One morning this summer in a rush to get out the door I caught a glimpse of the front page of the newspaper. “For the price of a basketball,” the headline read.
I didn’t have time to read the article, but I already thought I knew what it was all about. I could almost picture the two embattled teenagers. “Why did he have to go and kill him for a basketball?” I thought to myself.
I knew if that were the case my father would sit me down that night for another lecture on how dangerous this city is and place some restriction on the time I spend at the park. It probably happened somewhere in Brooklyn or uptown, I thought. (That’s where the hardest ball is played.) But if it happened in Queens, where we live, the speech would be longer and my father’s restrictions more severe.
At the New Youth Connections office I spotted another newspaper and this time had a chance to read the first paragraph. It turned out that two men had been hit by a train while chasing after a basketball in a Manhattan subway station.
It may sound strange but I felt an enormous sense of relief. I asked myself why I had automatically assumed the story was about a violent crime involving teenagers.
‘Young thugs’ and ‘pool punks’
Maybe it’s because the media has fed us so much negative news about teenagers that we have come to expect it. When my mother calls me to watch a story about a teenager on the news, I expect to see him being taken down to the local precinct in handcuffs. I honestly can’t remember a single positive news story about one of us.
“The media has a lot to do with the way people look at us. We’re portrayed as killers and rapists,” said Malene Young Lao, a member of YouthWatch, a group of teens who worked over the summer reading newspapers, watching television newscasts, and analyzing how the media is making us look. The city’s Department of Youth Services created YouthWatch to keep an eye on how the media portrays New York City teens and give them a way of “talking back.”
“Young Thugs Are on the Roam,” “Kids Who Kill,” and “War on Pool Punks” are a few of the headlines YouthWatch cites in its brochure as examples of how the newspapers and television lump all teens together into one category.
Mariela Quintanilla, 18, of West Side HS and a youth leader at Alianza Dominicana, a youth group in Upper Manhattan, believes these kinds of images cause people to stereotype us. “[People] tend to think because one teenager does something bad all of them are alike,” she said.
Time to Talk Back
While it may not be fair to us, it isn’t necessarily bad for business. How many extra newspapers were sold during the Central Park jogger case, when media hype made “wilding” a household word, and turned Black youths into “wolf packs”?
Perhaps if the newspapers stopped exploiting people’s prejudices and took some time out to highlight a special youngster or a youngster doing something positive once in a while, things might begin to change. Two minutes on the news to show a kid who’s trying to make a difference might influence another to try to follow in her footsteps.
What can teenagers do to make things like that happen? The first step is becoming aware. The next is doing things like monitoring the media yourself and writing to the newspapers and TV stations to let them know when you feel they are representing teenagers or other groups in an unfair way.
You can also join organizations like YouthWatch, Alianza Dominicana, and New Youth Connections and work together with other young people. Teens do have a voice-we just need to use it.
Steppin’ to the Media
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.