Zoned Out of Their Minds

Lynn Maison, 17, a junior at Franklin D. Roosevelt HS, had to lie just to get into the school. Her zoned school was Samuel J. Tilden HS but she didn’t want to go there. “I had to give them my uncle’s address and then move over to my uncle’s house later because it was too far to travel,” she said.
Lynn is one of many teens who have been adversely affected by the zoning policy in New York City’s public high schools.
One of the factors in her decision was the school’s diversity. Tilden is over 95% Black, while Roosevelt has a healthy mix of Blacks, Whites, Hispanics and Asians. Lynn, who is Black, says it’s important to learn about other people’s cultures and to teach them about her own.
“When you get to know people that are different from yourself, you get to understand them better,” said Aneka Gibbs, 15, a sophmore at Midwood HS which is very mixed racially. She said it gives you the maturity to stop judging everyone based on stereotypes.
Taariq Lewis, 18, of Wingate HS, agreed. He said diversity makes people more open and flexible. “A Chinese person who has gone to school with only Asians and then goes to college and sees a White person is going to be like, ‘You’re White. Wow! I’ve never seen you before.”‘
Taariq came to this country when he was a sophmore so it was too late for him to apply to Brooklyn Tech HS, the school he really wanted to attend. Brooklyn Tech is 37% Black, while his zoned school is over 97% Black.
Segregated Neighborhoods = Segregated Schools
But getting rid of zoning by itself is not enough to create diversity. Most people will go to the school closest to where they live. “As long as you have segregated neighborhoods, you will have segregated schools,” said Michael Shulman, who has witnessed various efforts to integrate schools in his 22 years teaching at Bushwick HS (97% Hispanic and Black).
One thing is certain: When the zoning line gets to the border between a White and Black neighborhood, it stops-even though the whole point of zoning in the first place was to get rid of these artificial barriers.
Years ago, Andrew Jackson HS in Queens, for example, had the stigma of being a school for poor, mostly Black students. New zoning lines were drawn to bring White students into the school. But it didn’t work. Many White families sent their children to private schools and many more moved out of the neighborhood altogether. Today Jackson is over 95% Black.
Dumping Grounds?
Regardless of race or ethnicity, zoned schools like Jackson often get the reputation for being “dumping grounds” for students with the poorest skills and the worst behavior. There’s at least some truth in it. “Suppose you apply to the specialized schools and no one accepts you,” explained Aneka. “You’re left to go to your zoned school.”
Back in 1984 at a public hearing on “The Crisis in Public Education,” Jackson’s Principal, Dr. Evelyn Jones Rich, explained what happens when a school gets a reputation as a dumping ground:
“Jackson’s student body is Black and poor and generally perceived to be unteachable…thus our most serious problem is the pervasive perception of Jackson as a bad school, as a dangerous school, as a school where little learning takes place…Equally serious is the students’ perception of themselves as failures-as incapable of learning to read, to write, to count…”
Others talked about the way specialized schools and programs lured the best students away from neighborhood schools.
Shaking the Juice
“They create a citywide skimming policy that we compare to orange juice,” said Mattie Evans, of the Educational Access Center. “Our Black youngsters are being treated like the sediment that collects at the bottom of orange juice containers. We’re not shaking the juice right.”
When you don’t shake up the juice, it neither tastes good nor looks good. All the teens I spoke to agreed: zoning just doesn’t work. “If you don’t want to go to a school in your zone,” says Marilyn Mark, a senior at Bushwick HS, “you should be able to go wherever you want.”
Even Bob Terte, a spokesperson for the Board of Education, agrees. He contends that “zoning is kind of a dead issue…We’re moving away from it.”
If that’s true then why don’t we just get rid of it and let teens go to high school where they want?
The answer, according to another Board of Ed spokesperson, Frank Sobrino, is “logistics.” If we did that, he says, there could be “massive shifts” in enrollment. “Students need to have a guaranteed seat in their neighborhood school,” he explained. If they open up every school to every student, he says they couldn’t continue to make that guarantee. Some schools might become even more overcrowded while those with bad reputations would be abandoned before they’re given “time to revamp.”
Schools Do the Choosing
In the meantime, Terte says that there is no other place in America where there are so many choices for high school students. “The problem is getting people to take advantage of the choices.” While that may be true in theory, in practice it usually doesn’t work out that way. The majority of students who try to take advantage of the choices end up in their zoned schools anyway because of limited space in the specialized schools and programs. In many cases students are given priority based on what borough or zone they live in. In the end it’s really the schools that get to choose and not the teens or their parents.
Zoning isn’t as dead an issue as Terte makes it out to be, not for us teens. But simply doing away with it isn’t going to solve anything either. The rich and highly motivated would find the best schools and travel, while the rest would go to a school as close as possible to home, often in segregated neighborhoods. On the other hand, you can’t force it to work either. Look at what happened at Jackson.
Making It Worth the Trip
Even though these problems seem complicated, there are steps we can take. Janet Price, program director at the Fund for New York City Public Education, suggests offering more special programs at the local level to attract a range of talented students from different neighborhoods.
“Why would you want to take two trains to go to Bushwick HS, if you live in Park Slope?” she asked, unless Bushwick offered something you couldn’t get anywhere else. Price said making sure that competitive programs are ethnically diverse would be another important step in the right direction.
She added that students currently have to travel too far to get to choice programs. Price recommends an open system within each borough, so that the schools would be smaller and you wouldn’t have to travel far to get there. “If Medical Science was popular,” she said, “you’d get a high school with that close to your home-but no zones.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.