When you step off the #7 train and out onto Main Street, Flushing at five in the afternoon, you’ll immediately be greeted by loud voices. “Two dala! Two dala! Best bargain in town!” There they stand, all along Main Street and Roosevelt Avenue, with their merchandise spread out on blankets or flimsy, aluminum stands. They are the street peddlers.
The Senegalese sell leather handbags, wallets, hair accessories and gold and silver jewelry (that loses its luster the first day you wear it). Many Middle Easterners have set up fruit stands. Mexicans sell unripe mango slices topped with salt, lemon juice, and/or hot sauce or else they are busy wheeling supermarket carts full of flowers up and down Kissena Boulevard. Italians sell zeppoles topped with a whole lot of sugar. Indians (Punjabis, Sikhs, Gujaratis) sell newspapers, candy, and Duracell batteries.
I’ve lived in Flushing all my life and have witnessed firsthand the sudden boom in street peddling. Recently I decided to find out more about what these people’s lives are like.
My first victims were a pair of young men in their 20’s. One was White, the other Black. They were manning opposite ends of a big blanket covered with hair bands and clips and other merchandise. Just as my friend and I were approaching, we heard a commanding voice:
“One time, warning. Two times, warning. Three times, NO WARNING!” It was an annoyed cop.
“Okay. Okaaaay,” replied the Black vendor sluggishly as he slowly gathered up the four corners of his blanket with all the stuff inside, threw it over his shoulder, and went off-probably on his way to relocate around the corner.
Here Come the Fuzz
I’ve seen this kind of thing happen God knows how many times. I’ll be walking down the block and suddenly I’ll see Roosevelt Ave. in a state of commotion. Peddlers, hauling off their bundles of goods on their backs, scramble from one side of the street to the other. Then the monster appears-the 109th Precinct police van.
The majority of the vendors are immigrants. They don’t have the legal documents, or proper identification to get a vendor’s license, let alone a regular, decent job. Peddling doesn’t require prior training, full command of the English language, or large sums of money to begin. And the hours are flexible.
Maria Rico is a woman in her 40’s, dressed in a long cotton skirt. On a cardboard box covered with a simple white cloth, she had laid a couple bottles of imitation perfume, belts, a couple of pair of earrings, and two pairs of panties that were hanging over the edge. Maria is from Colombia. She came to America to escape the “pobreza” [poverty] back home.
In a mixture of Spanish and English, she told me she sometimes buys her merchandise from an “auction sale” where large stores sell items in quantity. She also sells for her friends, who have their own stores. Although business is not usually good, Maria doesn’t depend on peddling to put food on the table. She sells to help her husband pay the children’s tuition costs.
No Job Skills
I found Ahmed in front of Alexander’s, with a display of exotic African jewelry. He was wearing traditional African clothing of red, yellow, green, and black and had a dirty cloth wrapped around his waist. I started to talk to him, but discovered his English wasn’t that good. He was raised in Uganda. When I asked him to spell his name, he looked at me with his eyes full of shame, and said he didn’t know how.
Lastly, I approached a young Black man, wearing a worn out shirt that was untucked, and a pair of high-water pants. He was selling hair scrunchies at three for a $1. I asked him politely if I could interview him but he thought I was some kind of secret agent. “You be kidding, lady!” he said in a heavy West Indian accent. “I don’t be wanna go to jail. How I suppose to know you not be those police people, lady. I’m sorry. I gotta be earning a living.”
Unlike me, Officer Louis Eiler is one of “those police people.” He has been patrolling downtown Flushing for six years now and has gotten to know many peddlers who are in unfortunate circumstances. Eiler says he sympathizes with them, but he has a job to do. He has to make sure these busy sidewalks stay clear of unlicensed vendors. He usually just warns the peddlers but has also gone to the extreme of arresting them.
When a vendor gets in trouble with the law, she is usually given a summons and has to pay a fine ranging from $25 to $1000. If she is arrested, the confiscated merchandise goes to the Police Property Clerk in Long Island City. It is stored there until the vendor reclaims it, which Eiler says does not often happen because most vendors don’t have the proper identification with which to get their stuff back.
A Vicious Cycle
Instead, the confiscated property is auctioned off. And guess who ends up buying it? You got it-the peddlers themselves. The very next day you’ll see the peddler and her goods back on the sidewalk.
As Eiler and I strolled down Roosevelt Avenue together, an Indian vendor selling copper and brass crafts slowly packed his things and tried to hide behind a cement pole. When I looked back, he was watching us with a self-incriminating smile.
While some immediately take Eiler’s hints, others will give him a hard time. Their excuses range from “Not selling. No business” to pretending not to understand English, according to Eiler. “Sometimes, they really get cute. They’ll ask me: ‘What time are you working till?’ or ‘Boss, when are you leaving?’ They know more than we give them credit for.”
“Most of them know it’s a game,” commented Officer Glen Newman. “It’s a waste. A waste of our time, a waste of their time.”
Community Complaints
If it’s all a waste of time and the system doesn’t work anyway, why bother getting rid of the vendors? According to Regina Colletta, District Manager of Community Board #7, community members gripe about sidewalk congestion during rush hour. They say the vendors are disrupting the business of storekeepers who pay taxes and rent. “What are they [street peddlers] contributing to society?” asked Colletta. “Is it a give and take situation?”
But vendor Engenio Alan thinks that’s a copout. “Instead of criticizing, they [city officials] should try finding a solution,” he said bitterly. “It’s so easy to point the finger.” Engenio is a licensed vendor of handmade jewelry and works in Greenwich Village. He strongly feels the system is “useless.” He sees the police and officials from the Department of Consumer Affairs arrest his fellow, non-licensed peddlers and confiscate their goods. The next day he sees them back on the street again with nothing-no merchandise, no job, no means of survival.
“All we want is a honest buck. No stealing or robbing,” said Engenio. “You see, the police going after these vendors-for what? Committing a crime? Instead they don’t go after the real criminals.”
Engenio and the other peddlers have proposed that the city open the empty lots in Manhattan for them. He said the city could even charge them a small fee. That way they would get out of the pedestrians’ hair, unused land wouldn’t be going to waste, and New York City would be making money at the same time. The city rejected their ideas.
The United States is supposed to be a haven for immigrants, a land of opportunities. The average peddler leads a very hard life and no one is offering them any real alternatives.
The People Who Peddle
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.