“The Commitments” is a movie about the rise and fall of a struggling rock and roll band from the slums of Dublin, Ireland.
“There are Blacks everywhere, we are the Blacks of Ireland,” says Jimmy, The Commitments’ tough band leader. He explains that American soul is the only music that captures the reality of their lives (the band members come from a neighborhood of dilapidated housing projects where almost everyone is unemployed).
In one scene, Jimmy has the group watch an old James Brown tape. He tells the band members that the secret to Brown’s magic is performance and soul. “Come on, say it loud, I’m Black and I’m proud!” Jimmy urges the White musicians.
My mother and I were practically the only Black people in the whole theater. We both looked at each other when we heard that. Where did they come up with the idea that they were Black?
Black Like Me?
“Oh, please, give me a break,” I kept thinking. “What makes you think you’re Black just because you’re poor? And who said all Black people are poor, anyway?”
But the movie is funny at times. One scene at Jimmy’s house shows a large portrait of the Pope hanging on the wall. Above it is a picture of the one and only Elvis Presley-who Jimmy’s father says is god.
Jimmy acts tough and confident. His favorite pastime is pretending that he is famous and being interviewed about how he got his start in the music business. But Jimmy is also rather naive. Middle-aged band member Joey leads him to believe that he has toured the world with some of the greatest soul groups of his time. Joey even manages to charm Jimmy’s father, with a story about meeting Elvis.
The band tries to emulate soul greats Otis Redding, Sam Cooke, Wilson Pickett, Ike & Tina Turner, and Aretha Franklin. They rehearse songs like “In the Midnight Hour” and “Try A Little Tenderness”. But their stiffness and lack of coordination prove that soul doesn’t come as easy as expected.
Adoring Fans
The three female back-up singers have a few things to learn about rhythm also. Their three-step choreography is rather awkward and poky at first. But they get better and soon have crowds of adoring fans clapping, cheering, and dancing energetically.
Although their act improves, the band members never quite get it together off-stage. They argue about their personal lives and their “monkey suits,” as one member calls the band’s outfits, copied from the classy suits worn by The Four Tops and The Temptations. Some members of the group want to go out and perform wearing their own clothes; they want to be themselves. Eventually, the band breaks up.
You may have trouble understanding their thick Irish accents and slang at first, but if you love rock and roll music, I guarantee you’ll enjoy this movie. If you’re more of a pop and rap fanatic, this movie isn’t for you. Personally, I’d rather be home watching BET (Black Entertainment Television).
White Band/Black Music: Do the Commitments Have Soul?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.