My Best Friend and My Boyfriend: She Wanted Him…He Wanted Me

Names have been changed.
Kim and I are best friends. We’ve known each other for six years now. We hang out together and share ideas. We have a lot in common. We even got interested in the same guy once.
We both noticed Mark at about the same time and talked about him constantly. Kim liked him a lot; she thought he was cute. I liked him too, but I never thought about him as a boyfriend.
Kim and I weren’t friends with Mark but, one day in the cafeteria, someone introduced me. We talked for a while and he told me I had pretty eyes. I blushed. That was the first time a guy ever complimented me that way. It felt good.
After that, Mark and I became friends. He used to tell me how he wanted a girlfriend. Since Kim liked him, I tried to bring them together. But when I talked about Kim, he didn’t seem interested.
He Asked Me Out
One day, Mark and I and some other friends were talking about an upcoming dance. He asked me to go with him in front of all my friends.
I didn’t know what to say. I thought he was joking at first, but he wasn’t. Luckily Kim wasn’t there. I knew that if she found out, our friendship would go down the drain.
I wasn’t even sure I liked Mark. But he was the first person who asked me out. If I said “yes,” he would be my first boyfriend.
I wanted to go out with him but, at the same time, I wished he had never asked me. I didn’t want to hurt Kim. I didn’t want to be a bitch.
It took me a few days to finally come up with an answer-I decided to go.
I didn’t know if I should tell Kim or not. I felt guilty when I saw her. I couldn’t bear to tell her, but I knew if I didn’t she would only hear about it from someone else.
‘How Could You?’
After school, I rode home on the bus with Kim and I told her. She listened very carefully and quietly. Too quietly. I kept saying, “I’m sorry,” but she looked like she wasn’t listening. The way her face turned scared me. It wasn’t even angry. It was numb.
“How can you do this to me?” was all she said. She didn’t want to talk to me, and I didn’t know what to do. I wanted to cry. Part of me wanted to go to my very first boyfriend and tell him that I didn’t want to go out with him after all.
But I didn’t. I went to the dance with Mark, and Kim stopped talking to me. Even though I now had a boyfriend, I was lonely.
I wrote Kim a letter saying that I was sorry. But I was kind of angry too. Even though I knew it was all my fault, I blamed her for not understanding how I felt.
She Forgave Me
A few days later, she and I had a talk. She seemed more disappointed than angry. I told her how sorry I was that I had hurt her and she forgave me. But after that, it seemed like our relationship had changed.
If I had a problem with Mark, I felt like I couldn’t tell Kim. I was afraid she might get upset if I talked about him. She was understanding in many ways, and she sometimes helped me out, but we weren’t as close as we had been before.
I went out with Mark for four months. After we broke up, Kim and I grew close again. I realize now how terrible I was, how I betrayed her. I made a mistake that I can never fix, but I know I will never make that mistake again.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.