Getting the Word Out: AIDS Ads Don’t Reach Teens

To many teens, the AIDS advertisements they see on TV, the subway and around their neighborhoods are neither interesting nor informative enough to be worth their attention.
“They’re full of statistics and other stupidness. They don’t get to the point,” said Teresa Francis, 19, of Youth Force, an organization which produced its own youth-written booklet on AIDS. “All they do is repeat themselves but they never send real messages,” added Indhi Dailly, 17, of Central Park East Secondary School and an intern at the Educational Video Center (EVC), a place where teens produce videos for other teens.
But one ad in particular impressed Henry Diaz, 17, of LaGuardia HS and another Youth Force organizer: “A pamphlet with a real guy, putting [on] a real condom.” According to Teri Lewis, Coordinator of The Adolescent Aids Program at the New York City Department of Health, ads like that aren’t so easy to do. She says there are barriers to being explicit about sexuality in advertisements and leaflets. “A lot of institutions don’t want to offend people,” she explained.
The Wrong Emphasis
Another reason teens aren’t paying attention is because of what they consider to be too much emphasis on abstinence. “When they say to abstain, kids are like ‘yeah right’ and then they do it [have sex] anyway,” said Trevor Brown, 17, of LaGuardia HS and a Youth Force volunteer.
Meanwhile, teens are hungry for information. Dailly said advertisers and educators just focus on death and don’t teach you anything about the virus itself. He recommended they “be more explanatory about the virus and what it does.” Some say that information would go in one ear and out the other, but Emilio (Skyway) Rivas, 21, of University Heights HS insists, “When you break it down to teens they will understand and won’t forget.”
Lewis agrees that ads which “talk down to teens [or] have fear messages” aren’t effective. “They just try to keep people ignorant and fearful,” she said. “They are successful at scaring people, but not really at other things.”
Fear Messages
One of the worst examples of this, according to Francis, is an AIDS education manual put out by the federal government. “A lot of kids probably tossed it aside or in the garbage,” she said. “If they did read it, it would seem like it talked mostly about death and how people of color were more likely to die of AIDS. It made it seem like there was no hope.”
Francis worked with other teens at Youth Force to come up with an alternative- “YOUth Can Stop AIDS” which emphasizes what young people can do. She feels that the most effective information comes from videos and youth-written AIDS pamphlets like theirs.
A lot of adult advertisers direct their messages towards teens because many are behaving irresponsibly and catching the virus. “It is important that we maintain respect, and don’t condescend or preach,” said Ann Sternberg, Director of Media and Materials at the AIDS division of the New York City Department of Health.
Sternberg says she is “not fond of ads that show cemeteries…You don’t gain people’s respect and trust by scaring them. You’re more likely to achieve success if people perceive positive benefits for themselves and their families,” she explained.
‘Cautious Humor’
“I’m not impressed by dancing condoms [either],” she added. Occasionally people pay attention to ads that are funny but Sternberg said, “It’s dangerous when dealing with sensitive subjects.” She said “Rubber Up For Safety”-which is a play on the old “Buckle Up For Safety” ad- is a good example of what she calls “cautious humor.”
Beth Anne Rominiecki, 18, of City-As-School and EVC would like to see more documentaries about actual people with AIDS and Guy Voltaire, 17, of City-As-School (and EVC) thinks the answer would be for teens to “get together with teens infected with the virus so they can better understand.”
These and other recommendations suggest that there are limits to what you can accomplish with an ad or a brochure. “The media can’t do it alone,” said Lewis. “There have to be a lot of different inputs.” Several of the teens interviewed stressed the need for more AIDS education in school.
‘Take the Time to Find Out’
“I thought I knew everything about it but I took a test on AIDS and I passed with a really low grade,” said Diaz. “I know the basics but not the details.” “They should have more classes that give health ed information,” Rominiecki added.
The teens interviewed feel that the problem is not so much that the AIDS crisis is being overly publicized, but rather that it’s being publicized in the wrong way. They think advertisers and educators should not only tell you that it kills you but how it kills you. They also say ads should be more “real” and “get to the point.”
Part of the problem, however, lies with the teens themselves. “A lot of teens are ignorant and don’t want to learn because it’s a scary issue,” said Carolie Jenkins, 17, of Martin Luther King HS, who is also an EVC intern. The job of educating can’t be done by teachers and advertisers alone. According to Anthony Ojeda, 18, of EVC, “You gotta take the time to find out. You gotta look for the information.”
Editor’s Note: The Health Department welcomes suggestions on how to improve quality or placement of AIDS prevention messages. Write or call about what you want to hear and see: Ann Sternberg, Director of Media and Materials, NYC Dept. of Health, 311 Broadway 4th Floor, New York, NY 10013. Telephone: 212-285-4631.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.