As early as this fall you’ll be able to get free condoms at your school-no questions asked. Odessa Antoine, 17, of James Madison HS, said she thought it was “about time.”
After months of bitter controversy, the Board of Education voted to approve a plan that includes making free condoms, counseling, and AIDS information available to all public high school students. Students will not need their parents’ permission or be required to give their names.
The “Chancellor’s Expanded HIV/AIDS Education Program” was first introduced by Schools’ Chancellor Joseph A. Fernandez last October. Its purpose is to combat the spread of HIV (the virus that causes AIDS) among young people.
“The health of our children is in serious jeopardy,” said Board Member Dr. Westina Matthews, in a speech given before she cast the deciding vote. “On behalf of a child’s right not to lose his or her life to AIDS, I vote yes.”
If everything goes as planned, some schools will begin to make condoms available in September. Within the next year and a half, every high school will have a special room where condoms, reading material, and trained counselors will be on hand for all students. Students from elementary school to high school will receive mandatory instruction in the prevention of HIV infection.
Parents Aren’t Doing the Job
While many continue to believe that this job should be left up to parents, Rafael Verdejo, 17, of Manhattan Center HS insisted, “The school has to play a role…A lot of us aren’t educated at home.” At a meeting with Dr. Matthews where students were invited to comment on the plan prior to the vote, Rafael invited Dr. Matthews to visit his neighborhood and see parents dropping their kids off at school and then going off in search of drugs. “There are a lot of parents who don’t know how to take care of their kids, who don’t [even] know how to take care of themselves,” he explained.
Kim Ross, 16, of Urban Academy admits that her mother “never really sat down and taught me about [sex.]” She believes teenagers are getting pregnant and spreading diseases because they are being taught poorly or not at all. For Julian Howlett, 19, also of Urban Academy, it’s already a little late for that. “I’m already a teenage father,” he said, “so [my mother and I] really don’t discuss [sex] anymore.”
No More Excuses
Richard Chevalier, 18, of John F. Kennedy HS, thinks the plan is important because “At my school…a lot of the students are just too embarrassed to go to the store.” He said students won’t have any more excuses for not protecting themselves. Money will no longer be a factor and “You know you can get it from someone you trust.”
All the students interviewed seem to agree that the plan will help not only to prevent the spread of AIDS and other STDs, but also to lower teen pregnancy rates. But the question remains: Will teens take advantage of it or will they continue to engage in unprotected sex? You can lead a horse to water, but will it drink?
“It depends on the atmosphere,” said Eli Fishman, 16, of James Madison HS. “If it’s gonna be in an environment [where] you walk in and you feel that everyone is watching you and is going to question you, then you [might] feel a little bit uncomfortable.” Rafael worries about the same thing: “I wouldn’t feel comfortable walking into a room saying ‘CONDOMS-Get your condoms.’ ” He goes to a very small school where, “Everyone sees what you’re doing. Word gets around. I wouldn’t want that.”
It Will Take Getting Used To
No one believes that students will rush to take advantage of it the first day but, according to Richard, “It’ll catch on… Once you see your friends go and get some…you’ll feel a little more comfortable.”
David Marshall, 17, of Urban Academy, asserted that he and his friends will go for it. “I don’t think there’s no shame in that game,” he said. But Claude Calixte, 17, of South Shore HS, warned that “You might [still] have kids that…don’t care if they are protected or not. They just want a few minutes of fun.” Julian was even more pessimistic. He doesn’t believe many teens will change their behavior at all. “Condoms and stuff are out there now and nobody is taking advantage of it,” he explained.
Other students foresee people using the program for the wrong reasons. “Some of them will go for it not because they are going to use it, but just to have it as a show,” said Pamela Celia Noel, 17, of Sheepshead Bay HS, “like some guys carry condoms in their wallets to be macho, to be accepted, to be one of the guys.”
“You may [also] have those who would take it as a joke,” cautioned Odessa, “Those are the ones you have to show why condoms are important.” However, Claude doesn’t think the idea sounds like any fun at all. “Having a room filled up with condoms and counselors would take away some of the enjoyment and thrill of [having sex.]”
Added Pressure?
People who fought against the plan, including some religious leaders and parent groups, are worried about just the opposite. They say that making condoms available will only make teens want to have sex: sexually active teens will increase their activity and those who’ve abstained will start.
“You have kids that are virgins and they probably want to save their virginity,” agreed Kimberly Marshall, 19, of James Madison HS. “By endorsing condoms, you are putting added pressure [on them].”
Kim Ross doesn’t think so, however. “The pressure is out there already,” she said. “Kids…are having sex already.”
“It wouldn’t make me want to have sex if I didn’t before,” added Tracy Rainford, 15, of Urban Academy. Eli, on the other hand, conceded that it might encourage some people to experiment “But then you have to think about the other side, that at least they are going to be safer if they use a condom.” He said it could also work the other way around: “It can also scare kids away from having sex-Just the whole pressure about having a condom and needing one.”
Saying No To Sex
One important aspect of the plan is its emphasis on abstinence “as the most effective way to avoid the sexual transmission of the HIV virus.” Students will be taught that condoms are not 100% foolproof and learn about “responsible decision-making and behavior… [and] the risks associated with early sexual activity.”
Some of the strongest opposition to the plan came from the Catholic Church which believes that abstinence is the only approach that should be taught in school. “I’m a Catholic, but there are a lot of things I don’t agree with because of the society we live in,” exclaimed Rafael. He said if we stick to the old rules, “There will be no society [left,] no New York City, no America.”
Opponents of the plan suggested requiring a parent’s written permission before a student could get condoms. “If I ask for permission, my parents would think that I was sexually active,” said Pamela. “They would treat me differently and look at me in a different way.” Richard warned Dr. Matthews that many students would say, “It’s too much of a hassle to tell my parents. I’ll just forget it.”
Requiring parental permission was considered so problematic that people suggested giving parents the option of writing the school a letter saying “Count my kid out.” Dr. Matthews estimated that few parents would write such a letter. However, she said she would support a future amendment permitting parents to “opt out.”
Parents Support the Plan
Meanwhile, most parents seem to approve of the plan as it is-without restrictions on who can get condoms. Jan Atwell, President of the United Parents Associated, publicly endorsed the plan. Bernoudette Adams, a Brooklyn mother of four, told NYC, “I will not want my son or daughter to carry or use condoms, but it should be available [to them] when absolutely necessary…People can say anything that they want, but the final decision is for the kids to make.” Anton Tomlinson, father of a teenage son and daughter, added that a child’s behavior depends entirely on the training she receives at home and said the Chancellor’s plan would benefit everyone.
Adams said that she trusted her children, “but I am still afraid that they will not tell me everything because they think that I might be disappointed with them.” She added that, “A parent who writes the school to count their kids out would be very irresponsible…I would never do that.”
Like it or not, all schools are expected to have a comprehensive HIV/AIDS curriculum soon. And in high schools there will be a room with adult volunteers and written information where the students can go to get condoms, ask questions or just talk to some one with a minimum of hassles.
Condoms, Counselors, Curriculum: What the New Plan Means to Students
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.