Like other children, I wanted to think of my childhood as happy and my parents as loving and supportive. I desperately tried to hold on to that myth as my grades, my social life, and my self-esteem suffered. When reality didn’t live up to my fantasy, I learned to blame myself. Only recently did I begin to face the truth.
For the first 10 years of my life, I lived with my grandparents in Calcutta, India. Then, one spring afternoon, I came home from school and found my grandmother packing. “Are we going somewhere?” I asked.
“Yes, to your parents, in Madras,” she answered.
My parents had sent me to live with my grandparents when I was only a few days old. No one ever told me why. Nor did they tell me why we were going to see them now. Still, I had never been to Madras before, and I was very excited about going to a new place. I’d never been out of Calcutta before.
I went to my grandfather and sat on his lap. “Is it true we are going to Madras?” I asked. Just for a moment, I thought I saw tears in his eyes.
But he smiled and said, “Yes, I’m taking you there.” Immediately I was reassured.
“Oh, boy! I’m going to Madras–to M-A-D-R-A-S,” I shouted and ran out to tell my friends. Not once did it occur to me that my life with my grandparents was about to end.
Meeting My Parents
At first, I found Madras very beautiful. It was like a big vacation for me and my grandfather with the two strange people I had only known from pictures. But after a month, my grandfather left. I was heartbroken–of all the people in the world, I loved and trusted him the most. How could he leave me with these people I had known for only a month? But I tried to make the best of it.
I tried to do everything my parents asked me to. They never really talked to me–just ordered me to do things or not do things. Sometimes my mother would break into fits, shouting that I was such an obstacle in her life. My father too said I was a terrible burden. Soon their words turned into beatings.
My mother was very particular about how she kept her house. She would always remind me that if I weren’t there, it wouldn’t be such a mess. Once she started hitting me because she had asked me to make the bed in a particular way. But I had done it another way. “What difference does it make?” I asked.
That made her even angrier. As soon as my father came home, she told him that I was disobedient and had the nerve to talk back to her. He took off his belt and started hitting me with it. Then my mother grabbed me by the hair and started slapping me while my father continued with the belt.
Another time I had come out into the drawing room not “properly” dressed for company. As soon as the guests left, my mother took a hot spatula from the stove and struck my cheek with it. My skin began to burn. I was so angry I said, “I hate it here, I want to go back.”
Proper Discipline
When my father came in, he started striking me with his belt again. “Do you think we want you here?” he asked. “Nobody wants you here. Such an impossible child–but I am going to fix you no matter what. I am going to fix you–I swear.” And he kept on hitting me.
At school, my teacher saw the burn mark on my face and asked me what had happened. After hesitating, I told her. “Your poor mother,” she said. “Do you know how much it hurt her to have done this to you? But what else can we do? You children don’t learn unless we hit you.”
Another girl in the class raised her hand and said, “My mother beats me with a ruler, but it’s only because she loves me.” In India, it was only part of “proper discipline” to hit a child. Over there, it’s the parents who never hit their children who are looked upon as neglectful.
Even in school we were beaten. Once, all of us who hadn’t done our homework had to stand up and put out our palms so that the teacher could come around and strike us with her ruler. When she came to me she gave a reproachful look and said, “You see, you still haven’t learned, you bad girl,” and gave me my punishment.
At home, my parents said I was the worst kind of child ever and needed a lot of discipline. “A bad child,” they would tell their friends, “So disobedient.”
The fact that I was a “bad” child was the answer to everything. My grandparents had sent me back because I was a “bad” child. Everyone hated me because I was a bad child. I started to believe I deserved to be treated this way.
Prisoner In My Own Home
When I was 12, my father was transferred to a job here. As a teenager in New York City, it became harder to deal with my parents. My friends would go to parties and movies and I would be stuck at home. Sometimes, when I did something they didn’t like, my parents wouldn’t even let me to go to school.
I wasn’t allowed to go out of the house alone until I started going to high school. Then I had to get home by 4:00 p.m. One time I went to McDonald’s after school to celebrate the birthday of one of my closest friends. I only stayed for about 10 minutes, because I didn’t want to get in trouble. I rushed home and got there by 4:20. My mother was waiting near the door and started slapping me as soon as I walked in.
When my father got home she told him to “ask her which guy was she f–king that she was an hour late?” She said I had started to curse at her when she asked for an explanation. I was used to her exaggerating things and didn’t even try to defend myself. I knew my father wouldn’t wait for an explanation. And he didn’t; he just started kicking me and swearing that he would fix me if it took his whole life. I just thought it was my fault. I shouldn’t have gone with my friends in the first place.
My friends would invite me to go ice skating and to their parties. I couldn’t ever go. After a while I just stopped trying to get permission, and the invitations stopped coming. I used to get depressed because I believed no one liked me. My grades started dropping.
Once I tried to join an after-school club. Since it was a writing club, I thought that I could just take the work home with me. But when I found out there were meetings I had to attend, I dropped out. I explained to my teacher that I had to get home by 4 o’clock and that my parents called every day to make sure I was there. “And what would happen if you weren’t?” he asked.
“I would be in trouble,” I answered, trying to say as little as possible.
The teacher wrote my parents a letter asking them to let me join the club but they refused and my father slapped me. He was angry in a way I had never seen him before. How dare I complain to strangers about him?
Although I couldn’t imagine telling an adult about what was happening to me, sometimes I would confide in my friends. “You should call the police,” some said. But the thought of police coming to our house scared me. “Why don’t you run away?” others suggested. Perhaps the worst thing I heard was, “Oh, you’re exaggerating, it isn’t so bad. Both of your parents are together. You are the only child. What are you complaining about? They’re just overprotective.”
The Truth Slips Out
Then one day, during another conversation with my teacher, I blurted out, “They hit me with a belt.” At first I didn’t think he was going to take me seriously. I thought he might say something like, “So what–I hit my kids with a belt too.”
Instead he looked at me very seriously for a moment and then asked, “When was the last time they did that?”
I remembered what my friends had said about calling the police. And I was afraid he was going to do just that. “It’s really nothing–I am the one who’s bad, really,” I said. I was remembering the grade school teacher who had labeled me a “bad child.” I hated the way she had embarrassed me in front of the class, but I preferred that to having my parents reported to the police. I tried to explain to him that my parents believed hitting was the best way to discipline a child–that in India hitting a child was considered appropriate, even necessary.
“But with a belt?” my teacher asked. “I have two children; one is 18 and the other is 21. I have never hit them.”
I just couldn’t believe him. He must have forgotten. I didn’t think it was possible to raise kids without ever hitting them.
“Well, you’re not going to do anything are you?” I asked nervously. Inside, I was thinking, “Oh, God, can’t you just forget it?”
He explained to me that as a teacher he was required by law to report any child he suspected of being abused. The next day I was called to my guidance counselor’s office. They told me that they wanted to call my parents.
That night I couldn’t sleep. I just couldn’t imagine how my parents would react if the school called. The counselor had asked me to describe how I thought my parents would react. All I could manage to say was, “They would be upset.” But that was an understatement. I knew the end result would be that they would take me back to India. I wish I could take back what I had said.
I tried to figure out how to convince my teacher and counselor that talking to my parents would do more harm than good. Finally they gave me a choice: they wouldn’t call my parents if I agreed to go to counseling. Naturally, that’s what I chose.
Once a week, I would go to my guidance counselor’s office and she’d ask me what happened over the weekend, whether there had been any fights. Of course, it didn’t change the situation, but talking about what was happening to me certainly helped me cope with it.
One time I told my counselor how my mother had asked me to iron clothes in a certain order and I had done them in a different order. Before, I had thought I was being disobedient when I didn’t do exactly what my parents said. But my counselor made me feel that it was bad enough that I had to iron everyone’s clothes. She said that my mother had no right to get upset over the order I did it in.
The counselor made me see that other kids did things that were much worse and yet their parents didn’t treat them half as badly as mine treated me. Soon I began to understand that I wasn’t responsible for everything and I didn’t deserve to be treated that way.
Just talking to my counselor made me feel better. I wondered why I hadn’t been able to get to know her before. I guess I had thought that all adults would be like my parents. It was a big relief to find out that it wasn’t true.
I Witness a Beating
When summer vacation came I went back to India for a visit. One day I was walking through a park. Some families had built little homes there. One of the women who lived there was slapping a child so hard that I could hear it from down on the corner.
When I got closer I saw a skinny child, about 4 years old, being beaten by his mother. He was naked from head to heel and his skin was red. Tears were rolling down his face but he wasn’t shouting. It seemed to me that he was used to this.
Suddenly, on an impulse, I shouted, “Stop it!” The woman looked at me, astounded. “Do you want to kill him?” I asked more calmly.
When the mother finally recovered from the shock of my intrusion, she got very angry. “What’s your problem lady?,” she managed to say. “He drank all the milk that we had for the week. Now his father is going to hit me.”
She kept shouting angrily at me: “It’s none of your business what I do with my children.” Just for spite, she struck the kid again. “What are you going to do about it?” she asked.
Isn’t There Anything I Can Do?
A good question. What was I going to do about it? Call the Child Welfare Agency (CWA)? India didn’t even have one, as far as I knew. Report the mother to the police? They would probably laugh at me. Get her therapy? Take him home with me, when I didn’t even have a home of my own?
I looked at the little boy’s face again. The tears on his cheeks were almost dry. I turned away and started to leave. “Ha! These rich people think they can control everything,” she called after me. “Hey, woman, if you love my son so much why don’t you take him with you?”
Suddenly I hated myself. Why did I have to butt in if I couldn’t do anything in the end? Did parents have eternal control over their children? Why was anyone else powerless to stop them? Why didn’t they have a CWA in India? And even if they did, would it solve the problem? In the U.S., we still have cases of kids being killed by abusive parents. I realized I had to learn more about child abuse and what to do about it.
Standing Up To My Parents
When I returned to New York, I decided that no matter what, I was going to help myself and others in my situation. I decided I wanted to do a Westinghouse research project on child abuse. In order to do that I would have to stay at school until 6 p.m. once a week. My parents still expected me home by 4 p.m. every day, but I applied to do the project anyway. I was determined that they weren’t going to stop me.
When I got accepted, it was an ordeal to convince my parents to let me do it. But it was the new me that they were dealing with. I didn’t wait for them to give me permission, I just started going. What could they do? Hit me? It seemed like they hit me no matter what I did.
Sometimes my father wouldn’t let me in the house when I got home after 6 p.m. Once I had to stay out on the stairs all night. My mother said I was getting out of hand and my father agreed. “We are going to take her back to India as soon as she finishes this damn school,” he said. This “American nonsense” was getting to me, they concluded.
One day I came back from school and my father started hitting me with his belt. I was shocked–usually he would at least give a reason before he started beating me.
I thought he had gone crazy. I just looked at him, too stunned to say anything. Then he stopped and said, “This is so that you can do your child abuse report better.” Somehow, he had found out what my Westinghouse project was about.
Later my mother grabbed me by the hair and started slapping me. “A report on child abuse,” she chuckled. “How daring!” She slapped me again. “How daring!” she repeated. Slap! “Child abuse, hah!” Slap!
Suddenly I couldn’t take it anymore. I pushed her away. Before, I would just stand there like a statue and take it when she hit me. But not this time. I left the room and locked myself in the bathroom.
They Knew What They Were Doing
In the bathroom, I cried a little and thought about why they were so upset about my project. I knew kids who were doing projects on dysfunctional families, but their parents didn’t get angry with them. It occurred to me for the first time that my parents knew that they were abusing me.
All along I had been thinking that they didn’t know any better, that it was just the Indian custom to treat children this way. But they were perfectly aware of what they were doing. No wonder when my teachers spoke to my parents they always came away with the impression that my parents were just “over-protective.” My parents had been treating me this way knowing it was wrong and making sure no one found out.
Suddenly I hated them. I had never felt as angry as I did that day. I used to think that it would be possible for us to have a reconciliation when I got older. But I no longer believe that there is any chance of that.
I’m 16 now and my parents still talk about taking me back to India to get all the “American nonsense” out of me. I have other plans, however. I’m going to stay here and study so I can help children like me as much as possible–not just in India, but all over the world. Because no one deserves to be treated the way I have been.
Although I would often cry myself to sleep at night, fantasizing about escaping from my parents, running away from home never seemed like a real possibility. Where would I run? I didn’t have any other family in this country and if I ran to friends I knew that eventually I would have to go back home. I believed that the only solution was to wait until I could go off to college.
In the meantime, I had begun taking other steps to cope with my problems at home. As soon as I entered my senior year, I began looking into being declared financially independent of my parents. I felt that if I was paying for my college education they would no longer have control over me. I gave the assistant principal and a few other people at school copies of the articles I wrote for New Youth Connections about my home situation so they could help me make my plans for the future.
I still didn’t want any outside intervention in the problem but once my story came out, I couldn’t stop things from happening. I will never forget the day when my school decided to report my situation to the Child Welfare Administration (CWA). (School officials are required by law to report suspected cases of child abuse and neglect.) It was a Friday afternoon. My father was called to school and, after speaking to him, the counselor decided that I should not go back home.
I was scared. I stayed in school late talking to one of my teachers. We decided that she would drive me to a CWA office where I could meet with a social worker. The CWA called my father into a meeting. He screamed at them and accused them of kidnaping me and said that our relationship was none of their business. That convinced them not to let him take me back home.
My First Night In Foster Care
I was brought to my new “home” at two in the morning. It was a group home in Brooklyn-a house where a bunch of girls lived together under the supervision of some adult staff members. After the initial paperwork was done, my caseworker left. Alone in that strange place I suddenly felt as if I was going to faint. I didn’t know what to expect or what my future would hold.
I was taken to a room upstairs. At first I couldn’t fall asleep as I thought about the day. I wondered what my parents were thinking and how my grandparents would react when they found out. I wondered whether I would be able to go to school on Monday. But, in spite of all my questions, I felt calm. For the first time in a long time, I wasn’t afraid that someone was going to start hitting me or cursing at me. I fell asleep.
Besides being away from my parents, the biggest adjustment I had to make was living with people my own age, including a roommate. As an only child, I wasn’t used to that. At first I was worried about whether I would get along with the other girls, but most of them were also new to the house and that made it easier.
‘Do You Think You’re Better Than Us?’
Even though most of the girls were friendly, I kept to myself. I didn’t want them to know my business, and I didn’t want to have to share my personal items. (I learned my lesson after I lent my roommate my precious leather bookbag. The next thing I knew, she ran away and I never saw her or my bag again.)
I also didn’t want to get involved in fights. The other girls would fight about clothes, their stuff getting stolen, revealing each other’s secrets, etc. Sometimes my quietness upset them. “Do you think you are better than us?” someone asked me.
Tired of always saying “no” when they tried to get me to talk, I decided to join one of their discussions. Everyone had gathered in one girl’s room even though it was past bedtime and we weren’t supposed to be in each other’s rooms. We went around in a circle, each of us telling why and how long we had been in “the system”-meaning foster care.
The girl to my right said she had been raped by her father and both of her brothers. Another girl admitted that she had stabbed her father. Almost everyone had tried drugs. It was as if they’d heard it all before. Listening to their stories, I started to feel that my own problems were not as severe. Compared to being raped, being beaten and told that you were stupid seemed insignificant.
Just as I was beginning to adjust to the group home, things started to change for the worse. My parents began to convince the staff that I was making up the whole story of how they abused me. They kept saying that I didn’t want to go home simply because they were too strict.
My Father Fought To Get Me Back
My father was determined to prove that the school officials were wrong about him. He hired a lawyer to get me back. My parents called the group home every day and visited every weekend, bringing me clothes that they knew I didn’t wear. Since I didn’t curse all the time like most of the girls and because my parents were so “educated,” the staff decided that I had a good upbringing. They didn’t seem to realize my parents were putting on an act to make a good impression.
The first few times I spoke to my parents after leaving home, I got very depressed. I tried to explain to them how I felt and why it had led to this. Instead of trying to understand me they told me that I was acting stupidly and letting outsiders influence me. They said that the CWA would eventually throw me out into the street and then I would have nowhere to go.
When I told the staff I didn’t want to talk to my parents anymore, they tried to force me to speak to them. Sometimes they would call me to the phone and not tell me that it was my parents on the line. Soon I realized that the only calls I ever got were from my parents! My friends said that every time they called they were told I was not home or that I was upstairs. The staff wouldn’t call me to the phone to talk to my friends. But for my parents, they would even get me out of the shower.
The people who worked at the group home began to tell me I was too “articulate” and “controlled” to have been abused. One staff member asked me why I didn’t want to go home to parents who were so caring. She told me that I was taking up room for someone who could really be helped by the system. I was shocked since this was a place that was supposed to protect my rights, not my parents’ rights.
At times I began to wonder if maybe I was overreacting to my whole family situation. Luckily I had lots of support at school from my teachers and friends. Also, my editors at New Youth Connections were always there for me. They listened to me and gave me the adult perspective on things.
After four months my parents and I were scheduled to go to court. The judge would decide whether I should be sent home or stay in the foster care system. I grew anxious because I knew my parents would never forgive me for telling people about how they treated me. I feared things would be even worse than before if I had to move back in with them.
After many sleepless nights the court case was finally resolved. The judge decided that I would not have to return home.
A New Home
I was glad but I didn’t want to stay in the group home in Brooklyn. The fact that the staff had taken my parents’ side made me really uncomfortable. I wanted to move to a group home in Manhattan that had a good reputation. I went for an interview and was accepted.
At my new group home, I feel that my wishes are respected. I have the freedom to choose if I want to speak to my parents or not. But, in some ways, living here is harder. We have to attend classes to help prepare us for living on our own (they deal with things like setting goals, budgeting money, etc.). We also have to take turns cooking for our housemates. In Brooklyn, we weren’t given as much responsibility, but we also had less control over our lives.
I still have a lot of problems. Even though I got into several colleges, I have not been able to get any financial aid. Since I don’t have my own green card, I’m not eligible. I’m currently working on changing my immigration status so I can get a job and financial aid for college.
The hardest thing about living away from my family is having to make major decisions and deal with their consequences on my own. I have to do everything for myself. I can’t believe the amount of time I’ve had to spend on the phone and in meetings with lawyers and social workers as I struggle to get the things I need from the foster care system.
At Peace and In Control
But, at the same time, I have peace of mind. I don’t cry myself to sleep every night anymore. Nor do I have to be afraid of someone hitting or ridiculing me. Although I still talk to my parents occasionally, I don’t see myself getting close to them again. Instead, I’m learning how to take responsibility for my own actions.
I don’t have any regrets about having to move away from home. Just a year ago I was afraid that my parents would follow through on their threats to take me back to India, where all my college and career plans would go down the drain. I find that I don’t worry about the future that much anymore because now when I make plans, my parents won’t be able to interfere.
I feel like I can finally achieve my goals-going to college, writing, and helping other people in situations like I was in. Being on my own has made me feel more optimistic and more in control of my destiny!
SIDEBAR
Abused Teens: Invisible Scars
Teens who suffer beatings or verbal attacks at home may wonder whether their experience can be considered “child abuse.” They may assume that if they don’t bear visible scars they’re not really being abused. But experts say that that’s not true. “Any behavior towards a child, either action or attitude, which makes them feel humiliated or harms them physically or sexually, lowering their self-esteem” is a form of abuse, says April Feldman, a psychotherapist at The Center for Children and Families in Queens. Feldman counsels abused children as well as adults who abuse. As Feldman points out, teens who suffer abuse don’t always bear the marks that tell outsiders that they’re being hurt. So how do they get help? “Some people can tell something is wrong without you telling them that you have a problem,” says Carol Grannum, the coordinator of Victim Services’ Project H.O.P.E. “Teachers can tell by indications of grades dropping, a change in behavior in the classroom, a change of clothing,” says Grannum.
What Happens If It’s Reported? Teachers, guidance counselors, and doctors receive special training to recognize signs of abuse and are required to report it to a state hotline. “The CWA (Child Welfare Administration) then sends a caseworker to the child’s house to find out what’s really going on,” says Grannum. If the caseworker determines neglect or physical, sexual, or emotional abuse, the child may be temporarily placed with relatives or in foster care. If the child is in danger of being harmed she is immediately taken out of the home and temporarily placed with relatives or in foster care. If the child isn’t in danger but problems are found-such as neglect, or parents who are abusing drugs-the agency may attempt to provide help to the family, such as counseling or other support, while allowing the child to stay at home. For abused teens whose situations aren’t noticed by outsiders, the first and often most difficult step to take is seeking help. Experts say teen victims often hesitate, either because they’ve become accustomed to the abuse, or out of fear that their stories won’t be believed. Renee Hicks, the coordinator of a child abuse prevention program at The Center for Children and Families, counsels teens not to give up if the first person they tell doesn’t believe them. “Tell someone you trust-someone who will believe you,” Hicks says. “If the first person you tell doesn’t, then keep telling people until they do. Don’t be discouraged.”
You Need Help To Heal
April Feldman says another reason victims of child abuse are hesitant to seek help is they don’t want to destroy their family. “It’s hard to say ‘I’m so important I don’t care what happens to anyone else, but I have to get help,’ ” she added. “Help” for victims of abuse is usually counseling by a skilled professional. Experts say this therapy is essential to recovery in cases of child abuse. “The purpose of therapy is to bring those buried emotions to the surface and turn it around in a positive way,” says Hicks. “In spite of the abuse, with treatment, people can learn to lead healthy, active and productive lives.” While some victims may feel they don’t need therapy, particularly if the abuse has stopped, Feldman says the wounds are often deeper than the victims realize. “It affects every area of your life,” she says. Feldman tries to help victims realize they have the right to be angry at their abusers. “Most people feel that since they love their abusers they can’t fight them or report them,” she says. She lets victims know that they can love and hate their abusers at the same time.
