The new documentary Hoop Dreams is the best movie I’ve ever seen. It brilliantly depicts the pressures two high school basketball players face, both on and off the court. The film took seven years to make and it was worth the effort.
The movie follows Arthur Agee and William Gates-two Chicago high school basketball standouts-through five years of their lives. It starts when the boys are in their early teens and catch the eye of talent scout Earl Smith. Smith recruits them for posh St. Joseph HS, the suburban school where Isiah Thomas began his basketball career. Driven by a dream of one day making it to the NBA, these two young men begin making the three hour commute to St. Joseph’s every day.
Living Up To Expectations
At the start, both boys are promised four year scholarships to the school as repayment for their services on the basketball court. But during their sophomore year, tuition is hiked and Arthur is told that if he wants to stay, his family will have to cover it. They can’t pay and he’s forced to leave the school.
William’s family can’t afford the tuition increase either but the school finds a personal sponsor-Patricia Weir, president of Encyclopedia Brittannica-to cover all his expenses. That’s because William was a freshman sensation on the varsity team while Arthur didn’t quite live up to the coach’s expectations.
In spite of this setback, Arthur holds on tightly to his dream. He transfers to a public high school in Chicago and continues to play there. William, on the other hand, starts to question whether the life of a prep school star is as wonderful as he thought. His coach, Gene Pingatore, spends most of the film comparing William to Isiah. As a matter of fact, the first thing William’s made to do as he enters his junior year is to watch an Isiah Thomas highlight film.
If you’re like me and felt cheated by the corny action scenes in other basketball movies like Blue Chips, you’ll love the scenes in Hoop Dreams. Especially when the directors show the similarities Arthur and William have with some of their idols, like Michael Jordan and Isiah. And keep an eye out for candid shots of some current college and NBA superstars back when they were in high school.
Trouble Off the Court
But what makes the movie great is that it isn’t just about what happens on the court. Both boys also have to deal with big problems in their personal lives. Arthur is forced to watch his father leave the family and turn into a drug addict. One time when Arthur is at the park with his friends, his father comes around and offers to play ball with his son. After taking a couple shots he leaves the court and goes to get some drugs from the dealers who are hanging nearby. Arthur watches, helpless and ashamed, as his friends begin to tease him. But Arthur doesn’t let his family’s problems distract him; if anything, his anger at his father just makes him more determined to succeed.
Arthur is now a senior at Arkansas State University where he is averaging 19 points per game. Yes, his dream is still alive.
William is pushed hardest by his brother Curtis, who was an awesome high school basketball player in his day. But, due to his inability to be coached, Curtis never managed to do anything with his skills. One of the saddest moments in the film comes when the adult Curtis sees a kid on the neighborhood court do a reverse dunk. Curtis, overweight and out of shape, attempts the same shot but he barely gets off the ground. After his feeble attempt, he leaves the court with his head down.
The Measure of Success
Curtis’s failure to make it to the pros means that the family’s hopes are now pinned on William. When, after five tries, William gets a high enough score on the ACT (similar to the SAT) to make him eligible to play basketball for Marquette University, he declares, “Curtis always wanted to go to Marquette, but he didn’t have the grades. Now he’s got the grades.”
After seeing what happened to Arthur and William, I’ve realized that a dream can only be fulfilled if it’s yours, and that happiness is really the only true measure of success.
Hoop Dreams is unlike any documentary I’ve ever seen. The people are not only real, they’re invigorating. The movie is over two and a half hours long but I still wanted more. The filmmakers shot a total of 250 hours of footage and I left the theater thirsting to see the rest of it.
At one point, William says, “people always ask me if I’m going to remember them when I make the NBA, but I wonder if they’ll remember me if I don’t.” I was reminded of this after the movie when a friend of mine kept referring to Arthur and William as “nobodys.” I disagree. Whether they make it to the NBA or not, these two young men, who graduated high school and are about to graduate college, are not nobodys. If they are, then what are the rest of us?
Paying the Price for “Hoop Dreams”
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.