Getting Along With Stepparents Is Not Always Easy

Remember the tale of a young girl named Cinderella who was treated badly by her stepmother? This fable makes stepparents look evil. For some teens the fable has a lot of truth, while for others it is just a fairy tale.
My mother remarried when I was 10. At the time I thought, “Oh boy, now I can get things from my mommy, my old daddy, and my new daddy.”
But I soon learned otherwise.
I mean, my stepfather seems to really try, but I just don’t appreciate all of the things he “tries” to do. That means most of the time my stepfather and I make the house miserable with our arguing.
Usually I don’t even speak to my stepfather, because I know our discussions will turn into arguments by him disagreeing with me or correcting me.
I see him trying to change the values I got from my father, and I resent this.
Sometimes I feel he does these things just because he is my stepfather, and is trying too hard to treat me as he thinks my real father would.
Some Teens Are Threatened
Some teens feel threatened by a stepparent coming along and taking the place of a natural parent, while other teens react very differently.
“I am very happy living with my stepmother. I see my real mother, but I’d never live with her. I couldn’t live with her, because I think I’d kick her in the neck…she left me in the hospital when I was three years old.”
This is how 18 year old J.J. feels about his real mother. He has lived with his stepmother and father since he was three. They went through legal procedures to adopt him because was living in a foster home.
J.J. said the biggest dispute he ever had with his stepmother was over bringing his hand revolver into the house. Otherwise he feels that having a stepmother isn’t so bad.
J.J., like most teens, didn’t really care that he lived with a stepparent when he was very young. Nothing much matters when you’re young, because you are not really aware of the situation.
“I didn’t care, because I was not in the mind to care. I liked her
because she took care of me,” J.J. said.
J.J feels that his stepmother has completely replaced his real mother, because his real mother abandoned him, and his stepmother doesn’t play favorites with her own natural children who live in the house.
“She treats me just like a son, and I like that. I have eight brothers and one sister, and none of us get special treatment.”
Tiffany [not her real name] feels much the same way about her stepfather. She was four when her mother remarried. Now she’s 17.
“I was young, so I didn’t really know much, all I knew was that I was happy because he spoiled me. Now, I think he’s great. He’s very lenient and not a pain like my mother can be.”
Tiffany said that she can’t stand her real father and would never live with him. Even though she argues with her mom all the time, and sometimes argues with her stepfather, she wouldn’t leave her stepfather for anything.
“I hate my real father, he doesn’t care, and he doesn’t do anything for me. I love my stepfather, he’s so sweet,” said Tiffany.
Dealing With Tension
One person I spoke to shared many of my views about her stepfather, so I was able to sympathize with her.
Unlike the other teens I interviewed, Shawn, 18, feels that there is always some tension with her stepfather.
“Even though I was young, there was always something there-it was just sort of camouflaged. Things changed drastically four years later, when he [her stepfather] had his own child.”
That’s when she said her stepfather began to act like a Vietnam veteran who just came back from the war “kinda’ crazy in the head.”
Shawn said that she is not on speaking terms with her stepfather. The relationship between her and her mother is more of a “water than blood” relationship-they are more like two associates than mother and daughter.
Shawn is in a difficult position-she seems to be drawn away from her mother because her stepfather has come between them, but she is not close to him either.
“Just last week, my mother let him literally fight with my sister.” Shawn was angry about this, because she knows her real father would never actually have a fist fight with either her or her sister.
Shawn said, “I was taken out of contact with my father. I think it may have been because my mother was sort of jealous. It’s been so long that I don’t know how I feel about him, but what I remember of him is good times.”
Shawn gave some good advice. She said, “You have to wait until your time has come, because if you rush out and try to leave because you didn’t have a good childhood, you won’t have a good adulthood. you’d be too full of hostility and looking for someone else to take it out on.”
In any case, as the song says, “don’t Believe The Hype.” For all you teens with stepparents, all I can say is examine yourself. Make sure you are not judging your stepparent because you think they are trying to replace your real parent.
If this isn’t the case, just hang in there and be patient. Maybe things will get better between you and a stepparent if you both try to see the other’s point of view.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.