What Price Glory?

NYC Rating: ***
I didn’t want to see “Glory.” There is something about movies based on true stories that I don’t like. I usually protest when a friend drags me to one-and that’s how I felt until I saw “Glory.”
It is about the 54th Massachusetts Infantry, composed of Black soldiers and led by Colonel Robert Gould Shaw in the Civil War.
“Glory” is a typical “White man’s burden” movie. The main characters are White and the story is told from a White point of view. The movie is largely based on Col. Shaw’s letters to his family, so, to be exact, it is told from Col. Shaw’s point of view.
At first I got the impression that Col. Shaw (Matthew Broderick) was a rich, spoiled, White boy who only got his commission because of his rich, powerful daddy and his rich powerful friends. At first I thought he would not care about his Black troops. I was wrong.
Encounters With Prejudice
The main Black characters are Trip, Rollins, and Searles. These men are very different. Trip (Denzel Washington) is a strong-headed runaway slave, Rollins (Morgan Freeman) is a smart and peaceful man, and Searles (Andre Braugher) Roger is an educated free man who also happens to be a good friend of Col. Shaw’s.
The soldiers of the 54th experience much prejudice, even among themselves. They are denied materials by the Army, such as shoes, socks, and uniforms. The men keep asking, “When are we gonna get the `blue suit?'”
In one scene, the 54th gets into a run-in with another unit. Rollins, who had been promoted to the rank of Sergeant Major, tries to pull rank over a White soldier. The soldier refuses to obey his order and starts a scuffle.
Col. Shaw tries to be fair to his men, but sometimes tries too hard to be a leader. When Trip runs away, Shaw is forced to have him flogged in front of the troops. When they expose Trip’s back, you could see the scars from the many floggings he had in the past. A tear rolled down his eye as he looked at Col. Shaw.
I came to realize that Col. Shaw really did care about his men. He used his rank over another officer who wouldn’t supply the men with necessities.
Standing Up For His Men
In one scene, when Shaw notifies the men that they will receive less pay than White soldiers, Trip convinces the soldiers to tear up their pay in protest. Col. Shaw fires a shot in the air and then says, “If you will take no pay, then none of us will,” and proceeds to tear up his pay.
Col. Shaw also did his best to get his men into battle, which included blackmailing higher officers.
The 54th was a successful unit. The men were proud to wear the “blue suit” of the Union Army. They were chosen to lead the assault on Ft. Wagner in South Carolina in 1863.
As they were on the beach getting ready to lead the battle, the other troops were cheering them on. It was beautiful. A tear fell down my eye.
Throughout the movie I had a smile on my face-except for the battle scenes, when I was sitting on the edge of my seat gasping.
Glory is an amazing movie. It is full of emotion. You laugh, you cry, and get excited. In the immortal words of Siskel and Ebert: “Two thumbs up!”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.