A Family That Plays Together

“The Five Heartbeats” is a film about a singing group of five friends who grew up together like family. It not only portrays the highs and lows of their careers, but also of their personal lives. Of course, it’s hard to separate the two.
Like any family, the band has its share of conflicts. Lead singer Eddie King Jr., brilliantly played by Michael Wright, is plagued with the most problems. He’s a gambler and as the group grows more famous, he also becomes a drug addict and alcoholic.
When the Heartbeats are just amateurs entering talent shows, his father (Paul Benjamin) tells him “You ain’t gonna be s-t because I ain’t s-t.” Eddie’s father doesn’t believe that he can make it as a singer. Even worse, he doesn’t believe that his son will amount to anything as a man. But Eddie’s mother (Marilyn Coleman), supports and encourages her son.
Duck and J.T. Matthews, are the two brothers in the group. Played very convincingly by Robert Townsend and Leon, they have a case of advanced sibling rivalry. In the beginning, they get along well together. They have this game called “shy brother” where if one of them sees a girl he likes, the other one goes and pleads his “shy” brother’s case to her. But the beginning of the end comes when Duck sees a girl he likes, asks J.T. to play “shy brother,” and J.T. deliberately goes off with her.
Unlike Eddie’s parents, their parents are supportive. Their father (Arnold Johnson) is so cool that he even gives them advice on safe sex when they are leaving on their first big tour. “Hood your willy,” he warns. “There’ll be plenty of girls out there.”
Just Bring Back the Gold
Choirboy (Tico Wells), is the son of a minister. He got his nickname because he used to sing in his father’s church choir. His father (David McKnight) doesn’t want him to join the group because he is afraid that the lifestyle will corrupt him. But his mother (Phyllis Apple-gate) tells him to follow his heart and gives Choirboy a bible to take with him, saying: “Just bring back a gold record for me.”
Harry J. Lennix plays Dresser, the most stable member of the Heartbeats. The other members of the group look up to him like an older brother.
The underlying strength of the film is the music. The soundtrack is excellent-filled with Black classics from the sixties plus 13 original songs. The music is very entertaining but it doesn’t overwhelm the movie. It blends right into the plot.
Another strength of the “The Five Heartbeats” is the way it portrays the passage of time. As the group progresses from year to year, the way they dress, even the way they comb their hair (afros and all), changes with the times. Director Robert Townsend also uses black and white still photography to show scenes from their road trips. For example, the grueling stage choreography drills given by Sarge (Harold Nicholas), is shown through a series of photographs. And various magazine covers like Variety, Rolling Stone, and Billboard are flashed across the screen to show the Heartbeats’ rise to fame.
Obstacles Arise
But there are a few obstacles on the road to fame. The band has to contend with the problem of “crossover,” a term used in the music field to describe an artist or song “crossing over” from Black or Latino music charts to reach a wider (White) music audience. During this period, the major record labels were all owned by Whites, so many Black artists had to make compromises. When a record label representative tells the band that he plans to put a White family on the cover of their first album, Eddie angrily tells him: “Crossover ain’t nothing but a double-cross.”
Another obstacle that they have more difficulty dealing with is the growing strain among the members of the group. Petty jealousies, rivalries, betrayals, and a bitter love triangle leads to the group’s demise. But like any true family, all sins are forgiven in the end.
Diahann Carroll, is splendid as Eleanor Potter, the loyal wife of the Heartbeats’ manager Jimmy (Chuck Patterson). And Tressa Thomas, who plays Duck’s baby sister, almost steals the show.
Robert Townsend’s skill as director and actor shows that he has talent. It also shows that his first film, “Hollywood Shuffle,” wasn’t just a fluke.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.