Why People Stutter

I wanted to get a professional perspective on stuttering, so I interviewed Catherine S. Montgomery, executive director of the American Institute for Stuttering in Manhattan.
-Gamal Jones
NYC: What is stuttering?
Catherine S. Montgomery: It’s the result of the vocal cords closing off when you want to talk. The brain signals don’t coordinate properly to get the vocal cords vibrating at exactly the right time. So the vocal cords spasm, sound won’t come out, and people push hard and struggle to make the sounds come out. That’s what most people hear as stuttering.
When the vocal cords are closed or spasming, the human response is to do something to stay alive because your airway is closing off, so you push and squeeze and your breathing gets all thrown off. That’s why so many people who may see you struggling say, “Come on, breathe.”
It’s a disorder that fluctuates. Like asthma, sometimes it’s worse than other times. It can be made worse by things like stress or anxiety.
NYC: When does stuttering usually start?
Montgomery: It usually starts between the ages of 2 and 5.
NYC: Why do people stutter?
Montgomery: It’s inherited, which means it’s passed down through the genes within families. It has to do with some brain signals that don’t signal the speech muscles the right way. It’s really a physical thing.
NYC: Do stutterers have any specific personality traits?
Montgomery: It’s not related to personality. It’s a genetic disorder that affects about 1% of the world’s population. It affects four times as many males as females. It’s not the personality that helps create the stuttering, but [the other way around.] Certain characteristics like being shy or quiet develop as a result of dealing with your stuttering.
NYC: Many stutterers often stutter when they say their names. Why is saying my own name so difficult?
Montgomery: It’s common for stutterers to stutter on specific words, like one’s name, or in specific situations or with particular people. This is the learned aspect of stuttering. In other words, you have trouble saying your name once, so the next time someone asks your name, you remember the trouble. That memory triggers more tension and the difficulty happens again.
NYC: What should someone who stutters do if he knows he’s about to stutter?
Montgomery: Without professional help, the most powerful thing you can do for yourself is to acknowledge your stuttering to your listener. Have an acceptance of your stuttering. Even have a sense of humor about it. I call it self-advertising. Give your listener a heads up: “Hey I stutter sometimes. Hang on, hang in there with me.”
Folks who stutter have spent most of their time trying not to stutter, and trying to hide. I think it’s an awesome concept to think about just being open about it, and people find it so liberating. It’s a natural instinct to look away when you’re in the midst of stuttering. But with eye contact, you keep your listener engaged and you also demonstrate what appears to be more confidence.
NYC: Are there ways to get rid of stuttering?
Montgomery: If we get kids who are 2 to 5 years old, it can be eradicated if the right things are done. We can treat the stuttering before the neurological systems get hard wired. Early intervention is really important in stuttering.
For stutterers who are school age through adult age, it’s not going to be gotten rid of. But people can learn to manage it so it doesn’t rule their lives. And yes, people can learn to speak a heck of a lot more fluently and easily. It’s possible to learn how to coordinate your vocal cords if you work with an experienced therapist.
NYC: How should a non-stutterer communicate with a stutterer?
Montgomery: Communicate in a normal, natural way. Do not fill in words for them-but that’s not a 100% rule either. I’ve had people actually say, “I really like it when people fill in my words for me.” But the majority say, “I don’t like when people do that.” don’t assume you know what that word is going to be. Be a patient listener. Make natural eye contact.
NYC: Is there anything that you would like to add?
Montgomery: Those who stutter are, on average, 14 points higher in IQ than the normal population. Studies have been done that show this, but I don’t know why it’s true.
For more information on stuttering, visit to www.stutteringtreatment.org

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.