Who’s more fitting to advise the New York City Department of Youth Services (DYS), an agency that oversees and funds hundreds of youth programs throughout the city, than young people themselves?
This was the goal when DYS officials and Mayor Ed Koch established the Youth Advisory Council, a group of teenagers who render advice on youth related issues and policy, back in 1986.
Today, the YAC consists of 35 youngsters who represent the diverse population of the city. It meets each month at the DYS headquarters in Brooklyn to discuss current problems facing New York City teens, lobby for more youth services, and network with local youth committees and councils.
Teen Pregnancy and Drugs Are Main Focus
The alarming increase in teen pregnancy and the drug plague sweeping the city are the two main issues currently being addressed by the YAC.
In order to effectively deal with these problems, the council formed Drug Issue and Teen Pregnancy committees-two smaller bodies that make recommendations and lobby public officials for changes in city policy.
“On my block, kids my age and under aren’t going to school…They’re selling drugs and working for dealers,” said Veretta Hanshaw, 18, a member of the Drug Issue committee, emphasizing that council members are directly affected by the problems they address.
YAC previously helped organize a statewide speakout on teen pregnancy in 1987 and published a pamphlet on substance abuse.
Most recently, the Teen Pregnancy committee compiled a position paper with seven specific recommendations for policy makers. These suggestions, based on the council’s research as well as data compiled from participants in the speakout, propose better counseling for teen fathers, greater parental communication in issues related to teen sexuality, and more comprehensive sex education on all school levels.
A Link To the Mayor?
The YAC has the power to appoint two full voting members to the New York City Youth Board, the city government’s chief advisory body on youth policy that is accountable to the Mayor.
If this privilege is used wisely, it could be a vital link between young people and Mayor David Dinkins. This largely depends on who is selected by YAC members to represent the council (and all of the city’s young people for that matter).
In the past, the council’s views were forwarded to the Mayor by the Youth Bureau (the former name of DYS). According to several YAC members interviewed, Koch was very supportive of their activities. With the recent change in administrations, however, it is difficult to predict Dinkins’ attitude toward the council and its recommendations.
“He has always been a politician who works with youths. He lets us know that he’s here for us,” observed Corwin Jacobs, 17, vice- president of the YAC, citing Dinkins’ record as a youth advocate. Other members voiced similar confidence in the new Mayor’s commitment to youngsters.
A Part of the Bureaucracy
From its meeting notices on DYS letterhead to the format of its teen pregnancy position papers, the Youth Advisory Council gives the clear impression that it is a part of the bureaucratic city government. This has both advantages and disadvantages.
It is understandable that the council must abide by the systematic formalities of local government, such as proper stationery and letterhead formats. It is also sometimes advantageous to be formal and business oriented when lobbying policy makers, who tend to be more responsive to a group that presents recommendations in a professional manner.
Then what’s wrong with being a part of the bureaucracy?
The council, whose purpose is to give youngsters a voice in the decision-making process, may not be able to recognize certain faults in the system which prevent youth empowerment. This is because the YAC operates within the system that it is intended to advise and, to an extent, oversee.
Fair Membership?
The 35 seats that comprise the advisory council are divided among the five boroughs based on their youth population. The ethnic make-up of the city is also reflected in the YAC.
Seems like a great, democratic council with fair and equal representation for all.
Except for one thing: once you’re selected as a member, you can sit on the council until you are 20 without ever having to go through the competitive selection process again. You are asked to leave before you’re 20 only when you are no longer a New York City resident or if you fail to perform your responsibilities, which include attending the monthly meetings and joining a committee.
This translates into few openings each year for the hundreds of applicants who meet the requirements for joining the YAC (a New York City resident between the ages of 14 and 20). The selection process is carried out by teenagers on the council’s Membership Committee who read and grade the applications (with an adult) and conduct interviews with candidates who have high application scores.
But what if there are two highly qualified applicants from Staten Island-perhaps more qualified than one of the borough’s representatives already on the council-and there is only one opening for Staten Island? Is this a fair system? isn’t the council trying to choose the best possible representation?
Why not have all 35 seats open for re-election each year and have members serve one-year terms? Sure, it will be a lot more work but it will be worth it, since this will ensure that the most qualified teenagers in the city are selected.
What We Really Need
The Youth Advisory Council is a good first step in empowering young people. But there is much more that needs to be done in order for the voices of youngsters to be heard.
What we really need is not a council that gives advice and makes recommendations, but a body of young people that makes decisions affecting the entire youth population in the city. Perhaps a Youth Board comprised entirely of teenagers who are accountable directly to the Mayor and whose ideas are utilized by Dinkins and other city officials responsible for setting youth policy, would be the best approach.
After all, who understands youth issues better than youngsters themselves?
Youth Advisory Council: Too Much a Part of the Bureaucracy?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.