Youth Must Have a Voice

“Where’s the Youth Voice in the System?”
This was the question asked on the cover of the last issue of Foster Care Youth United, yet it is a question that usually goes unanswered.
On April 2, I attended a forum sponsored by Child Welfare Watch. Child Welfare Watch is a new publication-almost like an adult version of Foster Care Youth United-that looks at problems in the system. I sat in the audience and listened to a panel of foster care “experts” express their views on such topics as family preservation, reunification, and the lives of children living in care.
I wondered how these experts were able to talk about these issues when there was not one youth currently in care or even a former foster youth present on the panel who would have been best qualified to speak on such topics.
No youth participation. No feedback from someone who had been in care or who is presently in care. Who can tell the story best? It seems that when “experts” get together to discuss foster care, youth are left out.
Among the panelists were Dr. Salvador Minuchin, a family therapist, Luis Medina, executive director of the St. Christopher’s-Jennie Clarkson foster care agency, John Courtney from Child Welfare Watch, William Bell from the ACS, Rosa Bruno, a parent who had children in the child welfare system, and Nakea Walker, who had siblings in the system.
Except for Rosa and Nakea, all these were professionals and experts who run the system. They think they have all the insight on how to change the way the system is run. It was nice of them to have Rosa and Nakea on the panel who had family members who had been through the system. But I ask the question again, “What about youth who are in the system?”
Oops! I forgot! We don’t quite know what’s good for us. We are not able to express ourselves like the experts do. Well, the youth living in the system are the best experts about the system, believe it or not.
There is a certain stereotype about youth in care which may contribute to the reason we’re not usually invited to speak on panels like the “experts” do. They think we are incapable of speaking without making angry comments about the system-that we can’t be objective. First of all, why shouldn’t we be angry? The adults may think that we don’t understand how the system works. But think again. We very well understand how the system works-more than you can imagine.
And even though we have a right to be angry with a system that has failed those it was supposed to protect, we are also able to be objective and to offer constructive solutions to problems.
For example, the different writers of this magazine have been able to show their objectivity. Some write about how the system isn’t working, while others urge us to look beyond that dark cloud and see the positive sides of the system. We are also encouraged to take advantage of the opportunities afforded to us within the system.
Why should youth be involved in these panels? Okay, I’ll tell you. We are the ones who know the intimate parts of the system-what life is really like in the foster homes and the group homes. We deal with foster parents and social workers on a day-to-day basis. We can also bring to light events that take place within the system and that have been kept in darkness. We can shed light and perhaps prevent a tragedy.
Okay, so they didn’t invite a youth to participate. Then how about a former foster youth now grown up and well-equipped with knowledge and experience? Like who?
Try Jessica Watson-Crosby of the National Association of Former Foster Children. Jessica was present at this event, yet was not invited to speak on issues pertaining to herself and other foster youth. One of the most qualified speakers present was not on the panel but sitting in the audience.
On April 3, the day after the Child Welfare Watch Panel, I attended an Independent Living conference for youth in foster care at the Hunter College School of Social Work, where about 100 foster youth were present. “Conceive it, Believe it, Achieve it” was the motto of the program.
I spent the day listening to various speakers talk about the importance of respect and support for youth in care. Advice was also given to us by the morning speakers, who talked about moving on in life, gaining independence, and being proud of our individuality. There were also workshops on conflict resolution and legal rights.
My point in telling you about this Independent living conference is that there is a need for more workshops like this one where there is a focus on youth, not just on adults having discussions about us and without us. It is important for us to get involved in programs that have an influence on our lives.
We recently heard about another panel discussion scheduled for April 25, entitled “Child Welfare: Starting From Scratch.” The organizers seemed to forget to invite a very important and distinguished panelist. Who? A child in foster care. Remember folks, without the child, Child Welfare would only be called Welfare and we all know there is a whole different meaning to that word.
Among the distinguished panelists were heads of various agencies, lawyers, the Honorable Roger Green from the New York State Assembly, and other experts. Take a look at the titles represented here. Do you see who’s missing? BINGO! Like I said before, the child in foster care.
Even though our invitation to be on the panel was apparently “lost in the mail,” the end result (after airing our opinions about being left off the panel) was that a space was finally made available for a youth to sit on the panel with all the other “distinguished” panelists.
Say yeah, folks, we have finally graduated! (But we still have a long way to go…)
Gettin’ Involved
Child Welfare Organizing Project: Helping Parents
Do you have a parent, grandparent, relative, or other family member who has children in foster care and needs help in dealing with problems in the system? If so, the Child Welfare Organizing Project (CWOP) can help.
CWOP is an organization that helps biological parents and relatives learn about their rights and work on solving their problems. They hold monthly meetings, and anyone with a child in the system is invited to attend. Call CWOP at 212-694-1866. CWOP recently moved to 3280 Broadway, between 132nd and 133rd Streets, 8th Floor, in Manhattan.
Youth Advocacy Center: Learn to Advocate for Yourself
On April 24th, the Youth Advocacy Center held a graduation ceremony for seven youth in care who successfully completed their 10-week advocacy training program this spring. Twenty-five people attended to congratulate the graduates, who received certificates and stipends. Two past graduates, Mohamed Khan and Danielle Joseph, received the “Andrea Wilson Award for Pioneering Achievements in Advocacy” and savings bonds for their success outside the system. (Andrea Wilson was a supporter of YAC).
Deborah Hayes, associate director of YAC, also thanked the foster care agencies which supported the youth, including Brookwood Child Care, St. Christopher’s-Jennie Clarkson, Little Flower, and the Salvation Army, and announced the creation of a new internship for YAC graduates at the political magazine George.
For information on how to participate in YAC’s programs, call at 212-675-6181.
The Door’s Legal Services Center: Stand Up for Your Legal Rights
Many youth in the system don’t know that they have the right to attend their “service plan” meeting (or UCR), which tells them how the system is supposed to help with school, housing, counseling, getting a Green Card, independent living, and other services.
The Legal Services Center, part of The Door, a youth center in Manhattan, wants to help foster youth learn about their “service plan” meetings. The Center also has a free booklet to help biological parents and children in care learn about their rights.
The Door is also starting a group for foster care youth later this spring, which will work on advocating about problems in foster care. The participants will work with an organizer, and meet regularly with The Door’s lawyers to work on their individual problems as well as for system-wide change.
The Door also provides many other services for youth, ranging from medical, educational and counseling to recreation and food, all without charge.
For more information, call Kim Hawkins at 212-941-9090, ext. 250.
The Triangle Tribe Group: For Gay, Lesbian and Bi-Sexual Youth
Are you a gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgendered, or questioning youth (GLBTQ) living in the system?
If so, join the Triangle Tribe, a support group that offers youth a chance to talk about their feelings of growing up in foster care. The Triangle Tribe also consults with agencies that seek to provide a more affirming environment for GLBTQ youth.
For more information, call Dr. Gary Mallon or Kevin Te Carr at 212-677-7288.
C-Plan Project: A Hotline that Can Help
C-Plan has a hotline you can call for help with problems in the system: 212-669-4955. C-Plan also offers weekly meetings where you can discuss your problems and learn advocacy and organizing skills. Call Jane Golden at 212-669-4106.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.