Interviews by Saretta Burkett
“Yes. To get what you want, you have to earn it. Some girls don’t realize that and they get upset.”
-Maria Chavarria
Center for Children & Families
Queens
“Some of the rules, they’re okay. A few of them we could do without. Like for instance, curfew. I think it should be later for older kids, not the same for everybody.”
-“Princess”
Girls Club of New York
Bronx
“In a way I feel they are fair because they guide us the right way. It’s hard to take orders from anyone, especially if they are not a relative of yours or if you are not used to taking orders. But at least I have someone to stick by me and guide me with my child.”
-Antoinette Torres, 16
New York Foundling Hospital
The Bronx
“Well, I guess to a certain extent they are fair. You have to get used to it.”
-Teresa Feliccea
Center for Children & Families
Queens
“Half is and half is not. For instance, they got this curfew thing going. They say we can stay out ’till three o’clock in the morning, yet they wake us up at eight in the morning to eat breakfast. If you’re not up by that time, you don’t eat because they lock the kitchen after that. Who’s gonna be up for breakfast if they’ve been up all night?”
-Ulysses Hicks
Center for Children & Families
Queens
“I think they’re too strict. We don’t have enough room to breathe. They force us to do things we don’t want to do. They never give us any freedom.”
-Joanne Johnson, 16
New York Foundling Hospital
The Bronx
“No, because there’s like activities should be planned on Saturdays instead of a Sunday, because everybody has things planned almost every day of the week.”
-“Cachet”
Girls Club of New York
Bronx
“I don’t think it’s fair. ‘Cause they made up this rule talking ’bout only one guy can call you. And it’s like you have a lot of guys that wanna call you, but only one guy can call you, and they gotta memorize his voice. And you can’t have visitors for a l ong amount of time, ’cause you got chores and all that other stuff to do.”
-“Wild Child”
Girls Club of New York
Bronx
“Some rules are okay, but rules such as one phone call a week and only to your mother or father is not right. They don’t allow you to speak your mind. Staff is always right, and that’s only cause they have the authority.
-Katrina Foster, 16
Salvation Army
Queens
“Like, the supervisor punishes the whole house for something one person did. Like, he’ll take the TV away for two weeks. Nobody is in the house anyway, but he’ll take the TV away for two weeks because somebody didn’t do their chore. Or he’ll dock a room for something one person did. It’s just some of the rules is basically just outrageous.”
-Eugene Adams
Girls Club of New York
Bronx
“I think the rules are fair because my mother never gave me any rules to follow. I always did what I wanted to do and when I wanted to do it. After I had my daughter, I felt as if I was grown, so I did a lot of things I wasn’t supposed to be doing. My mother and I were always fighting one another. That’s when I got sent to Wayside for a year. I learned a lot here. At first I didn’t like the rules, but as I thought about life I realized I had to learn how to do right. Now I follow all the rules. If I didn’t come here, I wouldn’t know right from wrong, but now I do, and I owe it all to my mother for signing the papers.”
-Niesha Hayes, 15
Wayside Home for Girls
Valley Stream, N.Y.
“I don’t like the rules because restriction is stupid. You get restriction for everything. You put a cup somewhere in the wrong place you get four weeks restriction. You don’t eat their food, you get restriction. You don’t go to meetings, you get restriction. You don’t go to school because it’s boring, you get restriction.”
-“Cocaine”
Girls Club of New York
Bronx
“Allowance money is too low. Guys got more than the girls, girls got a lot of things to buy more than the guys.”
-Name Withheld
Girls Club of New York
Bronx
“No, I don’t think it’s fair. Some of the kids in my house, they get more privileges than others because they think they older. It doesn’t matter whether you’re older or younger. We should be all treated the same way. And another thing is that they’re not fair about the phone. ‘Cause when you’re on restriction you’re not supposed to use the phone, but they let other people that’s on restriction use the phone and when we get on restriction, we can’t use the phone.”
-Linda Rodriguez
Girls Club of New York
Bronx
Are the Rules Fair in Your Group Home or Foster Home?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.