Mothers and Daughters: Culture Clash

The Joy Luck Club, a new film based on the bestselling novel by Amy Tan, revolves around the stories of four mothers who grew up in the world of traditional China and their far less traditional American-born daughters. Set in present-day San Francisco, it also includes a number of flashbacks that show what the mother’s lives were like back in China.
This movie examines the generational conflicts between the mothers and the daughters and takes a good look at the struggles and challenges women must face in their lives. I especially liked that it contained many strong and independent female Asian characters-something rarely seen in movies today. Although the characters are Chinese, the obstacles they encounter (such as marrying a man you find out you don’t love or having to decide whose needs to put first-your own or your family’s) are definitely things that can be understood by all women.
One of the daughters, June, spends her life trying to please her mother and make her proud. In a flashback we see June as a confident little girl walking on stage for her piano recital. As she begins, she is wonderful, playing every note perfectly. But in the middle of her piece, she loses her concentration and begins to fumble. By the time she’s done playing, she looks out to the audience apologetically and sees her mother’s disappointed face. She also sees her mother’s friend, Lindo, who is smiling wickedly, assured that her own daughter, Waverly, a famous chess champion and long-time rival of June’s, is more of a success.
This scene was very familiar to me because I’m Chinese and I know many Chinese families who are forever competing with each other over their children’s accomplishments. I liked the fact that The Joy Luck Club touched upon this aspect of pressure among many Chinese children to achieve in life.
Hold the Soy Sauce
In addition to accurately portraying some of the values of Chinese families, The Joy Luck Club does a great job of showing the tensions that develop as the daughters become more Americanized. The clash of cultures is made evident when two of the daughters become romantically involved with White men.
One of the funniest scenes in the movie shows the grown-up Waverly bringing her American boyfriend, Rich, home to dinner. She had tried to teach him some Chinese etiquette beforehand but she forgot to mention some things. For instance, her mother brings out one of her best dishes and says that it really isn’t that good because it isn’t salty enough. For the cook to show this type of false modesty is common during Chinese dinners.
What Rich was supposed to do was compliment her anyway and say that it was great. Instead, he takes one bite and says that it isn’t as bad as the mother made it out to be and that all it needs is a little soy sauce. So he begins pouring sauce all over his food. The mother is offended and shocked by what she sees as Rich’s terrible manners but Rich has no idea that he’s done anything wrong.
There’s a more serious look at interracial relationships when another of the daughters, Rose, is taken home to meet the family of her White boyfriend, Ted. Ted’s mother confronts Rose and tells her that even though their family is very “liberal” she doesn’t think that it’s such a good idea for the two to be dating. The mother’s racism made me angry but I think that it was important to include this scene in the movie because we have all faced a situation like this at some point or another and it made the characters more believable.
I also liked the scenes which show how the mothers were treated while growing up in China. Some of my friends said that the constant flashbacks just made the complicated plot harder to follow. But I thought they really helped to explain why the characters act the way they do, which made the story more enjoyable.
The Joy Luck Club is an excellent film because it depicts life in China as well as showing what it’s like for some Chinese women growing up in the United States. But even if you’re not Chinese I think you’ll like this movie because the topics the film deals with, such as dealing with racism and becoming Americanized, can apply to all cultures.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.