Where New York City Teens Drive Cars and Hang Out in Malls: The Long Lost Island

I am often shocked by people’s reaction when I say that I’m from Staten Island. Most of them have never been to Staten Island, yet they say that it’s boring and out of touch with the rest of New York City. There are so many misconceptions about Staten Island-some people think of it as a suburban country club, while others confuse it with Long Island. But most of Staten Island is just like every other borough.
I’m also insulted by the way people try to figure me out based on where I live. The first thing they ask me when I tell them I’m from Staten Island is if I have a boyfriend in Brooklyn. (Bayridge and Bensonhurst are just over the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge.) Then right away they assume I have money and lead a boring and sheltered life.
I was born in Brooklyn and lived there for ten years but for the past seven years, I’ve lived in Graniteville, a middle-class neighborhood near the center of Staten Island. Now I don’t go back to Brooklyn except to shop.
Friends Stick Together
I like Staten Island because my friends and I all stick together. They are like a family to me and I know that they will always be there for me. They know I will be there for them too and we always welcome new people.
Everywhere I go on Staten Island, I meet people who are friends of my friends. In the other boroughs, I feel like people keep to themselves. They have their group of friends and they don’t need anybody else. If somebody says “Hi” to them, right away, they think that the person wants something from them.
Compared to public high schools in the other boroughs, the schools in S.I. are okay. There are seven of them: Port Richmond, Susan E. Wagner, Curtis, Tottenville, Ralph McKee Vocational, Staten Island Technical, and New Dorp. There is one alternative high school: Concord. There are also many private and Catholic schools but few yeshivas (Jewish schools).
I go to Port Richmond HS which isn’t located in the safest neighborhood. We have students from all different neighborhoods-mainly middle class, but also students from poor neighborhoods.
No Metal Detectors
Unlike some high schools in the other boroughs, there are no metal detectors in high schools in Staten Island. But there are drug problems and cut-out problems. A lot more students are now starting to drop out of school and get their GEDs because they feel it is easier than going back for a regular high school diploma.
While most schools in Staten Island have a majority of White students, Port Richmond has a more diverse group of students-about 50 percent are White with the balance made up mostly of Latinos and a small percentage of Blacks.
But schools in Staten Island have very few racial problems. Blacks, Whites, Puerto Ricans, and other races usually get along. I think that most of the conflicts are between cliques.
Cliques seem to be a big part of S.I. teen life, especially in junior high. In my freshman year, I remember walking outside my school and seeing all the rockers on one side of the driveway and all the “guidos” on the other side. Things have changed since then and I’ve noticed that there’s now more mixing.
Rockers, ‘Guidos’ & Preps
At my school, a rocker (metalhead) is somebody who listens to heavy metal, wears rock concert T-shirts, silver jewelry, and ripped jeans. They are usually stereotyped as drop-outs, GED students, and “pot heads.” (People who smoke a lot of marijuana.)
“Guidos” are guys who usually have brushes in their pockets, drive expensive American “muscle” cars, wear Bugle Boy jeans, like dancing, listen to club music, and are mostly Italian. “Guidettes” or “glitters” are typically Italian girls who have their hair teased high and perfect. They usually have boyfriends who are “guidos.” (There’s a stereotype that “guidos” and “guidettes” wear gold and rockers wear silver.)
Preps or preppies are clean-cut boys or girls who wear neatly pressed clothes. Boy preps sometimes wear their hair to the side and girl preps usually wear baggy pants. Preps were at one time stereotyped as “nerds.”
There are other cliques, but these three are the biggest. As teenagers go from junior high school to high school, they start to realize that everybody is their own person and most of them will have friends of all kinds.
The Beaches and the Mall
What do Staten Island teenagers do for fun?
Well, many teens drive to parking lots along the beach for fun. The rockers usually go to South Beach; “guidos,” Midland beach; and the couples who want to just get away from the crowds go to Gateway Beach. In the summer they have keg parties (beer parties), and in the winter, teens just sit in their cars in the parking lots.
Most teens go shopping in the Staten Island Mall (the only mall on the island) and many of them also work there. Young kids 10-13 years old usually go to the mall for fun. My 11-year-old sister becomes really excited when her friend’s mother drops her and some other girlfriends off at the mall. I think it gives them a sense of independence and freedom.
Staten Island teens also go to theaters, bowling alleys, pool clubs, miniature golf clubs, diners, restaurants, teen dance clubs and teen bars (which don’t serve them liquor), cemeteries, forests, or just in the neighborhood to have fun.
No Car, No Fun
Some teens go to Brooklyn, Manhattan, New Jersey, and elsewhere because they feel Staten Island is boring. It’s not that Staten Island is boring, it’s that you have to look for things to do, you have to know the right people, and you need some kind of transportation. In Staten Island, it is necessary to have a car, or at least have friends who drive. Most S.I. teens have their license by the time they’re 17.
Staten Island has the reputation of being the safest borough in New York City. The crime rate is low but there are “bad” neighborhoods. (One bad neighborhood is right by the St. George ferry terminal.) A bad neighborhood is one where crime occurs fairly often, by Staten Island standards. Bad neighborhoods like St. George and Park Hill have a reputation for drugs and racial conflicts.
Staten Island Doesn’t Discriminate
There aren’t many homeless people on the streets of Staten Island. If I saw a homeless person sleeping on the street, I would right away assume I wasn’t in a good neighborhood and would never walk there alone at night.
Staten Island is not all that people make it out to be. In some parts, there are extremely wealthy people, while in other parts there are poor people. But I suppose it’s mostly middle-class. I have a friend who lives in a 15-room house with a live-in maid and a swimming pool and another friend who has to hold two jobs to survive. Despite the stereotypes, most people in Staten Island are not prejudiced; Staten Island does not discriminate. It is a place for all people.
Editor’s Note: “Guido,” “guidette,” and “glitter” are sometimes considered to be derogatory expressions.

SIDEBAR: What Does Staten Island Mean to You?
What images come to mind when teenagers think about Staten Island? A few teenagers were asked to give their opinions.
What do you think of when you hear Staten Island?’
Kevin Corbett, 16, Xavier HS, (Brooklyn resident): “Honestly? Heavy Italians, very suburban areas, the garbage dump [Fresh Kills], the mall, all the cuijines [similar to guidos] going to the mall.”
Rina Montaoban, 18, graduate of St. Dominick Academy, Jersey City, (New Jersey resident): “I think of my cousins that live like pseudo-suburbanites.”
Alice Marino, 18, recent graduate of LaGuardia HS, currently attending New York University: “[People who are] very concerned with their appearance…racist, sexist, anti-semitic. Mostly guidos-a lot of them are very rude.”
How would you describe Staten Island?
Kevin: “I think it’s a nice place. It seems to be for the most part. It’s a nice place to raise a family from what I’ve seen. I notice that a lot of houses are exactly alike. In a sense, that sort of symbolizes…the way a lot of teenagers seem to have very identical lives.”
Rina: “There are trees. There are houses. It’s safer than Jersey City and quieter…It is a city, but it is as quiet as a suburb.”
What are some of the good points about Staten Island?
Alice: “I like the fact that there are woods and parks and not wall-to-wall buildings.”
Giuseppe John Daconta, 18, former Susan E. Wagner HS student: “There’s less crime than in the inner city and I think people are more sociable.”
Candy Jacobsen, 18, graduate of Susan E. Wagner HS: “Personally, I think it’s just too small because there is always somebody who knows somebody.”
Do you think Staten Island should be independent and separate from the rest of New York City?
Alice: “Only because we get everyone’s c-p. We really do-the dump is just one sign of it.”
Giuseppe: “Yes, I would. If we became our own county of New York State, our income into Staten Island would be greater and we wouldn’t have to bother with Dinkins anymore because we would have our own mayor. I think that [we’d be] better off that way because Dinkins has been dumping all this s-t on us, as in tax increases and more city employee lay offs.”
Editor’s Note: In the November, 1990 elections, 82% of the residents of Staten Island voted to study the possibility of separating from New York City. After this study which will take 3-4 years, the residents will vote on the issue again. If they vote yes, the state legislature in Albany would still have to approve it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.