Courtni Webb, a 17-year-old high school student in San Francisco, was deeply affected by the Sandy Hook Elementary School massacre in Connecticut last December and tried to understand shooter Adam Lanza’s emotions in a poem she wrote in a personal notebook.
She wrote, “They wanna hold me back/I run but they still attack/ My innocence, I won’t get back/I use to smile/ They took my kindness for weakness/The silence the world will never get/I understand the killing in Connecticut/I know why he pulled the trigger/the Government is a shame/Society never wants to take the blame/Society puts these thoughts in our head/Misery loves company/If I can’t be loved, no one can.”
A teacher found the poem in Webb’s notebook and showed it to the principal. School administrators didn’t see the poem as a means of self-expression about the scarier aspects of life. They saw it as a potential threat to the safety of the school.
Webb was suspended and faced expulsion on the grounds that she was a safety threat to herself and her school community, all for the poem she had written for herself and never intended to share. She told NBC’s Today show, “I didn’t say that I agree with it [Lanza’s act], I said I simply understand it.” She has also said she’s written poems about suicide and sadness in the past. She compares herself to Stephen King, whom she says “writes weird stuff all the time.” But that doesn’t mean she’d commit suicide or a violent act, simply that she wants to explore these aspects of the human experience.
Harsh Punishments
These days, writing something a school deems “weird” can get innocent students in a lot of trouble. In the aftermath of Newtown and other mass shootings, schools are understandably preoccupied with protecting their students’ safety against potential acts of violence. But others say the kind of aggressive disciplinary measures taken against students like Courtni Webb go too far.
Webb’s school takes a “zero tolerance” approach to violence and the threat of violence, which means a violation of any school safety rule can result in a speedy suspension or expulsion. According to Dignity in Schools, a group advocating for alternatives to zero tolerance policies, the practice became widespread following federal legislation in 1984 that required states to expel any student who brought a firearm to school or lose funding. It also means that students face harsher punishments for more minor acts, suspension being the most common punishment used on students for breaking school rules.
Although zero tolerance has been around for decades, the increase in school shootings in recent years has led many schools to intensify the implementation of these policies, widening the range of student behaviors or actions that trigger disciplinary action. Though these policies are made to help protect students, they’vesometimes had the unintended consequence of punishing innocent students.
For example, an article in the Macon, Georgia newspaper The Telegraph described how a high school sophomore posted a Facebook status a few days after the Sandy Hook shooting, promising classmates “a big surprise” the next day in school that was taken as a threat. It turned out that the student actually intended to come to school dressed as Santa for Christmas and hand out candy canes to other students.
After the boy posted the status to Facebook, another student alerted the police. The police searched his house and found no weapons or evidence of a threat, but the next morning at school he was escorted by the police to the principal’s office in front of many students. The student was “gothic” looking, so people concluded he was a threat even though he wasn’t and didn’t even have access to any weapons.
Do Students Have Rights?
As a teenager, reading about these cases enraged me. As a writer, I was particularly affected by Webb’s case. Her teacher shouldn’t have read Webb’s personal poem without permission. Webb wasn’t allowed to meet with school administrators and tell her side of the story. In fact, according to KGO-TV, an ABC affiliate in San Francisco, her mother simply received a letter from the school saying that she would be not be allowed to return due to a perceived threat.
Her right to free speech was violated by her school. How is this OK? The same people that are supposed to be looking out for their students and fostering self-expression, her school administrators, are in this case the very people who suspended her. Even if Webb had been in an impaired mental condition, why would they think that suspending her would help her get better? This environment has got to change if public schools are really going to protect their students and prepare them for success.
In the wake of the Newtown shooting, the National Rifle Association, as well as several members of Congress, have advocated for placing armed security and police officers in public schools to guard against school shootings.
An article by Jason P. Nance published by the Stanford Law Review Online in February stated, “Many states have enacted or proposed legislation to provide additional funds to schools for metal detectors, surveillance cameras, bulletproof glass, locked gates, and law enforcement officers.” Nance wrote, however, that increasing security measures wouldn’t necessarily be effective in preventing violent acts on campus. He believes money is better spent on programs to help students deal with problems in a nonviolent manner.
In January, a coalition of groups-including Dignity in Schools, the Advancement Project, and the Alliance for Educational Justice-released a report warning against placing armed guards and increasing police presence in schools. Advancement Project Co-Director Judith Browne Dianis said, “It’s important to note that police in schools do not necessarily increase safety, nor do they catch early indicators of mental health needs, identify root and underlying causes of violence, or use the resources of law enforcement in an effective way.”
Instead of protecting students against infrequent cases of serious violence, Browne Dianis stated that police in schools more often than not “respond to minor student misbehavior by handcuffing, arresting and criminalizing the young people they were intended to protect.”
So, police in schools, and strict discipline in schools in general, more often target minor, less significant behavior problems than they truly protect students, as was the case with Courtni Webb.
Real Threats?
According to an article published in December 2012 by Frank LoMonte of the Student Press Law Center, though threatening speech is not protected under the First Amendment, the Supreme Court has made clear that speech does not qualified as a threat just because it is “very crude” or “offensive.” According to the article, the two Supreme Court-sanctioned criteria for a threat are something that “can reasonably be understood as serious” and “that the speaker has some realistic capability of carrying out the threat.”
If that’s the case, the teenage boy in Georgia with the “threatening” Facebook status who didn’t have any access to guns or weapons shouldn’t qualify as a real threat. But as Jason Nance described in his article, schools have gradually been given greater leeway in determining what constitutes a threat-a power that can be abused.
Nance stated that at the same time that schools are implementing stronger security measures, courts have been weakening student’s Fourth Amendment rights. The Fourth Amendment guards against random searches and requires a good reason for search warrants to be issued.
But since 1985, school officials haven’t been required to get a warrant. This precedent was set by a Supreme Court case in which searching a girl’s purse for cigarettes and punishing her for marijuana found was deemed reasonable, wrote Nance. Schools no longer must “meet the standard of probable cause, or have an individualized suspicion that a student participated in a wrongdoing before conducting a search.”
This lack of Fourth Amendment protection for students in schools could explain why the school administrators at Webb’s school could read her private notebook without her permission.
Support, Not Suspension
While school safety is important, there are other ways to establish safe schools besides violating student’s rights. Pedro Noguera, an education professor at New York University, conducts research to determine how to create successful schools. He wrote in a 2001 article entitled “Finding Safety Where We Least Expect It: The Role of Social Capital in Preventing School Violence” that in order to establish a safe school, students need to feel that their school is a place where they matter. If students feel as though their schools do not trust them or care about them, they will feel alienated.
Noguera believes that paranoid safety measures make kids scared of teachers and their authority, as opposed to viewing teachers as people who want to help them succeed. If students feel trusted, they are more likely to develop a sense of individual responsibility toward the school community and rise to the trust they are given.
On top of this, Nance argues that schools that prioritize control and order may be depriving students of quality education. If a school is focused on promoting conformity and obedience as opposed to critical thinking and analytical skills, teachers won’t view students as growing learners, but as potential threats.
Building Trust
A position statement by the Interdisciplinary Group on Preventing School and Community Violence concludes that students who feel valued and accepted by teachers and authority figures, as well as by their fellow students, are less likely to commit acts of violence.
The position statement offers ways for schools to prevent such tragedies while resisting the creation of the extreme security measures that alienate students. It emphasizes that programs must be created to support the “social, emotional and behavioral needs of students.”
The statement stresses the necessity of communication, connectedness, and trust within schools so that students feel safe reporting threats or worries about a fellow student’s mental health or behavior. The statement warns against detecting potentially violent students by using a set of “checklists or characteristics,” because this can lead to misidentifying students as threats when they actually are harmless, like Courtni Webb.
In order to create this atmosphere of trust, students must not feel as though reporting a friend will get that friend or the student immediately expelled or suspended. Otherwise, students will not feel comfortable doing so and those who need help will be less likely to receive it.
Research shows that if a student is alienated, he or she is more likely to commit a violent act. So instead of further alienating the student through suspensions, the school should reach out to that student and help them get involved in the school in positive ways.
Lastly, the statement advocates for support for at-risk students. It says that students dealing with “depression, anxiety, bullying, incivility and various forms of conflict” are more likely to commit acts of violence, and must be given support from the school community.
More Effective Approaches
I believe that my school’s system is effective in dealing with disciplinary issues. Each year, we hold elections for students who wish to be our grade representatives in the school-wide Committee on Student Conduct, or CSC. We, as a grade, choose two students who we feel represent our best interests and will defend our rights.
If students break a rule, they will not be disciplined immediately. Instead, the committee will first meet to discuss the best ways to prevent the student from breaking the rules again.
For instance, if a student is accused of cheating and sent to the CSC, their peers on the committee will try to understand the circumstances that might have contributed to the student’s decision to cheat. They can then work with administrators to address those issues. For instance, if a student cheated because they are struggling with a difficult subject, the committee might recommend a peer tutor, or simply help the student to get organized and feel supported by their peers.
Though it is perhaps easier for schools to expel or suspend students for behaviors they deem troubling, it is not always effective or fair. The problem with expelling and suspending students is that these policies do not get to the root of these behavior problems, and will not necessarily prevent students from repeating their actions again. That doesn’t make schools safer, and it doesn’t make for a good education.
Zero Tolerance for Violating Free Speech
Schools need better ways to ensure safety
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.