So you don’t like your financial aid award? Think you deserve more money? You should consider appealing your package.
I did-and I got an extra $2,000 the very next day!
In April, I was offered admission to New York University as a transfer student. A few days after being accepted, I got a package from NYU’s financial aid office describing the different scholarships, grants, and loans I was eligible to receive.
But I didn’t think the total amount was enough. So I called the financial aid office to appeal. After nearly 15 minutes on hold (“We’re sorry, all our counselors are busy now. Please hold and your call will be answered in the order in which it was received”), I finally got a live person on the line. I said I’d like to appeal my award.
“On what basis?” the counselor asked.
She asked me to describe any unusual circumstances which could help the appeals committee decide my case.
It was the perfect opportunity to describe family conditions that I could not explain on the financial aid form: My parents live in a foreign country (I live in New York with my brother).
“Do you receive any support from your parents?” she asked.
I don’t.
How Much Do You Want?
She then asked if I had any unusually high expenses (such as rent, medical or food bills). Had I been better prepared, I probably would have come up with something.
Finally, she asked, “How much do you want? It should be reasonable.”
I really wasn’t prepared for that! So I blurted out, “Hmm, $2,000.”
The next day, I got a call from another counselor saying that the appeals committee decided to award me an extra $2,000 scholarship.
Marilyn Varsa, a counselor at Options, a community-based college counseling program, says appealing your award-whether it’s through a phone call, a letter or even a personal visit to the financial aid office-is well worth the effort.
“We recommend that students try to bargain with their school if they don’t get an adequate financial aid package,” she says. “If you have a better package from another school, then show that award letter to the school you really want to attend and ask them for more money.”
Varsa says you also should seriously consider getting your parents involved in the appeal process. She recalls one instance where a parent of a student in her program drove up to the financial aid office at SUNY-Albany to demand more money. And he got it.
But don’t set your hopes too high, Varsa warns. While many schools try to work with students on better packages, economic constraints sometimes make it virtually impossible for them to offer more money, she says.
Nonetheless, if you think you deserve more money, appeal. But be prepared. Varsa says your appeal will be an opportunity to articulate financial and personal conditions that can be best described in person. “It’s always better for the human voice to emphasize these concerns, rather than just having a set of numbers on a financial aid report.”
Financial Aid: You Get What You Bargain For
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.