The gorgeous “mosaic” that elected Mayor David Dinkins saw hope in his words of equality and recognized a rare opportunity to improve its lot in life. But…
It all began on January 1, 1990 when New Yorkers read Dinkins’ lips for the first time on the steps of City Hall. In his inaugural address, the city’s new chief declared the “Administration of the Child.”
It soon became apparent that this promise was not going to be fulfilled. Mayor Dinkins drastically cut the Board of Education’s requested budget in his first city budget by about $43 million this past July. As a result, students who returned to school in September found services reduced and programs eliminated. Afterschool centers that were operated by the Board of Ed for years never re-opened their doors. Guidance and counseling services were reduced and class size fluctuated. Unfortunately, the worst was yet to come.
A continuously widening budget gap is an ominous sign that the city is heading for financial disaster. In early October, Dinkins began to fully comprehend the magnitude of New York’s fiscal woes. But it was too late-he had already offered a 5.5% raise to the United Federation of Teachers (UFT). Other unions quickly demanded comparable raises.
5.5% Raise
Even if the teachers deserve a pay raise, that doesn’t mean the city can afford it. And if the city is going broke, the money will have to come from somewhere. Among the aftershocks will be a $90 million cut (2%) in the Board of Education’s $6.5 billion budget which will take effect in February. While a budget cut was inevitable in such a crisis, it probably would have been less severe if Dinkins had not struck a sour deal with the UFT.
This 2% cut, ordered by the mayor in October during his across-the-board slash of agency budgets, was defied by Chancellor Joseph Fernandez. He warned that a $90 million cut would seriously hamper efforts to revitalize the schools, and would also disrupt classroom instruction. Fernandez submitted a plan outlining cuts of $45 million (1%).
Administration of the Child?
Dr. Fernandez’ plea was rejected at City Hall as Dinkins stood firm behind his original demands. Following a week-long war between the two superpowers, Dinkins refused to compromise. Result: the city’s almost 1 million students will feel the pain of the budget cutting ax. Ironically, losing $90 million could mean layoffs of several thousand teachers. It will also cause the elimination or reduction of many school services ranging from extra-curricular activities to guidance.
Fernandez’ defiance was based on the type of fairness which Dinkins so often speaks of; he felt that the school system should only be forced to make a 1% cut-the same as the Police and Corrections Departments. It is sad that a mayor who declared an “Administration of the Child” is not placing the same priority on preserving the city’s educational services as on hiring thousands of cops.
Bowing To Media Pressure
To be fair to Dinkins, there was tremendous media pressure to increase police presence on the streets. Unfortunately, those who control New York’s media do not care about preserving youth services and the public education system. They don’t have kids in the public schools. But they do want to be protected from the youngsters who are not adequately served by these failing institutions.
The mayor, however, did not have to submit to the media’s will. A plan that would simply add more cops is destined to fail because it does not attack the root of New York City’s crime problem- the need for effective social services, especially for youth who are blamed for much of the city’s troubles.
Dinkins Cuts His Commitment to Kids
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.