Mothers and Daughters: Can We All Get Along?

Names have been changed.
Over the past year I noticed what a bad relationship my friend Marion had with her mother. They were always arguing.
My friend Norma and I would pick Marion up for school, and she and her mom would sometimes get into it right in front of us. They would argue about where she was during school hours, who she had been with, the condoms disappearing from Marion’s drawers, her nasty attitude, and her friends.
I remember one fight involving a miniskirt. Norma and I thought the skirt was great, but to Marion’s mother it just didn’t look right. She saw how Norma and I were dressed (t-shirts, shorts and sandals) and told Marion off.
“Where do you think you are going with that?”
“To school,” Marion snapped.
“Marion, look at how your friends are dressed. They look decent and you look like you want to pick up a 35-year-old man. Go upstairs and change it right now!”
“Ma, it’s the style. Nothing is wrong.”
“Go change it now!”
“You make me sick sometimes.”
“Don’t talk back to me. I want you to go change that skirt to a decent one.”
Marion changed her clothes, but she was angry as hell. She had dressed up because she was planning to secretly cut school and see her boyfriend. “Sometimes,” she said on the way out, “I wish I could strangle her.”
The fights can be so intense that Marion says she’ll kill her mother or even herself. “I feel like taking a knife and ramming it into her back!” Marion will say.
Just Like My Mom
I think Marion’s mother fears that without her guidance, Marion will end up doing something wrong like getting pregnant, dropping out of school, or becoming hooked on drugs. And since Marion doesn’t confide in her mother, it leaves Ms. James curious about her daughter’s life outside the house. (Not that Marion is wild. She may cut class sometimes to see boyfriends, but she still manages to get good grades).
Watching Marion argue with Ms. James made me realize what a great relationship I have with my mother and how it came to be that way.
My mother and I weren’t always close. When I was 13, I went through a rebellious stage, going to clubs with my older cousins and trying to act older. I put on makeup, wore dresses that were backless, and even drank wine.
Whenever my mother asked me about my behavior, I would get upset and tell her to leave me alone. I believed that she was the enemy on a mission to ruin my life.
Then I read an article about a girl who answered her parents back, drank, and left the house without their permission. She was left with regret because she felt she missed out on teenage life by trying to act grown. Seeing myself in her, I decided to turn over a new leaf. I wanted to stop lying to my mother and tell her what I did and why.
We talked a lot and got out each other’s feelings. My mother told me my cousins were older than me and they could go places that were right for them but not me. I had to grow up at my own pace. We resolved our problem by trusting each other, communicating, and marking off a special day in the week to talk.
Now, we can sit and chat about anything as long as she isn’t saying things she knows will upset me, like: “Why don’t you dress more like a girl does?” or teasing me with, “You have such a big forehead.”
Now, don’t think she’s putting me down. She isn’t. I’m proud of how I look and she is too. For one, I love to wear pants; they make me feel comfortable. I hate dresses. My mother and I both have big foreheads. She just likes to point out mine is big.
Advice For a Friend
I realized Marion and her mother needed what my mother and I have. Lots and lots of communicating, joking around, and trust. I know my mother isn’t perfect, but I have too much respect for her to do anything to hurt her.
I always wanted to suggest that Marion and her mother go to family counseling, but I didn’t want to seem like I was up in their business, or that I knew how to solve their problems, so I kept my mouth shut.
But Marion and I did talk about options for how to handle the situation. I suggested she express her feelings to her mother, and she said it wouldn’t work for her.
Still, I believe things could work out, if they could learn to talk rationally, and LISTEN to each other.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.