Along with all the Earth Day hype, there’s been a lot of talk lately about how individuals can take action to save the environment. The Sanitation Department has put up thousands of posters urging New Yorkers to cut down on the garbage they produce.
“When shopping, take along a re-usable [cloth] bag instead of accumulating hundreds of…plastic bags,” we are also reminded. “Earth Day is every day.”
But according to experts on the environment, another, equally important issue has been ignored by the media and absent from public discussion: the corporate contribution to the devastation of our planet.
It’s Not All Up To Us
“There’s a tendency…to say, ‘It’s all up to us,’ giving ‘us’ equal weight,” said Alexander Cockburn, a nationally syndicated columnist, in a recent interview with E Magazine. (A bi-monthly magazine published by Earth Action Network.)
“[It’s implied that it’s] as much the responsibility of the working class as of the large-scale corporate polluters working next door,” he explained.
Cockburn, like many others, admits that preserving the environment is everyone’s responsibility. But he says big companies are guilty of far worse crimes than the average American. General Electric (GE), for example, has dumped more toxic waste in the Hudson River than most of New York City’s seven million residents put together.
Media critics like Martin Lee and Norman Solomon, of Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting (FAIR), further point out that in cases like that of GE, the media are often constrained by their own special interests. NBC is owned by GE and, perhaps for that reason, has not shown any interest in investigating who polluted the Hudson River with over 400,000 pounds of cancer-causing PCBs. “For every rare and fleeting reference to corruption by a company like GE [on NBC Nightly News,]” Lee and Solomon write that “We’re likely to hear a thou-sand times the ad lingo: ‘GE brings good things to life.'”
Focusing On the Victims
When they do report environmental stories at all, watchdogs like Lee and Solomon accuse the media of shifting the focus away from those most responsible for the crisis at hand.
“While reporting may sensitively focus on victims of ecological abuse, little light is shed on identifying the perpetrators,” Lee and Solomon write. They insist that nothing is done to illuminate “the potential…solutions and which forces stand in the way.”
For them, the 1989 Exxon Valdez oil spill is a perfect example. The 11-million gallons of crude oil that spilled into Alaska’s Prince William Sound resulted in hundreds of pictures of oil-soaked birds and otters dead on the once pristine beaches.
Profiting From Pollution
When it came to finding out who was responsible, however, environmentalists charge that the media effectively let Exxon and U.S. government regulators off the hook.
Instead, they say the blame was shifted to Captain Joseph Hazelwood, the tanker’s skipper who was allegedly drunk at the time of the accident.
“As with reporting on other environmental disasters, mainstream media stories about the spill did not explain [the] various factors [involved,]” write Lee and Solomon. “The legal and financial aspects of polluting actually work to the advantage of large corporations such as Exxon.”
In spite of all the hoopla and individual consciousness raising surrounding events like Earth Day, experts like these agree that, from the standpoint of the profit motive, private industry still finds it cheaper to pollute and pay token fines than set new standards that will protect the planet. If we each really want to do our part, we’ll have to do something about that.
Editor’s Note: This story was based heavily on an article by Martin Lee and Norman Solomon in the January/February issue of E Magazine.
They are the authors of “Unreliable Sources: A Guide to Detecting Bias in News Media,” published by Lyle Stuart.
Whose Turn Is It to Clean Up?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.