In a democracy people have the right to choose for themselves. In a dictatorship all the important choices are made for you. Either we are going to live in a democracy or a dictatorship. We can’t have it both ways.
Government officials feel that some music gives people, especially young people, the wrong ideas. They believe that someone listening to a song expressing racist or sexist ideas may adopt those beliefs. But music is not going to change your beliefs. If you didn’t believe it before you turned on the radio you won’t believe it after you turn it off.
They say if the music is sexually explicit, kids will go out and have sex. If the music is violent, it will lead a listener to go out and rape or attack someone. Music doesn’t have that much power over people. It may be good to dance to but it won’t make you kill anyone.
The Government Shouldn’t Tell Us What To Listen To
I understand that certain pieces of music may not be appropriate for young listeners. If the lyrics are profane, sexist, racist or speak too openly about sex, parents might not want their children to hear them. In that case, when a song that they don’t approve of comes on the radio, it’s the parents’ job to change the station, and to make sure their children don’t buy the record, go to the concerts or watch the videos. I realize it’s hard to monitor everything your children see and hear, but government censorship infringes on the rights of people who are old enough to decide for themselves.
A lot of people think that by banning songs with sexually explicit or vulgar lyrics they are making sure kids don’t hear the things being said. I disagree: If kids don’t hear it in music, they’ll hear it on the street or in school. Profanity, racism, sexism and violence are everywhere.
Even if the music were banned, people who wanted to listen to it would find a way. People get videos of movies that haven’t even been released. They make copies for their friends and sell them on the black market. I don’t think getting a record would be too much of a problem.
In fact, trying to censor music just makes the public curious as to what the controversy is all about. I never paid any attention to the lyrics of “Me So Horny” until people started talking about censoring them. In its effort to ban the music, the government is just making it more popular.
You might think banning a crude song like “Me So Horny” is unimportant. But if we allow the government to make that choice for us, it won’t stop there. Next they will be telling us what to wear and what to eat for breakfast. Eventually we will be living in a dictatorship where we won’t be able to decide anything for ourselves.
Music Censorship: Democracy or Dictatorship
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.