Schools Chancellor Joseph Fernandez has finally taken his first step towards ensuring student involvement in running the city’s schools. Last summer he authorized his staff to draw up a plan to create a citywide “Student Advisory Council” (SAC).
The plan fits within his commitment to giving parents, teachers and students themselves a greater role in the decision-making process.
Thomas Gentile, a summer intern at the Chancellor’s office, submitted the plan to Fernandez on August 28. The plan would create a 15-member student advisory group, or cabinet, which would meet with the Chancellor.
Didn’t Consult With Enough Teens
Since then, several youth groups and advocates have criticized it. They said that the plan won’t allow adequate representation of the diverse student population. They attributed this and other weaknesses to the failure of the plan’s creators to consult with the young people themselves.
“It was really stupid of the man [Gentile] to go ahead and draft this when he only consulted three youths,” said Henry Diaz, 17, a junior at LaGuardia HS. Diaz is also an organizer at Youth Force, a program of the Citizens Committee for New York City. “Three youths can’t tell all the needs and wants of the city’s students.”
But Ed Seto, special assistant to Deputy Chancellor Amina Abdur-Rahman, insisted that his office had made sure copies of the proposal were distributed along with evaluation forms in several high schools and youth agencies. Seto said he and his staff had been reviewing student feedback from twenty-five schools. “The [young people’s] recommendations gave us a sense of how the students felt,” he said.
How Many Students Will Be on the Board?
According to Seto, the size of the council was the students’ primary concern. The current proposal outlines two possible ways of organizing the council: The first would be a large assembly consisting of one student representative from each high school, which would mean a group of over 100 students. The second plan calls for a 15-member, “cabinet-style” body elected from students in the current borough councils.
In his plan, Gentile argued that, unlike the large assembly, a small cabinet would be able to have an open dialogue with the Chancellor-the main goal of a student advisory council. For this reason, he concluded that a larger council was not the way to go and did not offer any detailed plan for setting one up.
Seto said that three-fourths of the students he surveyed supported Gentile’s conclusion and favored the smaller, “cabinet” version. Youth Force members, along with other groups that evaluated the plan, challenged Gentile’s analysis and recommendations. They stressed that a panel of only 15 students would not be large enough to reflect the diversity of New York City schools.
Youth Force presented an alternative plan on October 5th at a youth “speakout” sponsored by Manhattan Borough President Ruth Messinger. Their plan called for setting up a “student congress” with two members from each high school including those operating in drug treatment centers and prisons.
Giving a voice to students with varied grade point averages from different school cliques or “crowds”-as well as to those with special concerns like immigrants and the disabled-would better represent all students, according to Youth Force.
Proposals Range From 15 To 250 Students
After taking the different recommendations into account, Seto said his office is leaning toward a 28-member council, slightly larger than the original 15 but a far cry from what organizations like Youth Force have in mind. (The “congress” they advocate would have over 250 members.)
The 28 member model would draw its members from the existing borough councils. Officials at every school select two student representatives to sit on these councils. Seto’s working plan would bring 5 students from each borough council and three representatives from the city’s alternative high schools to serve on the Chancellor’s Student Advisory Council.
“I think we can do it [with 28 members] without impacting on diversity,” Seto asserted, responding to the fears of groups like Youth Force that are still not satisfied and insist that the plans do not reflect the realities of the school system.
“This isn’t about student empowerment,” declared Dana Vincent, 17, a senior at Clara Barton HS and another Youth Force organizer. “It’s a puppet program that would meet with the chancellor whenever he wants.” Vincent is a former member of the “almost defunct” Brooklyn student council. “We never did anything. We just talked,” she said about her experience there. “It was one of those things where you just go and miss classes…They fed us. It was good food-not school food.”
Chancellor’s Student Advisory Council Proposal Debated
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.