Not too long ago, I was walking down the street when I saw a girl who I thought was stupid fly. She must have noticed that I was clocking her because she walked up to me and said, “Hi.” We talked, exchanged names, and she gave me her phone number.
On the way home that day, I thought about how many times a guy decides to go out with a girl based only on her appearance. You know the scenario-you’re in the classroom and two girls are interested in you. One is crazy dope and the other is smart but not-so-fly.
You may hardly ever speak to the fly girl, but you get along great with the intelligent but not so good-looking girl. Whom do you choose? Tuff one isn’t it? Of course you may initially talk to a lovely female because that is what you see first, and you can only find out that an average-looking female has a head on her shoulders when you’re forced to talk with her and get to know her.
Now, the question posed is what do guys look for after meeting girls-brains or beauty?
What Do Boys Want?
Joseph Smith, 17, of Brooklyn Technical HS, responded: “Beauty, because I think I’d feel more comfortable with a nice-looking girl than a not so nice-looking girl.”
“I choose beauty because you can’t make love to brains,” agreed Ralphy Gilby, a senior at South Shore HS.
“Beauty, because I really don’t need a relationship where we sit down and have an intelligent conversation”‘ said Chris Shaw, 17, of Lafayette HS. “It could be nice, but what a girl looks like is very important…at this time in my life.”
“I think guys today prefer beauty because most of them don’t really want a relationship-they’re after one thing-sex,” claimed Jamahe Proctor, a senior at Brooklyn Tech.
But not all guys feel this way. “With beauty, you can only fool those that are as dumb as you are,” noted Snello Emmanuel, a senior at South Shore HS. He added that a beautiful appearance “will not get you anywhere beyond a motel.”
“Brains is what makes a woman interesting,” said Jacques Lorquet, a student at Midwood HS. He explained that he doesn’t look for beauty queens because “Those girls wind up hunting the fellows.”
One of the main reasons young guys tend to choose gorgeous girls is to impress their friends. “I think the guys will prefer beauty because they will feel like a ladies man if they have a fly-girl on their arm sweating them,” said Jacques.
On the other hand there are guys who give brains and beauty equal weight and wouldn’t substitute one for the other.
“I like brains and beauty. I feel that both are important because of course, she can’t be stupid. And secondly, she has to have a nice firm body to keep my eye on her you understand,” explained Yves Zanor, a senior at Washington Irving HS.
What Do Girls Want?
How do girls feel about this debate? Asked whether they felt most guys liked beauty over brains, a few girls responded:
“I believe guys prefer beauty over brains because if a guy sees a girl, the first thing he sees are her looks,” said Malvina Godish, a senior at Midwood HS.
“You never hear a guy say, ‘Look at the brains on that girl,'” agreed Irina Gold, a junior at John Dewey HS.
“Guys like to walk around with a pretty girl on their arms so that other guys could look up to them and give them respect. They also think it makes them look good,” said Danielle Littles, a senior at A.Philip Randolph Campus HS.
Leah Walker of Norman Thomas HS felt that most guys would rather date a good-looking girl over a smart one. She explained that guys never say: “She’s ugly, but she has a great brain.”
“I think guys go with girls for their beauty. I say this because they don’t want to walk around the street with an ugly girl because they don’t want their friends to dis them,” added Kim Hines of Washington Irving HS.
But many girls don’t appreciate guys who only look for beauty in a female. Danielle said that guys who do that are jerks. “That’s discriminating against [the] other females.”
“The unattractive girl may really be a nice person and the guy is not giving her a chance because beauty can also be on the inside,” agreed Althea Jameison, a student at William E. Grady HS.
No Brains, No Date
“You will not be able to go out with a person if you don’t like anything about them except looks,” pointed out Irina.
On the other hand, some guys felt that females were just as guilty of choosing good-lookers over brainy types.
“A lot of girls go out with not so good-looking guys, but then again a lot of girls want to be with a cute guy,” said Althea. Even so, she felt that guys were much more guilty of discriminating on the basis of looks.
“I find that having the brains and looking good at the same time attracts me the most. I couldn’t go out with anyone with no intellect,” concluded Sophia Massop, of Midwood HS.
What Do Guys Want?: Beauty or Brains?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.