Arranged Marriages: Immigrant Teens Say `I Don’t’

Can you imagine getting married to someone you don’t know? Someone picked for you by your parents? A lot of people think the idea of arranged marriages is old-fashioned, but they remain the norm in some cultures and religions.
Right here in New York City, teenagers in immigrant families have to deal with parents who might be expecting them to follow the traditional practice. I’m interested in the subject because I have young relatives who have had marriages arranged for them.
Allison (not her real name) said that the culture in her parents’ native Bangladesh mandates arranged marriages. If parents permitted a “love match,” says the 20-year-old sophomore at Marymount Manhattan College, people would think the girl’s been “spoiled,” and that she’s been dating and sleeping around with guys.
For parents, setting up their children’s marriages means guaranteeing that the kids marry within their own culture, nationality and religion. It also means that their children’s future will be set, at least, financially.
Parents Who Mix and Match
Indians living in America typically use three ways to find mates for their kids, says Sheshagir Venkatesh, who is the father of two. The parents can go back to India to look for one there. Or they can try to match their child with an Indian college student, who has come to America to study. Children of friends who have grown up here are also a good bet.
Some parents also put ads in newspapers published for the Indian community in America. There’s an example from the New York edition of India Abroad, which is published weekly: “Hindu parents seek Medical Doctors, Ph.D, Engineers; for beautiful, tall, slim, qualified, employed daughter; sincere, cultured, mid-thirties.”
Venkatesh, who has a 20-year-old daughter and an 18-year-old son, says his children will definitely choose their spouses from a group that he and his wife will select. He claims that arranged matches are better for them. “I have seen [in] America so many marriages [where] within no time, there’s a divorce,” Venkatesh explains.
Fear of the Unknown
Teenagers, however, have a different take. Despite her cultural background, Allison says she wouldn’t agree to an arranged marriage because “it [would] be scary to commit yourself” to someone whom you’ve never met before. It’s especially frightening for females, she adds, because “women in our culture have [to obey their] husbands and in-laws.”
Another barrier is the cultural taboo on divorce, adds Purnima Chopra, 17, of Brooklyn Tech HS. The reason for the low divorce rates among Indian families may be because “you stay with the person no matter what,” she says.
Lack of trust and an uncertain future were some of the other disadvantages mentioned by teens.
“Marriage lasts forever, ” says Neena Shin, 16, of Stuyvesant HS. “It’s not something people [should] do for you.”
For Love or Money?
And qualities that a teenager would look for in a spouse are not necessarily shared by parents.
When Venkatesh, for example, searches for a spouse for his children, he says the first requirement is that the boy or girl be from the same caste as he. Venkatesh is a Hindu and Hinduism has many sub-divisions, known as castes. In India, it also serves as a class system, since a majority of the population is Hindu. A person is born into one caste and typically cannot move to a higher one.
As a second step, Venkatesh and his wife “study” the family background. Next the horoscopes are matched for compatibility. Lastly, there is a meeting between the prospective bride and groom to see if they like each other.
After their engagement, the couple can go out, but they can’t live together before the wedding. If they don’t like each other, the parents can go back to the selection process.
But for Shane Antony, 15, of Stuyvesant HS, religion and family background are not that important. Shane, whose parents are from India, says his future wife just has to be honest, intelligent, warm and friendly. And, of course, he adds, “she can’t be butt-ugly.” However, he admits his parents don’t share his criteria: They would look for a girl who comes from a good family and has money, he says.
Treated Like Furniture
Regardless of the different criteria, Neena says that arranged marriages are or should be a thing of the past. In her native South Korea, the custom began, she says, “a long, long time ago” because “women had no rights” and were treated like “furniture.”
While it continues in rural areas of South Korea, she says the custom is not really practiced among Korean-Americans, because the feminist movement is so strong; it’s not acceptable for many modern women, and “it’s not politically correct,” she adds.
But some teenagers believe that arranged marriages do deserve some credit. Ending up with someone of the same educational background and economic status “makes it easier to communicate to an extent,” says Shilu Ahmed, 19, who was born in Bangladesh. The junior at Marymount Manhattan College adds that she might agree to one if she weren’t already in a relationship.
Veto Power
Manoj Nair, 17, of James Madison HS, says arranged marriages could have other benefits since you have your family’s approval, and your parents already know the person. But, he adds, his parents “shouldn’t even think” about arranging one for him.
How do the parents of these teenagers feel about the subject? Neena says hers do not support arranged marriages because the practice does not exist in their family.
On the other hand, Purnima says that her parents want to arrange marriages for her and her sisters although they’d allow them to refuse their choices.
Her parents also wouldn’t mind if she picked her own husband, she adds, as long as the guy’s Indian and follows the same religion.
Right now, her parents are on “my sister’s back because she’s the oldest,” says Purnima. They have put an ad in a newspaper and have selected a few guys, she adds. But, so far, her sister, who is 21, has rejected all the choices because she’s not ready to settle down yet.
As for herself, Purnima is emphatic: “I want [my] parents to like him, not pick him.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.