Some of my earliest memories of my father involve his old car, a Ford Maverick. I loved that car, the way it looked and the way it smelled. It was white with a light brown roof and silver trim. It had this wonderful car smell I looked forward to inhaling every time we went for a ride. I usually didn’t know where we were going and I didn’t care. I was stuck in the house a lot so those drives were a treat for me, even if we didn’t go anywhere special.
I remember other good things about my relationship with my father back then. When I was about 6, we had a bedtime ritual. Every night at 10 p.m. we would go into the bedroom, usually by ourselves, and he would take our puzzles out of the drawer. He would do the crossword puzzles and I would do the circle-the-word puzzles until I fell asleep.
My father was also the one that got me into cartoons. We would sit in front of the TV, laughing, howling, and crying as we watched Woody Woodpecker or Bugs Bunny. I still remember the way he laughed, a very loud “AH HA HA HA.” I remember him as being very happy and jolly, joking around a lot.
Fights and Disappearances
I also remember some bad times, like when my parents fought. I don’t remember what their arguments were about, but I remember feeling like the world was ending whenever they had one. My mother would be yelling and screaming, with tears running down her face. Her voice made this kind of shrill sound when she screamed. I thought she was physically hurt. I would sit in a closet screaming and crying, “What’s wrong with my Mommy?” My older sister would comfort me until my mother came to show me she was alright.
I was about 7 when my dad moved out. I don’t remember anyone telling me he was leaving. I didn’t even notice at first that he was gone, strange as it may sound. I was probably used to him not being around because he used to disappear for weeks at a time before he left for good.
After that, he would still come by every once in a while to take me and my brothers to the movies. I didn’t miss him when he was gone, but when he did show up, I was usually excited. It meant we were going somewhere. He took us to McDonald’s, White Castle, the movies, the park, to visit relatives, and for rides in the car.
My father and I hung out together but we never really talked, not about significant things anyway. Sure I told him about school, my report card, and what I wanted for Christmas, but that’s about it. I felt that there was something missing from our relationship, that there should have been more of a father-son bond. I wanted him to tell me about where he came from, tell me about his life, give me advice. But maybe he thought I wasn’t old enough for those kinds of discussions.
Although my mother never tried to stop me from seeing my father, I knew she wasn’t happy about it. She would frequently sit me down and tell me he wasn’t doing his job as a parent. Whenever I came home from seeing him, she would take me alone in a room and grill me about where we went and what we did together. Maybe she wanted to make sure I wasn’t being mistreated. Or maybe she resented me wanting to see him at all.
I knew she wasn’t angry at me, she just disliked my father. But I felt I indirectly and unfairly caught her wrath and I resented it. I felt like she didn’t trust my judgment. It seemed like she expected me to run off and live with my father, like I couldn’t figure out for myself that she was doing a better job as a parent.
He Said He Loved Me, But. . .
The truth is, I didn’t know how I felt about my father. He used to say he loved me a lot when I was out with him, but I don’t remember my responses. I do know it was different from when my mom said she loved me. I don’t know why, I just think I understood how much she cared without even needing to be told.
On my 14th birthday my father took me to see Batman. The whole thing was a big adventure for me-going out at night in a neighborhood I had never been to before. We came in at the middle of the movie so he agreed to let me watch it again.
Afterwards, my father dropped me off at home and that was the last time I saw him for four years. There was no warning; he just didn’t come around any more after that.
For two years I carried the ticket stubs from that movie in my wallet. (My father always used to give me the stubs when we went to the movies.) Then, one night when I was 16, I took out my wallet and looked at those stubs. Tears welled up in my eyes as I thought about that night at the movies. I walked to the bathroom with tears streaming down my face. I ripped up the stubs and flushed them down the toilet.
I decided that I had no father. How could I call that man “Dad” when he was never around and I knew nothing about him? I didn’t know what kind of person he was or what kind of personality he had. I wasn’t even sure of his birth date.
Maybe he did care. Maybe he did love me. But when you say you love someone you have to prove it, you have to show it.
He Didn’t Do His Job
My definition of a father is someone who is always going to be there for his child. (As Laurence Fishburne’s character in Boyz N’ The Hood says to his son, “Any fool can make a baby, but it takes a man to raise that baby.”) A father makes sacrifices, he cares and worries until it hurts, and beyond. He is understanding and fair. He has to know his child. As far as I could see, my father hadn’t done most of those things.
Then last summer, two years after I had ripped up those ticket stubs, he showed up at my house. I wasn’t there, but the rest of the family was. They told me afterwards how old he looked, with a sprinkling of gray hairs and a dark, haggard face. They told me he stared in disbelief when he saw how big my brothers had gotten.
They showed him a picture of me. Squinting his eyes, he looked at it and asked, “That’s Scott?” (Not my real name.) I tried to imagine him saying that and looking at my picture. What did he look like? How did he sound?
After 4 Years, He Came Back
I just couldn’t believe it. After four years my father came back and I missed it! He had left a number where I could contact him but I didn’t run to the phone. For one thing I was scared. I didn’t know how I would feel seeing him again.
I was also worried about how my mother would react. For years I had to sit down and listen to her go on about the job my father didn’t do. She never had anything good to say about him. What would she say if I told her I wanted to get in touch with my father again? That I wanted to find out what kind of person he is? I was sure she would say, “Why would you want to see him? He’s just no good and all he’s going to bring is trouble.”
I thought about all of that for two or three weeks and finally decided to make the call and set up a meeting. A couple of days later, one of my brothers came over to me while I was watching TV and told me my father was at the door.
The Big Reunion
He was in uniform because he drove a bus. He was a couple of inches shorter than me. I saw the specks of gray in his hair. His face looked weathered and greasy. He had a small beer belly. His West Indian accent was so thick I couldn’t believe that we were related-I don’t have a trace of an accent. I shook his hand and we greeted each other.
We went outside and sat down to talk. I studied every inch of him. I kept looking at his face so I wouldn’t forget what he looked like. I have photo albums with pictures of him, but it hurts to look at them. I tried to talk to him about my memories. I told him I was shocked that he had an accent. “Yeah, I have an accent,” he said without emotion.
Who’s At Fault?
He started to go into why he left. He said it was because of his troubles with my mother and didn’t have anything to do with his children. He asked why I hadn’t tried to get in touch with him. It was a subtle guilt trip, but I paid no attention. I was more interested in getting to know him.
But when he mentioned it a second time, I got angry. “I don’t have to call you week after week, what do you think this is?!” Maybe he felt I was obligated to call him because he’s my father. Or maybe he wanted to blame someone else for the fact that he’s lost his sons. But whose fault is it that he hadn’t come to see us in four years?
My father and I still see each other from time to time and things remain tense between us. I am finding out bits and pieces about his past, which is my past as well. I still want to get to know him but, at the same time, I don’t want to give him the satisfaction of being able to call me “son” and act like a proud father when I feel he hasn’t earned it. I also still wonder if my spending time with him is hurting my mother. I want to do the right thing but I don’t know what the right thing is. It seems like no matter what I do someone is going to get hurt-my mother, my father, or me.
Not My Idea of a Father
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.