“Because of the number of girls spreading their legs for welfare checks, too many teens are having babies and the welfare system is burdened. A good way to handle this problem is to take away their children and put them in group homes, where they can be better cared for.”
These could be the words of the Republicans behind the “orphanage plan.” Well, somebody (that’s me!) needs to tell them they are making a big mistake.
An obvious example of their delusions is that they keep making references to Boys Town (a famous group home in Nebraska featured in a Spencer Tracy/Mickey Rooney movie of the 1930s) as an example of how well orphanages can be run.
Group Home Reality
Boys Town is a place where the “grass is green” and kids want to stay forever because of the excellent treatment (yeah right, most kids can’t even wait for home visits on weekends).
We in the system know that you won’t find too many agencies like Boys Town (if it ever existed-you know how Hollywood makes stuff up). Matter of fact, you have a much better chance of attending a Ku Klux Klan rally in Harlem.
And even though most orphanages aren’t like “Oliver Twist” (I hesitate to ask for seconds after seeing this movie), the image currently being presented to the American public is not correct.
But I doubt the public would want to see the true side of group homes. If they knew that we lose our individuality because we are nothing but a number among hundreds of other kids, that most of us have to depend upon staff members who may or may not care for us past their eight hours and paycheck, would the orphanage proposal be supported at all?
Everybody is claiming that it will cut down on welfare spending and save the nation money. I’m sorry to say that this is just another case of “Political Math.”
The cost of keeping a child in an orphanage for a year ($36,500) is much more than keeping that child on welfare ($2,644) for the same time. And don’t even think that private funding will make the difference since most agencies complain about a lack of money now. How do you think they’ll do with more children and less money? (Aren’t you glad the people behind this idea aren’t accountants at your bank?)
And since there are going to be more kids being removed from their homes, there will need to be more orphanages (surprise!!). Many of these kids will be Black and Latino. I am sure that many of these WASP Congressmen (with a few Uncle Toms thrown in for flavor) will want these new orphanages in their lily-White neighborhoods-especially Mr. Newt Gingrich (Speaker of the House of Representatives and a strong supporter of the plan), who comes from conservative Cobb County in Georgia. Building orphanages would probably be the only way you would see real integration in Cobb County and other areas represented by Republicans.
I could go on for days listing faults with this proposal, but instead I’ll end my piece by saying what I consider to be the truth.
Teenagers aren’t having sex so that they can be on welfare and get government cheese (yum yum!). But in a society which encourages teenagers to have sex at a young age, welfare becomes the ultimate “security blanket.”
Need for Sex Ed
And if Republican ideals become reality, such as ending condom distribution in schools because it “encourages sex” (when in effect it keeps the pregnancy rate lower), or stopping sex education and discouraging masturbation while naively supporting abstinence, they will end up causing what they set out to prevent-teenage pregnancy.
A way to change the number of mothers on welfare would be not to eliminate it completely, but change it into a “stepping stone” (e.g., a mother would stay on welfare for one to two years, during which time she would be expected to find a job).
And before I forget, let me also mention that just because children come from poor, single-parent homes, doesn’t mean they will all become a “Menace to Society” (as opposed to Jeffrey Dahmer, master chef and prison punching bag, who came from a “normal” two-parent home!).
(P.S. For all the slow people out there who didn’t figure it out already: I DON’T LIKE REPUBLICANS!!!!)
The Republicans Are Crazy
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.