t see each other over the summer, which I thought was weird, since they do live in the same city. Veronica had no problems meeting him, but he was too chicken to disobey his parents. Once in a while they talked on the phone.
I left for a couple of weeks in July. When I came back, Veronica told me she was still unhappy. I felt bad because I couldn’t really understand all her feelings. I have been infatuated with guys before, but I have never dated anyone. I didn’t understand how she could tolerate not seeing him. I didn’t know why she couldn’t just leave him. No matter how much she told me, I was still on the outside looking in.
When she finally decided to break up, I was thrilled for her. At last, she was taking a stand. But she didn’t get the satisfaction of ending the relationship. They both agreed that it wasn’t working out and decided to be just friends.
“By the Way, I Never Loved You”
Over the rest of the summer, Veronica occasionally told me that she missed Michael. But I think she knew that breaking up was the best thing for them. She was planning to stay friends once school started.
When we went back to school, Michael gave Veronica a belated birthday present: a bottle of Eternity and a letter.
“Does this mean…?” I asked.
“I don’t know.” I hope she doesn’t fall for his crap, I thought.
After Veronica finished reading the letter, she looked like she was about to cry or kill someone.
We were sitting on the steps of the gazebo in the park next to our school. “Are you OK?” I asked. She didn’t answer and told me she was going to take a walk.
Ten minutes later she came back looking calmer and gave me the letter. I couldn’t believe what he wrote. The a-hole made her sound like a whore.
Michael wrote that he had been “lonely and needed a… girl to hang with. Since you were the closest thing around…” Thing? Veronica is not a thing. She is a person with feelings. He went on, “I let my lust and false ego drag me into the hellish trap that our pathetic relationship was.”
As if trashing her and their relationship wasn’t enough, Michael also told her about his new girlfriend. That’s great, I thought. You do not tell someone that “our little fling was a total and utter MISTAKE,” and, by the way, I have a new girlfriend, so aren’t you happy for me? What an idiot.
Over the next few weeks, Veronica ignored him. By the time they talked again, most of her friends and a few of his knew about the incident. She was mad because he wrote the letter. He was mad at her for showing everyone the letter. Veronica admitted that it was a childish thing to do on her part. (I think it was very appropriate. I told her that she should have sent a copy to his parents!) Michael said that he had just wanted to explain everything and that he couldn’t understand why she was hurt.
On To a New Guy
But the letter only left Veronica confused, and the experience made her angry at all guys. She said she was going to think it over a lot more before getting involved again. She thinks that she only went out with Michael because the idea of having a boyfriend, any boyfriend, seemed nice.
For those of you who like happy endings, you’ll be glad to know that Veronica has a new boyfriend. John is a senior at our school and this guy is so sweet (and corny, if you ask me!). They have actually gone out on dates and he actually talks to Veronica’s friends. So far, so good. I’m crossing my fingers and hoping that this relationship won’t turn into another tragedy.
Still, after Veronica’s experience with Michael, I’m happy not to have a boyfriend. Why should I put myself through all that pain when I have lots of other sh-t, like school and parents, to deal with?
Who’s in Control?
When I do get into a relationship, I want to really know the person. We would have to be good friends first. But that raises all kinds of problems, too. As a friend, Michael was OK. Do all guys change once you agree to go out with them? Do my male friends treat their girlfriends differently than they treat me? I don’t know and I don’t feel comfortable enough to ask any of them because we never talk about dating.
I’m also still unsure about where the line is between compromise and letting a guy run my life. Say we are going out on a Friday night and are trying to decide which movie to see. If I give in and agree to see the movie he wants to see, am I compromising too much? Should I go for a coin toss? Or is it just a stupid movie so it really doesn’t matter who gets to choose?
Of course, all of these uncertainties don’t mean that if Tom Cruise asked me to go to a movie on how ants mate, I would hesitate to say yes! Fiction sometimes can be so much better than real life.
A Girl’s Dating Dilemma: When to Give In, When to Give Up
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.