On inner city streets where young boys are taught to be “nothing less than men,” young gays find it especially difficult to be accepted. “When you’re a Black or Hispanic male and you’re gay,” explains one such youth in the documentary “Paris Is Burning,” “you’re going to have a hard f—g time.”
Being a minority is difficult enough, but being a minority within a minority is even worse. Can you imagine not being accepted by your own people in addition to not being accepted by your White counterparts? Racism and homophobia have robbed them of acceptance and sometimes their lives, but it has not shattered their dignity.
Vogue-ing At Balls
Many gay youths seek acceptance in clubs or gangs known as “houses,” which are substitute families for gays who have been orphaned or rejected by their families. “Paris is Burning” takes you into these “houses,” where members put on monthly fashion competitions called “balls.” Most take place in Harlem, but they’ve moved to other places around the city as well.
“Balls” are an explosion of fantasy and reality in which the participants compete for large trophies by portraying the very people who oppress and exclude them. The balls are a satire of that part of American society which refuses to acknowledge gays-and particularly Black and Latino gays-as human beings. Participants in the executive high fashion category wear business suits and carry attache cases. In another scene, the contestants portray rich men on a yacht drinking champagne.
One of the contestants in the schoolboy category was dressed in a Yale sweatshirt and penny loafers and held a thick text book in his hand. Accuracy and “playing the part” count highly in the judging.
Vogue-ing, which combines the stiff gestures of runway fashion models with the flexible movements of Olympic gymnasts, is one of the main attractions at the “balls.” As the crowd moves to the corners of the room, the vogue-ers flex their arms to the pounding bass from the music and chants of “pop, dip, and spin,” from the audience. All of the contestants are male. Some are dressed in drag and look like high fashion models while others imitate Las Vegas showgirls with glittery costumes covered with feathers and beads.
Living a Fantasy
Octavia Saint Laurent is the most convincing of all the transvestites. He looks so much like a woman that he fools a high fashion model when she interviews him.
These “balls” give Black and Latino gays the chance to live out their fantasies and pass for something they’re not, whether it’s rich, White, female, or straight. They know that once the “balls” are over, they will have to return to lives full of frustration and suffering because of homophobia and racism.
Until I saw this movie I had a pretty negative view of homo-sexuals-I didn’t like them and I didn’t know why. But “Paris Is Burning” made me aware of the problems they face.
In one scene, a transvestite confronts a group of people looking at him in disgust because he is dressed in drag, and says, “If I get cut, I bleed just like you.” “Paris is Burning” is not a movie about minority gay youth, but a movie about human beings who’ve found a creative way to both imitate and mock a hostile world.
“Paris is Burning”
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.