Is One Parent Enough?

For Natasha Francis, 16, of George Washington HS, whose father died before she was born, the hardest part about growing up in a single parent home has been “hearing the things my friends did with their fathers and not being able to relate to it…Sometimes I wish that my friends didn’t have fathers [either] so they’d know how I feel.”
Every child that lives with one parent has had these kinds of feelings at one point or another. “I feel that I’ve missed out on some type of male influence that every child should have,” said Alicia Garcia, 15, also of George Washington HS.
Whether it’s the mother or father that’s missing, the teens often feel that they’ve been cheated out of something that ought to be theirs by right.
It’s caused Crystal Domingo, 15, of Long Island City HS, whose mother left when she was 5, to feel a lot of resentment. “I am an angry person now,” she says, “and this drives people away from me.”
Not Enough Money
Children from single parent families may feel bitter and left out, and their day to day lives can also be tougher. Dr. Alwyn Cohall, chief of adolescent medicine at St. Luke’s/Roosevelt Hospital, says that because there is only one bread winner, this kind of family usually doesn’t have as much money as a two parent household.
“There is an obvious want for everything,” he explained. “The single parent often has to work double time to take care of the children and try to make ends meet.”
Alicia wishes she had a father, “so my mother wouldn’t have to work so hard.” Joel Phillip, 17, of George Washington HS, who also lives with his mother, complains, “I have too many responsibilities…I have to work all the time and help take care of my brothers and sisters.”
He says he hardly sees his mother at all: “She’s always at work.” Even when she is home, “she’s too busy or too tired.”
Blame and Resentment
Like Alicia and Crystal, Joel’s parents are divorced. In such cases there can be a lot of lingering blame and resentment.
“Children often wonder if the break up is because of them,” said Dr. Cohall. But he said it rarely has anything to do with them. “In some cases it may be so when there is a chronically ill child and either of the parents find that they are unable to cope with the pressures involved. Only then [can it be] considered the child’s fault.”
Victor Perez, 16, of Urban Academy, said because his mother died while giving birth to him, “My father blames me for my mother’s death.” Crystal, on the other hand, blames her father for their situation. “It’s his fault that my mother left us,” she claims.
Not only are there tensions within the family, but society at large can make it hard for teens from so called “broken homes.”
“People stereotype me as a kid who had an improper upbringing,” said Joel. “[They say] this will cause me to turn out bad.”
Alicia has had similar experiences. “People say I was brought up wild because I don’t have a father…they make me feel like an outcast,” she said.
Stereotypes
When they aren’t being judged, teens from single parent households are often pitied. “People feel sorry for you,” said Gerald. “[They] go out of their way to help.”
Natasha said adults call her “the girl with no father…When Father’s Day comes around they get really weird.”
Living with a single parent isn’t necessarily a bad thing, however. Natasha says it’s “normal” for her-she never even knew her father-and it’s enabled her and her mother to form a special bond.
“My relationship with my mother is very strong,” she said. “She’s all I’ve got. Without her I wouldn’t be who I am.”
Gerald Black, 16, of Urban Academy, gets along “pretty good” with his dad. “[He] shows he cares by keeping the family together.” Alicia says her mother is “more like a friend than a parent.”
It Made Me Grow Up Faster
The teens I spoke to seemed to be a lot more positive than those with two parents. “[My father and I] take care of each other,” said Joanna Rivera, 14, of Urban Academy. Among other things she said the experience has forced her to learn how to cook.
Gerald agrees. “It’s made me grow up faster,” he said. “I’m not as childish as my friends.”
Along with their added responsibilities and independence, the teens I spoke to were also more appreciative of what they have. Unlike his sister Crystal, Juan Domingo, 17, of Long Island City HS, said life with his dad has been great.
“I do a lot of stuff with my dad…We understand each other. And because of this we’ve become very close…It was no fun when my mom was with us. They fought a lot.”
Asked if he’d like to have a new mom, Juan said, “If my dad found someone who will make him happy, then that will be great.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.